When reading Job, I can’t help but notice how wonderfully it contradicts the idea of a belief in a just world. This belief is a topic of psychology that explains people’s desire to believe that people get what they deserve. This belief is at work when people ask questions like “why do bad things happen to good people,” and for this reason I think it is applicable to Job. The most interesting aspect of applying this theory to Job is that not only does the reader possibly have trouble accepting the events that transpire in Job’s life but even Job’s “friends” can’t help but believe that he must have done something to deserve what happens to him. I appreciate the book of Job because it challenges people to realize that no matter what justifications people can come up with for why bad things happen to others, negative experiences are a part of life…and not just for bad people.
I also noticed quite a bit of defensive attribution in Job which I think is, in part, due to the need to preserve a belief in a just world. Defensive attribution is a mechanism by which people make up excuses for why something bad happened to someone else in order to make themselves feel like it wouldn’t happen to them. I think this is what Job’s friends were doing when they insisted that he had done something to deserve the terrible things that were happening to him. Because these men are normal human beings who obviously have a hard time believing that God would do such awful things to someone who doesn’t deserve it, they justify it by finding reasons that will: 1) make the experiences seem just and 2) make it seem like they won’t go through the same experiences.
Overall I think there’s a lot to learn from Job. I don’t think these lessons only involve some kind of heartwarming moral story about having faith in God and the experiences he puts us through. The most important lesson to learn is that God is in control of our lives and no matter what we’ve done or how good we think we are, we might encounter terrible experiences because that’s what God feels we need.
I like your post, especially how you point on the motives of Job's friends in finding fault in Job. I think it is logical that this could be so that they can justify that suffering will not come to them. I do disagree slightly when you say "we might encounter terrible experiences because that's what God feels we need." This isn't really supported by the text, or at least I don't see it. Job was blameless. Look at 1:8, in this verse even God calls Job blameless and a person who "turns away from evil". A close reading of the beginning of Job reveals that God's decision to allow Satan to smite Job is God's response to Satan's suggestion that people only worship God when they are being given good things. God allows Job's suffering because God needs the ego boost and has a need to prove Satan wrong. Basically, Job has a terrible experience because this is what God needs, not what Job needs. In my opinion, this God is very self-centered.
ReplyDelete