Thursday, November 18, 2010

"Why Me?"

A Serious Man, directed by Ethan and Joel Coen, depicts a man's struggle through life and his journey to understand his suffering and the question “Why Me?”

The audience first meet’s Larry Gopnick as a Physics professors who faces a moral dilemma of whether or not to change a foreign exchange student’s grade from failing to passing. The student, Clive, is very adamant on professor Gopnick changing his midterm grade so he does not lose his scholarship but professor Gopnick refuses. When Clive leaves his office, Larry realizes that he has left behind a large sum of money which is meant to bribe Larry to change the grade. This is when Larry’s life begins to fall apart. When Larry arrives home from work, He learns that his wife, Judith, is leaving him for his best friend, Sy Ableman. He is given no answers as to how or why this happened and is left in a state of shock. As he deals with this, the audience is given a look into the rest of Larry’s life. His two children, Danny and Sarah, are two teenagers who are a complete mystery to their father. Danny is a young teenager preparing for his Bar-Mitzvah who steals from his sister to buy pot and Sarah is the older sister who steals from her father to save up for a nose job. Larry has no connections with his children and suddenly loses connection with his wife as well.

When Larry meets with his divorce attorney, he explains all of the suffering that he is facing at the time. The attorney suggests that Larry should meet with the Rabbi to find some clarity in his life. After meeting with two Rabbi’s and finding no answers, Larry is told he needs to meet with Rabbi Marshak because he has all of the answers. The problem with this is Rabbi Marshak does not do pastoral care. He only meets with students directly after their Bar-Mitzvah so Larry is not able to meet with him, leaving Larry with no answers.

At the end of the film, Danny’s Bar-Mitzvah brings the whole family together. Although Danny is high, it is a moment that seems to bring peace to Larry’s life. Ironically, after the Bar-Mitzvah, Danny is able to meet with Rabbi Marshak instead of Larry. The film ends with scene changes from Danny at Hebrew School and Larry at work. At Danny’s school, a tornado warning is underway and all of the students seek to find cover. While this is happening, we see Larry give in and change Clive’s grade to passing as he receives a phone call from his doctor. The doctor asks Larry if he can come in immediately to discuss some X-Ray’s that he had taken at the beginning of the film. The film suddenly ends with a shot of the tornado coming quickly towards Danny’s school as the students watch. The audience is left with no answers as to what happened to Larry. Was he dyeing? Did he die anyways because of the tornado?

A Serious Man reminded me a lot of the Book of Job. Like Larry Gopnick, Job searches for the answer to “Why Me?” through his three friends, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. At the beginning of the book, the reader learns that Job has lost all of his possessions and his family (1:13-20). Although Job does not find the answers he is looking for through his friends, they are still interested in his suffering and want to help him, unlike the Rabbi’s that Larry meets with and Larry’s family who seems to have no interest in his suffering. Both men believe they have been righteous and have not committed any type of great sin that deserves the suffering they have gone through, although neither is given the answers to the question “Why Me?” I think the Book of Job is more satisfying in the end because the reader learns that Job is given everything that he lost in the end and Job lives a fulfilling life because of this. A Serious Man was more frustrating because the audience is left with no answers about the film and Larry Gopnick’s life.

1 comment:

  1. I think that this film is supposed to do more than remind you of Job. There are some direct parallels between the two works that are supposed to create a connection between them. Most notably, the whirlwind is a direct lift from Job. The Coen brothers, who were raised in a Jewish community, would have a familiarity with the story that would inform this film and make it more than just similar to the book of Job, but directly influenced by it.

    ReplyDelete