Monday, September 20, 2010

Eat, Drink, and be Merry!

Eat, drink, and be merry. This surfaces as a mantra in a book of the Bible, to the Epic of Gilgamesh, and even a Dave Matthews Band song. This idea seems to stem in all these cases from a fear of death or a realization of our mortality and the uncertainties of death.

Qohelet’s seems to formulate this idea after deciding that life is meaningless. In chapter 8 verses 12-14, Qohelet realizes that those who fear God it will be well in the eyes of God. But that is not necessarily the truth for humans. He tells of another vanity of earth: there are righteous people treated like the wicked and wicked people treated like the righteous. This difference between God’s judgements of humans and how humans judge one another causes Qohelet to come to the conclusion that humans should eat, drink, and be merry because this seems like the only logical thing to do.

Qohelet claims that everyone shares the same fate (9:3), the righteous and wicked alike die. Even the hero of an epic poem, Gilgamesh, is almost destroyed by his obsession with this realization after the death of his dear friend. Gilgamesh goes to search for an immortal man and speaks to a tavern keeper on his journey. He tells the keeper of his friend’s death and how he is now afraid of death. The tavern keeper tells him to be happy for “this is the work of mankind.” However, Gilgamesh continues on his journey to find Utamapishtim, the man who became immortal, and when he does he tells him of his plight. The immortal man asks Gilgamesh why he works so hard if nothing lasts forever. Even after this Gilgamesh seems confused and asks himself, “for whom have my hands been toiling?”

Unlike Gilgamesh, the possibly-equally-as-epic Dave Matthews seems to have taken the advice of the Tavern Keeper and of Utamapishtim. Dave Matthews Band’s song, Trippin’ Billies (http://bit.ly/881ey1), refrains “eat, drink, and be merry. For tomorrow we die.”

5 comments:

  1. I think there may be a certain sadness to Qoheleth's "Eat, Drink, and Be Merry" philosophy. Once someone realizes the futility of life, there are only two approaches that one can take: 1) suicide or 2) accept it, move on, and enjoy the futility. When viewed this way, Qoheleth's seemingly optimistic philosophy comes off as less incongruous to his previous gloom and doom.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree. I never thought Qoheleth meant that we should literally eat, drink and be marry. I took it more sarcastically, as this is all your ever gunna get so enjoy it if you can.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lance, I tend to agree with your interpretation of Qoheleth. Unless one enjoys the futility of life- what is there to live for? Is life worth living- just to eat, drink, and be merry?

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's interesting that you said that, for Qoheleth, the most LOGICAL thing to do is to eat, drink and be merry. How is that logical? From injustice and confusion, logic doesn't seem to inherently infer that one should party and enjoy life. That seems to be more of Qoheleth's own way of coping with life, and not something that every "logical" person would do.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Genevieve, I guess I should have been more clear and perhaps "logical" is not the best word to use. I meant that once Qohelet, Gilgamesh, and Dave Matthews realize we all come to the same fate then they can not let this idea overwhelm them. If they became so obsessed with this idea that everything is meaningless then how would they be able to function in daily life? Nothing would matter and so they would have no goal or purpose to live for. It's as thought their only option to be able to live in this now meaningless life is to simply enjoy it. Does that make sense?

    ReplyDelete