During today's reading, we read about the conversation's between Job and his friend's fighting over whether or not Job really deserved the suffering he was going through. All but Job believed that your actions determine the suffering that you undergo meaning that Job had to have done something terribly wrong.
Eliphaz starts off the passage accusing Job of folly, implying that maybe Job just considered himself more righteous than he actually was. Eliphaz seemed to mock Job like, "ha ha, you suck, I'm more righteous than you." Job starts arguing back, that basically his friends are not there for him and that they don't understand what he is going through, which is true, I'm sure that God never placed a bet on their lives as he did Job's. Not cool God. I agree in a way with Job that his friend's should comfort him more when he is going through the worst of times and not attack his faith and beliefs, but at the same time they should add a little bit of criticism in there for how Job is basically questioning his faith and on the pursuit of cursing God's name. Job thinks this is God just adding to his suffering as he explains in chapters 16 and 17, "They gape at me with their mouth, They strike me reproachfully on the cheek, They gather together against me. Had has delivered me to the ungodly, and turned me over to the hands of the wicked." (Job 16:10-11) As far I'm concerned that's the closest you can get to cursing God without actually cursing him, which is what God was betting Satan Job wouldn't do.
Even during the Prayer for Job's Relief he was cursing his friends saying that they are "mockers" and he is getting ready to face death but they still bother and make him more miserable than God has already made him. Bilidad then steps in and tells Job that only the wicked are to be punished so obviously Job is a wicked man who has commit ed many sins even if he had not realized he was committing them. Bilidad is also pretty angry that Job is arguing with the friends as shown in chapter 18:2-3, where Bilidad basically says Job shut up, listen to me because I'm much smarter and don't call me stupid and goes on to tell Job how"wicked" he really is for he isn't praising God at this point in time. Job still believes that God is the almighty but that Job is such a small aspect in God's life that he doesn't want God's attention because God has ruthless powers and Job is tired of being punished, yet he still wants to see God in the after life. The argument over Job's "wickedness" continues on to Zophar who know gives a sermon over the meaning of being a wicked man and what happens to those who are wicked, well basically "everything under the sun" can happen to a wicked man.
Poor Job, had my friend's talked to me like that in a time of need, I probably would lay there and wait for death as well. Job's friend's are supposed to help reaffirm Job's faith, instead they are driving him farther from God. Perhaps that is why God punishes and sends them away at the end of the story.
Although it would clearly suck to be in Job's shoes, and feel utterly alone in your suffering, I think you should also consider how you would act if you were one of the friends...Job is challenging their entire worldview, a worldview which he too held confidently prior to his suffering. Haven't you ever been with a group of friends, and on some specific topic the whole group disagrees with the opinion of one person? Well, Job didn't just disagree with his friends on a small topic, he disagreed with their fundamental understanding of the topic of life in general! Sure they could have been sympathetic to a degree, and heard him out with a more open mind. But i'd say its human nature to so easily gang up against a person who challenges the dominant belief of a group.
ReplyDeleteI didn't think of that at first, but you make a valid point.
ReplyDeleteBig Daddy Z, I was thinking along the same lines. It seems that the friends and Job are seeing life through totally different paradigms. The friends see God as totally good, and therefore anything that happens in the world that is bad must be the result of humans. Job has reason to not see God as totally good, actually he speaks of God as someone who "slashes open my kidneys, and shows no mercy" (16:13). I don't think Job sees God as totally evil, but for him the possibility does exist that something besides humanity can cause harm in the world. It's important to realize that Job and his friends are seeing the world through totally different pairs of "glasses". It's not only Job's friends who are unwilling to trade "glasses" and see the world in another light, Job does not see the friends point of view either.
ReplyDeleteYour interpretation of why the friends might be punished at the end of the story is really interesting. That's definitely something to think about. Good post!
ReplyDelete"""Job's friend's are supposed to help reaffirm Job's faith, instead they are driving him farther from God. Perhaps that is why God punishes and sends them away at the end of the story."""
ReplyDeleteI liked this, very interesting, because it seems almost contradictory. But that makes sense. Maybe asking all these questions and examining relentlessly is *more* conducive to ultimately understanding (as well as a human can) or accepting the will of the Creator. Maybe the blind shutting down of questions and sticking to the "party line" (the old actions => consequences paradigm) like Job's friends is actually the less faithful approach. Maybe that's the place of... well, of skeptics in scripture!
Maybe.
Anyway with that said, I agree with Z. It's very much human nature to strongly resist attacking a system that has been the very basis for your life and prosperity. Imagine...
JOB: Guys, I can't get a job. I'm unemployed and my whole family has starved to death. Even though I was the most righteous college student. I got my B.A., I made a perfect GPA, I had very marketable and useful skills, and I worked hard for my employer. But circumstances outside of my control ruined it all.
ELIPHAZ: You sure about that? Those who study and work hard are rewarded, and it is the lazy and wicked who perish. Maybe you weren't such a hard worker after all.