Luckily for Job, whose friends can no longer provide any more naïve and critical advice, a young man suddenly appears on the scene, ready to save the day! It is youthful Elihu, who is so self-conscious of his age in comparison to the maturity of Job's “old” friends that he prolongs his credential justifications for the entire first chapter and continues to defend his authority in matters of wisdom throughout his monologue. He reminds me of rappers who spend at least half of their song telling listeners about how rich they are, how tight their lyrics are, and how much better they are than all the other rappers, before they get around to actually making a point. I was dismayed reading Elihu's chapter: does Elihu actually have novice, constructive advice for Job, or is it just a soliloquy of a self-proclaimed child prodigy?
Whatever his personal motives, Elihu does recognize one true thing about Job, which is that his friends did not provide any real help, that “there was in fact no one that confuted Job, no one among you [the friends] that answered his words” (32:12). If the reader similarly felt that the words of Job's friends were devoid of truth, Elihu may at first glance appear to be the voice of reason and console that Job needs. But, is the little bit of wisdom Elihu manages to extrapolate from his qualifications any more helpful than that of the friends?
Like Job's other friends, Elihu believes that Job must have sinned and is now receiving punishment from God. Wilson's NIV commentary depicts Job as “a sinner in need of confession,”(378) in the eyes of Elihu. This consolation does not sound much better than that of the friends, and must have sounded even worse to Job, when he was told that he wasn't even receiving the punishment he deserved. Of course Job didn't think he deserved the horrific punishment he was receiving from God, but Elihu went in another direction, claiming that Job should have been punished even more! Only by God's great mercy was Job's soul spared from “going down to the Pit”(33:28). Elihu chastises Job for not having faith in God's unfailing justice and for daring to question God's ultimate authority and judgment. Elihu portrays God as a being who is impeccable, incapable of mistakes, and ultimately out-of-bounds for questioning by humans, especially to those as self-righteous as Job. This may be consolation to Job if he is able to see his suffering as constructive, but that point of view is dubious in the face of Job's stark confusion.
Your depiction of Elihu was humorous. I guess that i viewed Elihu in the light but never put into those words. I have to agree with you, Elihu kind of comes off as arrogant. I honestly don't see the reason for him to speak. He is in agreement with and only repeats what the other friends have said, only after inflating his ego.
ReplyDeleteI did find it refreshing that Elihu brought up the point for Job to be thankful for what he does; small it may be, have left. For instance his life. I have been asking that same question, why doesn't Job see even the slightest bit of thankfulness that God spared his life?
Since you are obviously not fond of Elihu, do you think it is possible that Elihu was added by some later scribe? I think it is possible this was added based on the fact that Elihu just shows up unannounced at the end of the dialogue like he had been there the whole time. If you think this is the case, do you think the words of Elihu should not be read? Do you think Elihu provides an important voice even if it is not a good one?
ReplyDeleteCayce, I like your point about Elihu possibly being added into the text at a later time. That is definitely something that I have been considering and I think your questions are definitely something to consider. Is Elihu's voice important?
ReplyDeleteFirst off, I love the rapper comparison. I feel as though the over boastful nature of Elihu is inconsistent with the book and probably does lend itself to Cayce's idea of him being added later. That would also explain why he hasn't been included with the other dialogue...
ReplyDeleteI liked how Elihu added to be thankful for what Job still has, even though it isn't much. I think this answers Cayce's question that he does provide an important voice.
ReplyDeleteDo you think that Elihu is another example of an old view of wisdom and way of looking at God? He seems to not think that God could do any wrong so he would fit the other friends in that regard. I think Elihu is another example of not having a questioning faith and a way that the reader should not live.
ReplyDelete