Monday, October 25, 2010

I Want My Weakling God

If God is mighty, if God is omniscient, if God is all powerful and totally just, then why couldn’t he stop the Holocaust or simply prevent it from ever happening? A God who is capable of stopping suffering and chooses not to is a bastard, which seems to be the conclusion that the Auschwitz prisoners come to in the PBS documentary ‘God on Trial’. It is interesting that these prisoners really wrestle with their concepts of God during the trial. They seem to be circling around two options: God is a powerful bastard who “was not ever good, he was only on our side” or God is not actually powerful, but instead God is personal, God is suffering in Auschwitz, God is being gassed with us. The men seem to mentally settle on the former option when they charge God with murder, when they decide that he is indeed guilty. However, it is not so easy to know what option they choose in their hearts. One man says, “Now God is guilty. What do we do now? Now we pray.” There is something comforting in praying to God; there is something comforting in feeling that God suffers and that God cares.

Job also suffered in the same manner that the Auschwitz prisoners suffered: his children were taken from him and killed, his possessions were destroyed, his body was broken. In the midst of his suffering, Job also called God a bastard, in quite a few more words. Job wondered if maybe God wasn’t fair, but Job still wanted God to be with him in his heart. Even while calling God a bastard, Job still wanted the bastard. This could be why the prose tells readers, “In all of this Job did not sin or charge God with wrongdoing.” (1:22). Maybe Job questioned God, but on the other hand, he still wanted this God to suffer with him, he didn’t really want God to be a bastard, even as mentally he couldn’t deny that he might very well be.

The Holocaust victims are an extreme case of what Job is going through. They allow us to see that even while men call God a bastard, they will still pray to him. ‘God on Trial’ actually helps me feel more sympathetic towards Job. Job is not whiny and Job is not some hotheaded jerk who simply wants to argue his point with his friends. Job is a man in pain. His life experience suggests that the God he needs is either a bastard or a weakling. Job’s worldview is shifting and if God wouldn’t have come back in his whirlwind, the book of Job would have probably ended with Job realizing that “God is [his] God, even if he doesn’t exist.”

2 comments:

  1. So does God have to exist? if God is not doing anything and "god is god, even if he does not exist" why still pray? I find it very interesting that even after the men found god guilty of breach of contract they still prayed to him. That kind of unending faith is what you need in the face of great sorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that mighty, powerful God doesn't have to exist. The Holocaust victims and Job only found anger, not comfort, in the face of suffering with the concept of the mighty God. Job didn't have the chance to realize that maybe God is not something that can fight all of you're suffering battles for you, and that God is around for another reason. However, since God didn't show up in a whirlwind in Auschwitz, the victims were able to realize that a concept of God with us or God being gassed with us actually brings comfort during suffering. It seems that this God is the God that can actually help. You are right, I think that people need an unending faith that something "more" is with them in the face of suffering. I'm not sure it really needs to be called God.

    ReplyDelete