Monday, November 8, 2010

Werd Elihu. Werd

Elihu says in this passage what he believes about God's reasons for tormenting Job. I honestly think this is what most people would assume about a God who is supposed to be completely fair and just, so I can't blame him for assuming that Job has done lots of sinning to merit his suffering (as is insinuated). The interesting part here is that we know that Job is, by most measures, a righteous man indeed and does not deserve what is happening to him. Regardless of whether or not he is pious to the point of self-righteousness, he is not an evil man. Elihu seems to attempt to get Job to shoulder the blame for what is happening when he points out that he has tried to justify himself, but not God.
My own views on why Job has been messed with is that God used him basically as a means to demonstrate that everything is a gift from Him that He can take if he wants to. There really for the most part has been little to no correlation between being evil and suffering and being righteous and having a great life (as seen by Job being punished for seemingly nothing).
What Elihu wants Job to see is that whether or not he thinks what God has done to him is just and fair, God does. So Job should accept that and ask for God's mercy because surely he has done some terrible things.

4 comments:

  1. I fnd it intersting that Elihu seems to be totally unaware of the introductory passage of Job, where God dances with the devil. I wonder if this is evidence that Elihu was added later to the book itself, or the other way around, it evidence that the introduction of the book is un-original. Or perhaps the unexpected entry into Job of Elihu's youthful faith in a just God is simply another perspective that the author felt was important.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I found your view on why Job is "being messed with" interesting and I agree that perhaps it is God trying to teach a lesson, saying that everything is a gift and that gift can be taken away at any moment. I wonder, if this is the case, why God chose Job. I also agree with your translation of how Elihu responds to Job's problems.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I tend to agree with your thoughts about how God is portrayed in Job. God seems to be in charge of the universe and he uses Job as a means of communicating that He can do whatever he wants without good reason. However, I disagree with your statement that "surely He has done some terrible things." To me the text does not seem to suggest that Job has done terrible things. I suppose if he has cursed God that would certainly be terrible, however, I don't think there is enough textual evidence to make such a claim.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that maybe God is just trying to teach the lesson that everything is a gift. Why would he have chosen Job though? It seems like Job already understood that the great things in his life were from God.

    ReplyDelete