In the first part of “A Serious Man” the Jewish wife says, “Blessed is the Lord. Good riddance to evil” as she shuts the door on the “dybbuk”. Her words create a clear line between God and evil, as she believes that one cannot be a part of the other, which would mean God is all good and evil is evil. The main character in the film, Larry Gopnik, seems to have the same idea about life. Larry sees life in black and white, he is Physics professor but only understands the straight-forward math, not the stories he uses for explanations, he even states while talking to a student that, “Actions always have consequences”. This view doesn’t really hold up as Larry’s life begins to unravel, he starts wondering why these things have happened to him and searching for some answers.
First Larry’s wife tells him she wants a divorce, his children are little monsters, and his life gets pretty chaotic. Along with these things he has to deal with his wife’s other partner dying in a car wreck, and his live-in brother getting in trouble with the law and he might not be getting tenure like he thought he was going to. As a response to the turmoil Larry just keeps repeating, “I didn’t do anything”. Throughout the movie, as things fall apart for Larry, he tries to find reasons why these things are happening to him and what he should do about them. He starts talking with his rabbis-much like Jobs friends giving him advice-but never gets an answer he is satisfied with. The first rabbi that Larry speaks with is the junior rabbi, he is young and tells Larry “all his problems are just a mirror”, the mid-level rabbi tells him some story about a dentist finding a message in a man’s teeth…this doesn’t really make any sense to Larry either. As a last resort Larry tries his hardest to speak with the head rabbi, but the rabbi is always “busy”. He never gets to speak with this rabbi, but his son does. When Larry’s son meets with the rabbi, the rabbi hands him back his radio that was confiscated in class. Like the “Jefferson Airplane” song that was playing on the little radio, the rabbi says, “when the truth is found to be lies and all of the hope within you dies…then what”?
One of the themes of this movie, I think, is the uncertain line between “good” and “evil” and how to apply this to your life. Larry has a hard time figuring out the right or good things to do in his life once it starts to crumble. He keeps saying he hasn’t done anything, probably meaning anything bad, and he feels like all of these things are happening as no fault of his own. He tries to find the answers through his faith and still comes up short. This blurred line between good and evil can also be seen through the behavior of this whole Jewish community. These seemingly devout Jews act in a way that “good” Jews probably shouldn’t, but this doesn’t necessarily make them bad people. As the movie progresses I think we see the characters start making decisions based on what they feel is right or good, and not based on some higher power such as God, because he obviously is going to do whatever the hell he wants to.
I like your interpretation of the beginning. I was so confused by it that I had almost convinced myself that it wasn't supposed to be a part of the film. Maybe like the prose isn't supposed to be a part of the dialogue in Job? Any way, I like how you point out that the wife thinks that good and evil are fully separated. However, I think that someone could interpret her assumption as wrong just by watching the first scene. She does stab a man and he is seemingly going to die as a result. She is supposed to be good and he is supposed to bad, yet she is the one doing the killing, presumably in the name of goodness. This seems blurry to me, as does the rest of the movie.
ReplyDeleteI like how you mentioned the "actions always have consequences" belief in the movie. As I was watching the movie, I started thinking that maybe actions do always have consequences but so does inaction. I think God wants to prevent humans from being complacent by punishing passivity. I guess in this way being passive is an action in and of itself and is therefore subject to punishment...if that makes sense.
ReplyDelete