The film God on Trial tells the story of a group of men at Auschwitz--some of whom were selected to go to the gas chamber the next morning--who decide to try God for breech of contract. Some of these men argue that God has broken his covenant with Israel and that their present situation shows that God has abandoned them. Others argue that this may be a time of purification for the Jews and that God must be allowing this to happen to them for a reason. The issues in this film are complex and bring up many questions about the nature and mind of God.
One of the issues that these men deal with in the film is the idea of God punishing children for the sins of the father. These men do not believe that they deserve what is happening to them or that they have broken their covenant with God but, given the possibility that they were not, in fact, good men, they do not understand why God chooses to punish children. The film brings up scriptural examples of God killing the firstborn of Egypt because of Pharoah's unwillingness to grant the Israelites freedom and of God killing the child of David and Bathsheba for their indiscretions. The men also discuss their experiences with this. One man tells the poignant story of how he was made to choose between his three sons. At the end of the film, one of the older men sees his son selected to go to the gas chamber instead of him. These men, unlike David or Pharoah, do not see how they have sinned and do not see the justice in the suffering of thier children even if they have, in some way, caused God to turn from them.
I find that this issue in particular--of allowing the father to live and killing the son--is reflected in the book of Job. The first way that God tests Job is by killing his children. In the end God restores Job by giving him new children. The taking of children as means of punishment or trial seems to be a common scriptural theme and is a great part of Job's suffering. To the men in the film God on Trial and to Job, the suffering caused by losing their children is likely greater than the thought of their own suffering and death and brings up questions of the justness of a God that would allow the innocent to be punished in that way.
I really enjoyed your comments about the use of children in the movie and in the book of Job. One of the ways that people truly suffer is when they see children getting hurt or being killed. And in Job just like in the movie the innocent children have to die while the men continue to suffer causing the men in the movie and Job to question God.
ReplyDeleteIn the movie I thought it was very interesting when one man brought up the violent nature of God. Later when the physics professor was trying to discredit God through reason, the scholar asked where reason was in a world run by madness. When trying to explain evil many of the men brought up free will. In Job we see that even though Job has done nothing wrong (if you include the prologue) God allows Job and his children to be punished. This makes God look violent and unreasonable. Job has free will for how he would react to this, but the people in God on Trial might say "what kind of choice is that?"
ReplyDeleteMelody, I really like how you compared the use of children in this movie and in the book of Job. I also find it interesting how the question of the justness of God is brought up in the film. You mention how would a just God allow innocent children to die over the father's but i see God making the father suffer rather than die just as well. Yes, the children die which is not just but it is just to make the father suffer. This makes me think of the question, What exactly does a Just God look like?
ReplyDeleteI also really like the your comparison of children in the movie and the book of Job. I feel like there is something to be said about the manner in which God treats children in Job. It almost seems as though children are regarded as material possessions to be taken and replaced at will, but the movie definitely disagrees with that.
ReplyDeleteWhat about humans as children of God? I'm not sure whether that is a New Testament or a Hebrew sentiment, but it would be an interesting addition to your (good) explanation of the issue of father and child. If God does have the same kind of concern for us as our human parents feel, then we would be better equipped to argue on his side; that, since he feels the same torment from watching us suffer, he must not desire us (the Holocaust victims) to receive such a painful infliction...unless maybe it is to ward off even more potential pain in the future. But either way, he doesn't enjoy it.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the way you incorporate the children being killed and tortured and it causing the parents to question god. I didn't make that connection until I read your blog. This was a very sad movie but I enjoyed your post.
ReplyDeleteI second what Todd said about the children in Job seeming like material possessions. The movie and the book of Job also have the X+Y=Z idea in common as well..."I didn't do anything wrong, so why are my children/I being punished?"
ReplyDelete