Wednesday, November 10, 2010

"The Lord Speaks" Job 38:1-42:6

In this passage God flips out at Job. God's statements are a series of questions aimed at Job realizing that he is nothing compared to the Lord. The one major disappointment in what God says is that he never actually answers Job's questions. Job does not get an explanation as to why he has been punished by the Lord, and he back's down. I am disappointed in both God and Job in this passage. I think God should have answered Job's questions and Job should not have backed down.

I do, however, like the way that Wilson describes God's apparent rebukes. God is not rebuking Job. The bombardment of questions is the only way that the author knows to separate the Greatness that is God from humanity. God only wants Job to understand that God is so much more then Job. (Wilson 420-421) This makes a little more sense to me as to why God sounds so antagonistic towards Job. Job does not get an answer from God because he would not have understood the answer. The logic of God is too big for any human to understand so Job simply must accept that God is God and Job is not. This interpretation does seem to go back on what we have been saying which is that Job is changing his world view for the better. Job has to back off and stop asking questions because God has come down to earth "like and asteroid, and Job is squished." (O'Conner 172) Job seems to have fallen back into the more traditional worldview, wherein God is always right even if we do not understand why he is right. I do not really like this. I think Job really grew a lot and now has been forced to take the view of his friends who are later severely rebuked by God.

All in all I think that God is a bully in this passage. He does not really give Job an answer and simply yells until he gets his way, much like a spoiled child.

5 comments:

  1. I like what you said about God being a bully. It sounds funny but it really seems to be true in this passage. God makes Job feel small in comparison to himself and rebukes Job, though he still never tells Job what he did wrong. Job, to me, seems to simply be afraid of God and unable to question or argue with God. It almost seems like an abusive relationship to me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your reference to Wilson, "God only wants Job to understand that God is so much more then Job," also makes me think of the way Job has been almost patronizing God. God is unpredictable and does not operate by what Job considers fair treatment and so Job treats him as though he is intellectually inferior and somewhat blind. Wilson's remark may mean that God wants Job to see that not everything is as simple and pure as he thought, and that a relationship with God is not something to take for granted.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Like you, I was frustrated with the lack of an answer to Job's question as to why he is suffering. I think that O'Conner provided a very nice commentary on the whirlwind speeches, but I don't feel like she was able to answer the question of why Job is suffering. This lack of answer in the text & lack of commentary on the matter, seem to suggest that we aren't supposed to know why suffering exists in the world. Unfortunately, after studying a text for several weeks it is frustrating that the conclusion seems to be that there are no concrete answers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I would like to examine the implications of Wilson's claim "God only wants Job to understand that God is much more than Job." Even if I do accept that this was God's purpose, I still do not think any more highly of God. I do think that humility is a good thing, however is it EVER okay to kill children, animals, and inflict harm on a person's body to get your point across? I say no. So, Job's a little cocky, at least he's not a murderer. My point is that God cannot be exempt from morality, and saying that Job's suffering (and the deaths of numerous others) justifies some greater goal/plan is exempting God from morality. There is a big hole in Wilson's point.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with the frustration that occurs in this passage. Why couldn't God just give Job a concrete answer? Like Kate says, It is frustrating to know that we have been waiting the past few weeks to find out about Job's suffering but really there isn't a concrete answer..but what it new?

    ReplyDelete