Monday, November 15, 2010

After all the trouble YHWH had brought upon him...

In the narrative epilogue, YHWH begins by rebuking Job's friends for speaking incorrectly, unlike Job, who apparently had everything right and remained righteous (Job 42:7-9). In his commentary, Janzen points out that each of the four times G-d makes mention of Job's friends, this mention is paired with some form of praise for Job's righteousness (263). G-d's dealing with the friends in this passage does not appear to connect very well to the narrative. It seems that G-d has done what the friends have said he would do, and yet G-d says that they spoke incorrectly. Janzen deals with this by arguing that Job argued that G-d might restore him because he was just, while Job's friends argued that Job would only be restored if he repented of his wrongdoing (263-264). I disagree strongly with Janzen's argument, as Job explicitly "repents in dust and ashes" at the end of he dialogues (Job 42:6). In the same dialogue, in v.3, Job states that he "spoke of things that he did not understand. Job seems to clearly think that he has done/spoken wrong and he has need to repent of it. The dialogue and the narrative in this instance are contradictory.

Another point which Janzen brings out in his commentary is the absence of the satan from the end narrative. Janzen argues that as long as we interpret the figure of the satan as a kind of mouthpiece for G-d's questions about Job's righteousness (as the Persian root word suggests), then the satan's absence is to be expected. This is because there is no longer a question for G-d as to whether or not Job is righteous (262-263).

This interpretation puts the action back in G-d's hands, as does the narrative itself when Job's relatives come together to comfort him "after all the trouble YHWH had brought upon him" (Job 42:11). In his commentary, Janzen notes a connection back to the law of Exodus. G-d gives Job back twice what was taken away. This is the punishment for a thief who is caught (Janzen 267, Exodus 22:4). This makes it seem that G-d is guilty of some wrong in what he has done to Job, far from the claim made by Elihu, "Far be it from G-d to do evil, from the Almighty to do wrong" (Job 34:10b).

1 comment:

  1. Ed, I also disagree with Janzan's argument about why the friends were punished as opposed to Job. In Job 42:6 its clearly states that Job did repent and therefore the friends should not have been punished at all because what they had been telling this whole time became true.

    ReplyDelete