This was the saddest section I have read yet for this class. Qohelet's writing was bearable because he so frequently qualified his suffering with a bit of hope of enjoyment in sensual delights, but Job does not even have that option. All of the possibilities that were offered to Qohelet are thwarted by Job's suffering, which covers all options. Job's suffering is so intense, so broad and all-consuming, that he literally cannot physically or emotionally bring himself to alleviate any pain, no matter how terrible.
The reading by Solle, Suffering, provided an example of a factory-worker boy who suffered in a similar way to Job: inescapably. The boy said of his agony, “It often simply cannot be endured...And yet I have to endure it anyway. There is nothing one can do to change it.”(67) Both Job and the boy have been, in a disparaging way, forced to come to terms with their relentless pain, so much so that the only alternative Job wishes for is death. If Job could see Solle's “chart of suffering,” he would see that at that point of his suffering (as well of that of the young boy) he was entering Phase Two of “Powerlessness.” This would mean to Job that, if he lives long enough, if he endures his blood-sucking powerless feeling long enough, he would eventually pass through Phase Two, in which he would accept his powerlessness within the structure God provided for him, and into Phase Three, where he would conquer his powerlessness.
Solle's chart of suffering might have imparted a bit of hope for Job – that his variety of suffering is prone to eventual mitigation, but Job would have had a long way to go before being healed. Before he could be healed, he would have first had to accept his suffering, which generally comes after at least partial understanding of the situation, which Job had definitely not yet achieved. He had no clear answer for his agony: his friends blamed him for sinning, God didn't provide any helpful explanation, and so Job was left in a whirlwind of dark confusion.
The world that God created and which he was said to have cared for felt, to Job, to be a cruel joke. Job mocked God's concern for the tortuous world saying, “What are human beings, that you make so much of them, that you set your mind on them, visit them every morning, test them every moment?” (7:17-18) At this point, Job sees God as a cruel landlord who has nothing better to do than make the lives of his tenants miserable. He cannot yet be healed because the world and it's relationship to God does not make any sense. Job's world was turned upside down by his unexplained suffering, his belief in a just God shattered, and his optimism for relief quickly escapes.
I thought that your comment on Job seeing God as a "cruel landlord" was quite interesting. Job does seem to think in this passage that God may not be just and that he isn't given a reason for his suffering. It is interesting that despite these thoughts Job still refuses to curse God.
ReplyDeleteI found the poem by Vallejo echoed some of Job's sentiments toward the all-encompassing nature of his suffering. Did you have any thoughts on this poem?
I really liked your point on how Job has a long way to go before he can reach Solle's second phase of suffering. I also felt that the only way that Job could start to move on would be to accept the position he is in, however Job obviously will not be doing that anytime soon because Job feels as if he has no explanation for his suffering.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your blog post and agree with a lot of the things that you said. In your last couple of sentences you say that Job cannot be healed because, " the world and it's relationship to God doesn't make any sense." This is the main idea that I get out of Tuesday's passage. I think it would be interesting to see as we move through the text, whether or not we think the world and it's relationship to God starts to make sense. I would venture to say that it doesn't, but I'm not too sure.
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you incorporated Solle's chart of suffering into the book of Job. I didn't think to categorize Job's suffering with Solle's. I agree, Job is definitley in phase two (Maggie, i disagree with you, i think he already in phase two), he clearly is speaking is aware of his situation, and is expressively lamenting. I also agree that its going to be a hard road to travel to get to phase three. When do you think Job reaches phase three (when God confronts him?)? Does Job ever reach it? i think my questions go along with kate's, does Job really think in the end that the relationship between God and humans makes sense?
ReplyDeleteI agree completely that Qoheleth is in phase two. I really enjoyed your post today Genevieve and the way you compared and contrasted the boy to Job. I thought the same way after first reading it. But I agree Qoheleth has nothing on Job.
ReplyDelete