Wednesday, October 27, 2010

How Redundant

Job chapters 3-21 consist of Job, Bildad, Eliphaz, and Zophar discussing their viewpoints on why such terrible events are happening to Job. Basically the friends are attempting to convince Job that he has done something wrong and thus he deserves this awful punishment. After reading chapters 22-27 I think the only thing that changed was maybe they raised their voices a little. The friends are pushing the same opinions and Job is still insisting he’s innocent.

Although it’s kind of boring I think the repetition of the arguments shows the strength of Job’s character. It would be easy (and probably natural) to claim innocence at the beginning of an argument in which people are questioning your actions. However, I think the compelling arguments offered by the friends the second time would make many people crack. This seems especially likely since it’s a three against one argument. The fact that Job endures the accusations twice from each friend and still steadfastly clings to his claim shows that Job is a strong man whose beliefs aren’t easily changed by the suggestions of others.

I feel like Job is becoming a little desperate in these chapters. His friends won’t stop heckling him and the god who did this to him won’t even answer his questions. I feel sad for Job and I wish for his sake that God would have appeared after the first round of arguments to explain himself. I also feel similarly desperate to find the truth about what is really going on in the book. I think the fact that God hasn’t shown up maybe says something about how he feels about the situation. I get the feeling that God might be trying to avoid Job and the situation he created because he realizes it might have been too much. I suppose it’s also possible that God is so arrogant and sure of his actions that he didn’t feel the need to explain himself to his own creation. If the first is true, Job’s God has similar characteristics to humans and that isn’t very awe-inspiring. If the latter is the case, God doesn’t seem very approachable or loving. It’s impossible to understand exactly how God felt about what he did to Job. It’s also impossible to know if Job was truly righteous or if he was guilty of some punishment-deserving deed. These impossibilities make it frustrating to read the text because we can never know the truth. Although I don’t usually welcome frustration, I think it might provide a way for readers to feel just a touch of what Job felt during his misery.

4 comments:

  1. I agree that these arguments tend to be a little repetitive and it seems like the friends are trying to wear Job down. Job, to his credit, mostly stays firm but does seem to get more emotional and desperate as the dialogues go on.

    I found what you said about God to be interesting. I always assumed that God just didn't feel like he needed to explain himself to Job but I like the idea of God being ashamed about what he has done to Job. I think that there is evidence for God maybe feeling that way in the 2nd chapter of Job when he starts to ask Satan why he persuaded him to test Job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you, in that the repetition of the friends arguments reveals how strong Job is. Even if it might be more beneficial for Job to just say he was wrong, the fact that he holds on to his innocence through two rounds of his friends disagreeing with him says something about his strength. I also really wonder why God couldn’t have shown up a little earlier? I can’t think of a satisfactory reason to why he didn’t come earlier that wouldn’t just make me feel like God was a big jerk.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also agree with you about the repetition in the friends showing how strong Job is. I also like your last sentence about welcoming frustration to help understand what Job is going through. I think it is a great way to describe Job in this instance and it helps me to understand this by putting myself in Job's shoes. I admire Job for how strong he is through his friends arguments.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I didn't really think about what you said, how this shows the strength of Job's character. On one hand, it does show some strength that he doesn't just give up and give in to their arguments. But on the other hand, it's like he tries to sound more and more pitiful as the story goes on. At some points it almost seems like he isn't even arguing with them anymore, he's just complaining (in 23:1 he even uses the word "complaint"...not that he doesn't have a reason to complain)...but that very well could have just been how it appeared to me.

    ReplyDelete