The Cohen Brother' film A Serious Man, tells the story of Larry Gopnik, a middle aged, Jewish professor of physics dealing with some extremely bad circumstances. In the film Larry’s wife Judith leaves him for another man, his son smokes pot, his daughter steals money from him, a Korean student tries to bribe him for a grade, and his brother Arthur refuses to come out of the bathroom and repeatedly breaks the law. In response to all of the turmoil in his life, a friend suggests that he go see the rabbi in hopes that he can provide Larry with some answers as to why his life seems to have gone off the deep end. Along with her suggestion to see the rabbi, she reminds Larry that their Jewish heritage provides them with several stories of people who experienced the same kinds of suffering that he has, and that he should glean wisdom from the Torah. In this instance, she reminded me a lot of the friends in the book of Job, because she relied on the knowledge that she had been taught in the past. According to her (and Larry’s) tradition, when trouble comes it is important to seek wisdom in the scriptures and from the rabbi. Up until this point, I have not had a whole lot of sympathy for Job’s friends, but the portrayal of this woman in the Cohen brother’s film, made me view them as more caring individuals, than I had previously thought.
Unfortunately, traditional wisdom does not seem to work for Larry. The rabbis are unable to provide him with answers to his questions. Fortunately, he is granted tenure and after his son’s Bar Mitzvah things seem to get better for a little while, that is until he gets a call from his doctor and a tornado approaches the Hebrew school. It is with these things that the film concludes leaving the audience with no answers as to what has occurred in Larry Gopnik’s life. The film’s ending offers what is perhaps the greatest parallel to the book of Job within the film. Just as God does not give Job the answers that he seeks, the Cohen brothers do not provide us (or Larry) with the answers as to what happens in the life of Larry.
Earlier in the film, the friend who suggested that Larry go see the rabbi said, “It’s not always easy trying to figure out what God is trying to tell you, but that doesn’t mean you have to try to figure it out by yourself.” While I don’t think that the book of Job (or Larry) necessarily comes to the same conclusion as the friend, I do think that this perspective resembles something that Qoheleth would say. God may not always give us the answers that we wish he would, but it is much better to try to engage in dialogue with others about such questions, than to go at it alone.
Kate, I also found the ending of A Serious Man to be one of the most interesting parts of the film. I agree with you that the greatest parallel between this movie and the book of Job is ending of the film. Just as Job wants answers and doesn't get them, we also don't get answers to the problems in Larry's life.
ReplyDelete