This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Monday, September 13, 2010
And he takes and he takes and he takes.
Qoheleth talks about man having everything under the sun and not having anything at the same time. The rich being prosperous yet not being happy with his earning or losing everything they have earned so that his son still has no earnings from his toils.
Eccl. 5:1-4 suprised me, it didn't have the same tone as the rest of what we have read from Ecclesiastes. The heading for this section, Stand in Awe of God, but I percieved it as more Stand in Fear of him. "Gaurd your steps when you go to the house of God. Gonear to listen rather than to offer the sacrifice of fools, who do not know that they do wrong. Do not be quick with your mouth, do not be hasty in your heart to utter anything before God." (Ecc. 5:1-2) Sounds like more of a warning if you ask me. Should we fear God? Or should we look at him in a fraternal way?
After listening to Casimir Pulaski Day, I got the feeling that while they were talking about the father driving to the Navy yard when he heard that the daughter (I'm guessing daughter) had bone cancer, and that he drove there to say he was sorry, that somehow he was supposed to be interpretted as God. Thinking of God as your father and then interpreting the song in that sense made the song make more sense to me.
The Riches are Worthless
Ecclesiates chapter 5 begins with a meditation on the worship of God. Qohelet sees no point in making sacrifices to God when God is in heaven and man is on Earth (v. 1-2). The realm of God has no need for money or slaughtered animals. What man can offer to God is fulfilled vows, unfulfilled vows come from fools who speak empty words. Silence is preferable to empty, ill-chosen words, it is better to listen to God because as someone on earth what can be said to God who transcends earth. Therefore it is better to let your words be few in front of God (v. 2). I’m not sure if this means Qohelet thinks that God does not do anything about human concerns or if there is no connection between Earth and God. In “Casimir Pulaski Day” the sick person was prayed for but nothing happened.
Money is an earthly thing that man foolishly tries to collect. The rich are Money cannot be taken with man when he dies yet rich men spend all of their time trying to get more of it (v. 10). The rich are never satisfied with their wealth. So much so that the rich man cannot sleep while the laborer's sleep is “sweet” (v. 11-12) Man leaves the world as he enters it (v.15), a man cannot take what he has earned from to work to whatever happens after death. At the end of this section, Qohelet realizes that is its good for man to enjoy the short life that God as given him and enjoy whatever wealth he has received, unlike the rich man who always wants more and can never enjoy what he has (v. 18-19). In verse 20, Qohelet seems to think that a man who follows this advice has a good life in the sense that he does not worry about the shortness and meaning of his life because he is focused on enjoying simple pleasures (eating, drinking, finding joy).
In chapter 6 Qohelet says that the inability to enjoy things is a “grievous evil” (v.1-2). He thinks that a stillborn child, who never knows anything of existence, is better off than a man who does not enjoy his good fortune (v. 3). I’m not sure what Qohelet means by the man not receiving a proper burial, maybe not receiving a burial is like being unfulfilled. I’m guessing the hypothetical man’s 100 children did not care for him because he was not enjoying his life including not enjoying his children.
And he takes and he takes and he takes
Ecclesiastes 5:1-6:9
The opening lines of Ecclesiastes 5 are instructions regarding how one should act in the presence of God. Qoheleth uses the setting of the temple to instruct the reader to “draw near to listen.” Qoheleth believes that it is better to listen than to offer a sacrifice that is not genuine. He evokes a sense of humility from the reader when he says that it is better to be silent than to speak “ for God is in heaven, and you upon the earth” (v.2). Qoheleth seems to be suggesting that God’s thoughts are higher than our thoughts. He is beyond human understanding, therefore, we are incapable of understanding his movements or his ways.
A rather abrupt shift occurs in verse 8 when Qoheleth begins to talk about the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice” as an everyday occurrence. He then makes another unusual shift by saying, “the high official is watched by a higher, and there are yet higher ones over them. But all things considered, this is an advantage for a land; a king for a plowed field.” Even after reading Brown’s commentary on this portion of the text, I am still completely confused as to the meaning of this passage.
In the next section of chapter five (v.10,) Qoheleth says the lover of money will never be satisfied. The more they get, the more they shall want. Even carefully guarded wealth can be lost. Qoheleth writes that in the end material wealth is meaningless, because we will all end up in the same place. Humans gain nothing from their toil. Once again, Qoheleth suggests that man eat, drink, and find enjoyment in the few days he has been given.In chapter six, Qoheleth discovers an evil that he says, “lies heavy upon humankind.” God gives wealth and then does not enable the wealthy to enjoy it – “ And he takes and he takes and he takes” (Casmir Pulaski Day). Man be given much in the way of material possessions, land, and children, but if he cannot enjoy it, Qoheleth says that “ a stillborn child is better off than he” (v.3) Qoheleth believes that a long life that is never filled with joy is worse than no life at all.
Qoheleth ends this section in chapter six by saying that humans will never be satisfied. They will always desire more than they have been given. It is important to see the good and find enjoyment in the very act of recognizing the good, rather than the act itself, which will only result in further desires which cannot be fulfilled.
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Up in the Vapor
Ryan is a loner who flies around the country firing people for a living and also, strangely enough, is a motivational speaker. Ryan is at home when he is flying from place to place. He loves all the things about air travel that most people hate right down to the cheap sushi. He is also working on flying 10 million miles to be only the seventh person to ever do so and have his name placed on an airplane. Ryan really knows how to travel, he knows how to get all the perks and benefits, he knows all the shortcuts, and he knows how to travel light. He also travels light with the relationships with people in his life.
In his motivational speeches he claims that “relationships are the heaviest components of your life.” He tells his audience that their relationships take up too much of their life and that they should not put as much into them. Perhaps Ryan has this “philosophy” on relationships because he does not see anything meaningful. This of course is similar to the plight of the author of Ecclesiastes.
Perhaps Qohelet and Ryan have such an innate fear of mortality that they force themselves to believe that there is no meaning to life. If they have no meaningful life then once their death comes around then nothing is lost.
Qohelet and Ryan both agree that “we all end up in the same place… there is no point.” (Ecc. 2:15). However, both offer some glimmer of hope in the value of a companion. Qohelet says, “Two are better than one, because they have good reward for their toil.” (4:9) Just after Ryan starts to believe that life is better with a companion he is given the opportunity to mend his relationship with his sister by talking to her groom-to-be with cold feet on the day of the wedding. The groom also thinks there is no point to life because he believes that we all end up dead anyway so Ryan tells him to think of all his favorite memories. He then asks him if he was alone in any of those memories. “Life is better with company,” Ryan offers to the cold feet groom, “everybody needs a copilot.”
Crap Happens and Then You Die
What's the Point?
During the movie “Up in the Air” which casts George Clooney as the protagonist Ryan Bingham, we are entered into a world of airline travel and isolation. Ryan Bingham’s job is to travel around to other companies and fire employees for bosses who are too pansy to do it themselves. It sounds like horrible work, never being home, traveling in crowed airports all the time, but Bingham loves it. He discusses how he couldn’t imagine living any other way, here in the sky is where he calls home. Bingham’s whole life is about efficiency and he proves himself to be very efficient by using the fastest car rental place, by swiping his elite status cards at every checkpoint and being able to cram his whole existence in to one carry-on suitcase. He runs away from family and from any type of human connection because he doesn’t know why he should care. His life is shifted when he meets Alex, a women who lives or so he thinks a very similar lifestyle to him and then again when he is asked to work with Natalie the new up-in-coming associate in his office. His world of isolation is shifted into a world of companionship and connection. He attends his sister’s wedding with Alex and realizes that he likes having her around. Suddenly he has the backbone for the first time in his life to step up and be there to support his sister. He even saves the day when her fiancĂ© gets cold feet before the wedding. The fiancĂ© asks what the point of life is if at the end we just die. Bingham responds that there is no point because at the end you will just die, but wouldn’t you rather spend the time you do have here on earth with somebody. He no longer wishes to be isolated, but to suffer through life with someone by his side. Bingham flies to Chicago to tell Alex, but discovers that she has been lying all the time and that she has a family. After putting his heart on the line it gets crushed by someone he really cared about. Is it worth it? Having all the feelings of pain and suffering of love on top of the pain and suffering of life. I think it is and so does the book of Ecclesiastes.
Qoheleth in the book of Ecclesiastes talks about the oppressions in life and how people are living lives of vanity. He discusses how people like Bingham are toiling away and gaining nothing, “For all their days are full of pain, and their work is a vexation; even at night their minds do not rest. This also is vanity” (2:23). He also is trying to discover the meaning of life, the purpose of his existence on earth and the reason for him to keep on living. Most of Ecclesiastes is dark, but one of the lighter parts is when Qoheleth talks about companionship. He says “Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other; but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help” (4:9-10). Qoheleth is acknowledging that that while life is not easy and most of the time it is horrible, if you have to suffer through it you should suffer through it with someone else. Bingham also comes to this realization during the movie, because he discovers that companionship is what he is missing. Qoheleth doesn’t give a lot of reasons to live in this book and even states that the best scenario would be if you didn’t live at all, but he makes room for eight verses to describe companionship. Obviously companionship became important to him at some point in his life. So maybe life doesn’t have a purpose, maybe it’s just important to find someone who is willing to search for that purpose with you.
Co-Pilots and Companionship
In Up in the Air we learn about the life of Ryan Bingham (George Clooney), a corporate downsizing expert (aka: an expert at firing people) who cherishes his 24/7 isolating job. In the beginning Ryan sees no immediate need for family, friends, or a home. He lives out of a suitcase, is a stranger to his family and doesn't have any real friends. This all changes when Ryan's company hires a new young employee, Natalie. Natalie developed a method of video conferencing that will allow Ryan and his co-workers to fire people without leaving "home". This basically threatens the life Ryan cherishes. To prove Natalie wrong, Ryan takes Natalie on a cross country firing spree. While on this trip Ryan begins to see the downfalls in his way of life. His belief that 10 million frequent flyer miles will make him satisfied begins to shift when Natalie pokes and tests Ryans lifestyle. She asks him questions on family, love, and marriage. Only after convincing his sisters fiance to go through with the marriage saying that life sucks but its suckiness is better when someone else is there...a "co-pilot" does he truly convince himself. Here is where Ryans importance of life changes from frequent flyer miles to companionship. Ryan then decides that Alex, his girlfriend/friend with benefits is someone he wants in his life permanently and wants to have a home, family and friends.
I think that Ryan Binghams life and the book of Ecc mirror each other in themes. Qohelet searches for meaning in self-indulgence (2:3-11) but found short lived pleasure (2:11). Ryan Bingham looked for meaning his accomplishments (frequent flyer miles) and self-indulgence (golden access cards, specific travel cars) but never found true and whole satisfaction. Qohelet also tries to use wisdom to find and reach the meaning (1:13), but only found sorrow and vexation (1:18). Ryan, I believe, was intrigued and somewhat enlightened by Natalie and Alex to a new meaning of life, but Ryan only found sorrow because he discovered that he was truly alone. Finally Qohelet decides that the world is what it is, nothing can change it (3:14-15), and it stinks. But Qohelet discovers that the world, even in its vanity, can still have joy if you have companionship (4:9-12). Ryan comes to the conclusion at his sisters wedding that he needs his own co-pilot.
Both Ecc and Up in the Air conclude with the notion that life stinks and it will always stink but it can be bearable with others.