Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Rants, Complaints, and Prosperity.

The book of Job was disconcerting, disorienting, and long-winded. I am only familiar with the first couple chapters of Job, and never realized how much lay beyond Job’s tests.

The first thing I noticed about the book of Job was how much of a dialogue it is, not between Job and God, but between Job, other men, and God. On Job’s end, he goes on and on with a never-ending rant about God, what has happened to him, and why him, continuously saying he just wants a chance to make his case to God (yet he never curses God for his misfortunes). The men he is talking with try and subdue him but have no success. Finally, God makes a grand entrance and shoots Job down, pretty much telling him he knows nothing about the universe or the ways of God. Job is instantly quieted and becomes much less whiney.

Another thing I found interesting about the book of Job was the concern Job had with the reactions of the people around him. He was hurt that he was being mocked by people who had once respected him, and brought it up multiple times in his speeches. Job also came off as thoroughly annoyed at the men he was speaking with, who were judging him and chastising him. It was a blow to his authority when Elihu, the youngest of the group, reprimanded him as well, and I felt like the challenging of Job’s words was significant in evoking certain reaction and eventually summoning God.

Finally, I was really thrown off at the end of Job, after God has put Job in his place. He then reprimands the men Job was talking to, telling them Job was saying correct and true words and they were not, and Job was the example they should follow, that God would listen only to Job’s prayer. God then gives Job twice as much fortune as he had before, and brings back all the respect and love Job had before. This is what confused me the most. A happy ending to 40 something chapters of misfortune and complaining? Did the epilogue get added later on in Job too? Or does this just show that if you stay strong, fear God, and restrain yourself from cursing Him for misfortunes in your life you’ll end up more prosperous than before? What kind of God is Job dealing with?

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

God is a Jerk

The Book of Job starts off with God assembling his angels and then noticing that there is one extra. Satan has come to ask God questions and to try to get God to realize that all of his followers would leave Him if God did not give them things. So God allows Satan to make Job's life a living hell to prove that Job would never leave God. When Satan then tests Job, Job refuses to blame God for what has happened to him and only says that he wishes he was never born so that he would not have had to suffer like he has. Next Job's friends show up and ask him what he did wrong and why he is being punished. They continually tell Job to just forsake God so that God will kill him and end his misery, but Job still refuses. Job constantly refuses to blame God for what has happened to him (even though the reader knows that it is God's fault), and stays an upright and God-fearing man. The only thing that Job does is he wants to question God. He asks to see God and be allowed to make a case for why he should not be punished, and for an explanation as to why he has been. I think this is a perfectly reasonable request. We have just seen in Ecclesiastes that questioning is not necessarily a bad thing it simply may lead to you being very depressed all the time because you can't find any decent answers. I have also been taught all my life that if you cannot defend a position against attacks then you should reevaluate your position and find a new position you can defend logically. Yet when God finally does appear and speak to Job all Job gets is a bunch of sarcastic remarks about Job thinking he is better than God. God is the biggest jerk ever! God has just allowed Satan to take everything away from Job and he doesn't even tell Job that it was all only a test. Job gets no explanation for why his entire family has been killed and he still does not blame God for anything. He is a better man then I. Job did get all of his wealth back in the end of the story but his sons and daughters are still dead. He still had to build back that wealth which could not have been a fun activity. I think that Job had every right to be pissed at God and demand an explanation. Now this brings up some larger issues as to how you demand something of an all powerful deity, but I still think Job at least should have asked.

Sorry about the late post

The pursuit of the epilogue (vv. 12:9-14) is to interpret the message of Qohelet. The epilogue speaks in a positive tone regarding Qohelet’s wisdom, though at the same time says too much wisdom can be a bad thing/acquiring wisdom can be a tough process.

The epilogue consists of two verses about Qohelet (vv. 9-10) two proverbs (vv. 11-12), and a conclusion (vv. 13-14). Verses nine and ten say that Qohelet “tested the soundness of many maxims” and “sought to discover useful sayings”. I agree that he questioned things and tried to discover useful sayings throughout Ecclesiastes, though I’m not sure if he found what he was looking for. Verse eleven infers that verses nine and ten are about wisdom. It also says that the goads and nails of the “one Shepherd” have been given to the wise. We think of this in the same way a shepherd prods their flocks along for their own gain.

Verses twelve through fourteen caution against probing too deeply when reading Wisdom Literature such as Ecclesiastes, because studying wisdom can become a never-ending endeavor. In verse fourteen, the writer reminds us that, in the end, God will judge us in everything we do (“God will call every creature to account for everything unknown, be it good or bad”). Verse fourteen repeats verse thirteen in saying “the sum of the matter….revere God and His commandments”, supposedly so the book does not end with a threatening tone.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Epilogue

In the epilogue of Ecclesiastes (verses 9-14), the epilogist attempts to summarize Qohelet’s message. In my initial reading of Ecclesiastes, I found the epilogue to be very different from the rest of the book; however, upon closer reading, I believe that the epilogue provides a fairly reasonable summary of Ecclesiastes.

The first paragraph of the epilogue serves to state the reliability of Qohelet as a wise teacher. As readers, we can trust that Qohelet was not only wise, but “also taught the people knowledge, weighing and studying and arranging many proverbs” (v. 9). Additionally, Qohelet did not write Ecclesiastes as “some haphazard arrangement” (Brown, 116), but instead, as stated in verse 10, “he wrote words of truth plainly.” This paragraph verifies Qohelet as a reliable narrator.

The next paragraph discusses the nature of wisdom. This paragraph is particularly important to Ecclesiastes because while Qohelet touches on the negative affects of wisdom, verses 11-12 warn the reader that gaining wisdom is a painful experience. According to Brown, the use of the images of “nails” and “goads” depict how “pain is part of the process of learning, analogous to the forceful training of animals” (v. 12). So, while Qohelet generally speaks of wisdom in a positive sense throughout Ecclesiastes, the epilogue offers a word of caution. Additionally, verse 12 warns the reader against “anything beyond” what Qohelet has explored because “of making many books there is no end” (v. 12). Here, the epilogist warns the reader that attempting to seek more wisdom than what Qohelet has sought will never be satisfied. This warning parallels Qohelet’s theme that there is nothing new under the sun.

In the third and final paragraph, the epilogist restates the idea that all will be judged by God. Verse 13 begins by saying “all has been heard,” another restatement that there is nothing new under the sun. Verse 13 goes on to say “fear God, and keep his commandments; for that is the whole duty of everybody.” One could interpret this verse as a commandment tacked onto the end by the Church trying to reconcile Ecclesiastes with the rest of the Bible; however, according to Brown, the concept of fearing God “connotes a reverence of the wholly Other that is devoid of grandiose expectations and cleansed of ulterior motive” and “reflects a realistic faith at its simplest and sincerest level” (119). This parallels Qohelet’s idea that joy can only be found in the simplest aspects of life: eating, drinking, and our relationships with others. Similarly, in faith, one must not expect to gain something through serving God; rather, faith should be exhibited in it’s simplest form: obedience.

The epilogue, though clearly not written by Qohelet, is not completely irrelevant to or out of character from Ecclesiastes. Rather offers some summary of two major themes explored by Qohelet and some insight into how to apply Ecclesiastes to the life of the reader.

Isn't it Ironic

Ecclesiastes 12:9-14 seems to be one of the most contentious passages of the book. This epilogue has suffered debate over authorship and over intent. It is unclear whether it was added to the book later or, conversely, what the author meant by shifting tone so dramatically near the end of the book. Carolyn Sharp argues for an ironic, deconstructionist reading of the text arguing: "No biblical book is more thoroughly basted in reduction upon reduction of irony than is the book of Qohelet. The multifaceted irony of Qohelet calls the reader into the unexpected intimacy of shared confidence one moment and mocks the reader's expectations from a great distance the next, painstakingly constructs a deceptive rhetorical edifice and then dismantles it in a stroke (Sharp, 41)." Sharp's view implies that the author not only constructed the figure of Qohelet purposefully, but also wrote the epilogue as means of separating the reader from the fictional figure of Qohelet. To Sharp, Qohelet and the epilogue are rhetorical constructions attempting to prove the argument of the author and to show the irony in Qohelet's search for wisdom. Sharp interprets the use of these rhetorical tools as attempting to prove that: "Only obedience, not wisdom as such, can name the human person apart from the injustice, chaos, and disintegration that eternally constitute the cosmos. Wisdom and striving cannot free us, cannot enact justice in the life of the human person or in the eternal rounds of the universe. Obedience alone names us, defines and constitutes us, for that is all of who we are (Sharp, 65-66)."


It is possible to analyze Ecclesiastes 12:9-14 from Sharp's viewpoint. In the ironic reading, this passage, not the rest of the book in which the character (possibly a construction) Qohelet speaks, is the true voice of the narrator or author. That verses 9 and 10 speak of Qohelet in third person seems to coincide with Sharp's view. These passages seem to refer to further actions that Qohelet performed and they are from the point of view of someone familiar with his actions, not from himself: "..the Teacher also taught the people knowledge, weighing and studying and arranging many proverbs" and "The Teacher sought to find pleasing words, and he wrote words of truth plainly." This does seem to lend itself to an interpretation in which Qohelet may be the subject, not the author, of the text.


In her argument, Sharp states that the rhetorical devices employed in this book serve to point out the essentiality of obedience, not wisdom. Verses 12-14 seem to evidence this interpretation. "Of making books there is no end, and much study is a weariness of the flesh (12)." Throughout the book of Ecclesiastes, Qohelet searches for wisdom, for answers about life and death, to no avail. This epilogue seems to imply that such wisdom is impossible to find and is, dare I say, meaningless. Verses 13 and 14, as Sharp would note, extol the virtues of obedience to God. "Fear God, and keep his commandments; for that is the whole duty of everyone (13)." The "end of the matter" for Ecclesiastes is not wisdom, it is obedience to God.

How Many Authors Does it Take to Write an Epilogue?

In these final five verses of Ecclesiastes (12:9-14), the author of the book seems to change abruptly. One reason that sparks the idea that the epilogue was added later by an additional author is the reference to Qohelet (the Teacher) in such a positive and praising light. 12:9 says, “Not only was the Teacher wise, but also imparted knowledge to the people. He pondered and searched out and set in order many proverbs.” Whoever wrote this final epilogue praised Qohelet and his wisdom, and gives the indication that Qohelet purposely challenged and righted proverbs of the day. I find this to be in stark contrast to the rest of the book of Ecclesiastes. Qohelet may reference proverbs or pieces of common knowledge, but setting them right never seems to be his goal.

Another contradiction I see in the epilogue is in vv. 11-12, which states that “the words of the wise are like goads, their collected sayings like firmly embedded nails” and to “be warned, my son, of anything in addition to them. Of making books there is no end, and much study wearies the body.” The author seems to be saying, in reference to Qohelet, that one should take the words of the wise and not question them or trust anything added to them, as well as avoid writing books and studying the words of the wise too much. This especially contradicts what the previous verse said about the Teacher who challenged and set right proverbs, though is in line with Qohelet’s position that too much wisdom is just as bad as foolishness. These inconsistencies lead me to think that two additional authors had their hands in the epilogue, possibly with a third voice emerging in verses 13-14.

The final two verses of Ecclesiastes are, as I read them, a middle ground between what seems to be Qohelet’s position on life and what 12:9-12 has to say. V. 13 warns the reader to “fear God and keep his commandments,” while v. 14 returns to the idea that everything will be judged by God. It seems to be a neutral way to end the book, touching on some prevalent themes but staying far enough away to avoid staking a radical theological claim.

The epilogue of Ecclesiastes, 12:9-14, is an inconsistent, yet at times vaguely cohesive, passage. It certainly does not have Qohelet’s usual pessimistic, depressing sass, and puts Qohelet and wisdom up on a metaphorical pedestal, leading to the conclusion that others have tampered with the end of Ecclesiastes,

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Qohelet Should Get to Punch This Epilogist in the Face, Or Atleast Tell Him Off

When reading Ecclesiastes 12: 9-14, the epilogue, I found myself wondering if the person who wrote this section had read the same Book of Qohelet that I have been reading. The epilogist begins, in third person point of view, by saying that the Teacher taught people knowledge. I guess that one could make the case that Qohelet’s constant reiteration that humans have no control over what happens in the world, to the point that they cannot even know how to be good, is some twisted sort of wisdom. However, this is definitely not conventional wisdom; this is not simple advice that one can effortlessly apply to life in a beneficial way. The epilogue fails to shed light on the confused, meaninglessness at the core of Qohelet’s knowledge. Instead, the epilogist compares Qohelet’s teaching to “many proverbs” in verse 9, which is misleading. The epilogist also says, “he wrote words of truth plainly”. Qohelet is nothing if he is not confusing. I cannot see how anyone could find the Book of Qohelet plain, or easy to interpret. This book is basically one frustrating contradiction after another. This false impression of Qohelet tinges the rest of the way that the epilogue is interpreted.


Since verses 9-10 portray Qohelet as a person that has knowledge that is true and helpful, it is easy to assume in verse 11 that Qohelet is using goads, with nails firmly fixed, to encourage his students to heed his advice. Of course, the knowledgeable Qohelet of the epilogue, with his true, pleasing words, would only be goading people for their own good. Qohelet is even referred to as a “shepherd” in verse 11, and in verse 12, the epilogist warns readers to beware of delving into the study of anything that is “beyond these”, which I took to mean beyond these wise teachings of Qohelet. In verse 13, the epilogist takes this caution a step further, when he says, “The end of the matter; all has been heard.”


Verses 11-13 really portray Qohelet as a person who should be listened to, as a man who truly knows what he is talking about. I’m not quite sure that Qohelet would like this. I think he would be the first to admit that he knows nothing and he wouldn’t be embarrassed by this, because no one knows anything, but chasing after the wind. I think the epilogist is using Qohelet as a means to his own ends. In 13b, the epilogist says, “Fear God, and keep his commandments; for this is the whole duty of everyone.” Maybe fearing God is what the epilogist would like to think is the whole duty of everyone, but the real Qohelet has just written an entire book proclaiming the futility of fearing God, because humans cannot know what God desires. The epilogist ends in verse 14 with an attempt to enforce his advice to fear God, with the reminder that in the end God will judge all deeds, whether good or evil. I think at this point Qohelet would laugh at the epilogist and remind him that all people come to same death. Maybe Qohelet would sneer at the epilogist and tell him that his goody-two-shoes self is still dyeing and going down with the animals.


This epilogue is making a mockery of the Book of Qohelet. The cynical, confused, honest Qohelet is lost, and some all-knowing wise man is presented instead. Although the epilogist’s stretching of Qohelet’s message is probably the reason that Ecclesiastes made it into the Judeo-Christian cannon, Qohelet’s true wisdom has been lost and perverted in the epilogue. A more honest epilogist would have ended with “Enjoy your food, wine, and toil; for this is best that you can hope for in your vain, little life.”