Monday, November 1, 2010

The Trial of God

The Trial of God by Ellie Wiesel reminded me a lot of the film God on Trial. In the text, three men arrive at an inn in the Ukraine on the eve of Purim. They ask the innkeeper if they can perform a play in exchange for food and water. The innkeeper tells them they can perform the play as long as it a trial of God. This trial of God is commissioned because of a pogrom that occurred a year earlier in the town. They decide that the innkeeper will be the prosecutor, and later in the story, a stranger shows up to play the “defense attorney.” The story ends with the abandonment of the trial, due to the need for the men to defend themselves against a mob. There is no final verdict, and the story concludes with Mendel saying that the “ The verdict will be announced by someone else, at a later sate. For the trial will continue without us.”

There are several parallels between The Trial of God and the book of Job. In Job 2:3, God says that Job’s suffering is “for no reason.” In The Trial of God, it is evident that they cannot see why they are being forced to suffer. It is hard for these Jews and Job (and the Jews in God on Trial) to come to terms with the fact that God is causing (or if not causing then allowing) them to suffer for what appears to be no reason.

Another parallel between the book of Job and The Trial of God is that they both contain people who suggest that those who are suffering have done something wrong. In the book of Job it is Job’s friends who suggest that Job must have cursed God , because God is just and does not punish the righteous. In The Trial of God, it is Sam who suggests that all is suffering is “because of our sins”( p.125). The people in both of these texts and the film cannot seem to reconcile suffering with a just God. Unfortunately, after reading both of these texts and the seeing this film, I have a feeling that the question of suffering is one which will never be able to answer.

1 comment:

  1. I agree with the parallels you found between Job and Trial on God. The "you must have done something wrong in order to be punished" was a major theme that I found throughout both stories.

    ReplyDelete