I liked the movie Up in the Air in the same way that I like Ecclesiastes; they're not the perfect little happy stories. Yes, they are kinda sad ans depressing, but they are real and talk about true human thoughts and troubles. Last year when I first saw the movie, Ecc and its references ever crossed my mind. But on the second viewing I saw many similarities. However, i don't think that Up in the Air was based on or had its roots in Ecc. Qohelet in Ecc was struggling with legitimate queries and doubts pertaining to life. Those same questions are still reside in people today, but instead of writing about it, a movie was made. (This kinda supports Qohelets idea that wisdom can only take a person so far. People today struggle with things that people thousands of years ago struggled with; obviously we haven't made much progress). Up in the Air and Ecc have similar themes throughout but that doesn't necessarily mean they were based on one another.
In Up in the Air we learn about the life of Ryan Bingham (George Clooney), a corporate downsizing expert (aka: an expert at firing people) who cherishes his 24/7 isolating job. In the beginning Ryan sees no immediate need for family, friends, or a home. He lives out of a suitcase, is a stranger to his family and doesn't have any real friends. This all changes when Ryan's company hires a new young employee, Natalie. Natalie developed a method of video conferencing that will allow Ryan and his co-workers to fire people without leaving "home". This basically threatens the life Ryan cherishes. To prove Natalie wrong, Ryan takes Natalie on a cross country firing spree. While on this trip Ryan begins to see the downfalls in his way of life. His belief that 10 million frequent flyer miles will make him satisfied begins to shift when Natalie pokes and tests Ryans lifestyle. She asks him questions on family, love, and marriage. Only after convincing his sisters fiance to go through with the marriage saying that life sucks but its suckiness is better when someone else is there...a "co-pilot" does he truly convince himself. Here is where Ryans importance of life changes from frequent flyer miles to companionship. Ryan then decides that Alex, his girlfriend/friend with benefits is someone he wants in his life permanently and wants to have a home, family and friends.
I think that Ryan Binghams life and the book of Ecc mirror each other in themes. Qohelet searches for meaning in self-indulgence (2:3-11) but found short lived pleasure (2:11). Ryan Bingham looked for meaning his accomplishments (frequent flyer miles) and self-indulgence (golden access cards, specific travel cars) but never found true and whole satisfaction. Qohelet also tries to use wisdom to find and reach the meaning (1:13), but only found sorrow and vexation (1:18). Ryan, I believe, was intrigued and somewhat enlightened by Natalie and Alex to a new meaning of life, but Ryan only found sorrow because he discovered that he was truly alone. Finally Qohelet decides that the world is what it is, nothing can change it (3:14-15), and it stinks. But Qohelet discovers that the world, even in its vanity, can still have joy if you have companionship (4:9-12). Ryan comes to the conclusion at his sisters wedding that he needs his own co-pilot.
Both Ecc and Up in the Air conclude with the notion that life stinks and it will always stink but it can be bearable with others.
This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Maybe it's the Situation
In my opinion, the movie (Up in the Air) itself is about finding your purpose and defining what is valuable to you. Throughout most of the movie I would say that Ryan Bingham (George Clooney) was busy occupying his every second so that he wouldn’t have to address the issue of life’s purpose. He didn’t have any valuable people in his life, not even his own family. As the movie continues, however, Bingham is faced with the possibility of being “grounded” for life. I think this possibility forces him to reevaluate his life in terms of the relationships he doesn’t have. During the movie meets Alex Goran, a fellow travelling businessperson, and as their relationship grows he feels compelled to be more seriously committed to her. Unfortunately, Alex is married. I think the fact that they can’t actually be together isn’t as important as the fact that their experience together taught him to value the people in his life. At the end of the movie Bingham, in an act of love and perhaps devotion, transfers his precious airline miles to an account for his sister and brother-in-law. I think this growth from feeling like he didn’t need anyone to realizing that having other people in your life is important is the whole point of the movie. I also feel that it is quite relatable to Ecclesiastes 4:9-12.
I also feel that the movie possibly gives some insight into how Ecclesiastes might be better understood. What is the meaning of all our “toil under the sun?” Perhaps the answer to that question depends on what kind of day you had; who you met, how much stress you experienced, or how you felt. Maybe the reason why Ecclesiastes seems so confusing is because he’s writing different sections at different times. It seems possible to me that a lot of people feel like life is worthless…until they don’t. Ryan Bingham appeared very anti-committed relationships until he met Alex Goran and changed his mind. He spoke at conferences all about how people should remove the baggage of their relationships from their lives. He apparently didn’t think personal relationships were meaningful enough, that is, until he met Alex and found a purpose in them. I think Qohelet could be expressing or possibly journaling his day-to-day thoughts about existence. Maybe some days he feels lonely or bored with his life and those emotions produce the passages that question what it’s all worth. On other days he might have met a beautiful woman at the well and totally changed his perspective. Then, maybe she wasn’t so interested and he’s back to his hopeless outlook. I obviously don’t know the life experiences that Qohelet had but I do think it’s a reasonable assumption that he probably allowed those situations to shape his outlook on life.
I also feel that the movie possibly gives some insight into how Ecclesiastes might be better understood. What is the meaning of all our “toil under the sun?” Perhaps the answer to that question depends on what kind of day you had; who you met, how much stress you experienced, or how you felt. Maybe the reason why Ecclesiastes seems so confusing is because he’s writing different sections at different times. It seems possible to me that a lot of people feel like life is worthless…until they don’t. Ryan Bingham appeared very anti-committed relationships until he met Alex Goran and changed his mind. He spoke at conferences all about how people should remove the baggage of their relationships from their lives. He apparently didn’t think personal relationships were meaningful enough, that is, until he met Alex and found a purpose in them. I think Qohelet could be expressing or possibly journaling his day-to-day thoughts about existence. Maybe some days he feels lonely or bored with his life and those emotions produce the passages that question what it’s all worth. On other days he might have met a beautiful woman at the well and totally changed his perspective. Then, maybe she wasn’t so interested and he’s back to his hopeless outlook. I obviously don’t know the life experiences that Qohelet had but I do think it’s a reasonable assumption that he probably allowed those situations to shape his outlook on life.
Tuesday, September 7, 2010
some fun meaninglessness (sorry this is long, main point at end)
In the movie "Up in The Air" by Jason Reitman we follow the life of Ryan Bingham whose job it is to travel around the country and fire people. Most people would not like this job. Bingham sees people on the worst day of their life and he is the one who made it the worst day of their life. Bingham, however, loves it. He does not have to stay home and tells us that he does in fact love flying and being in the air. He only truly feels at home and happy when he is on the road. Now with only a short explanation of the plot I will dive into an examination of the story. The underlying theme of the movie is a search for what is truly important in life. In the course of the story we see Bingham make a complete turnaround with what he believes is important. In the beginning of the story the most important thing to Bingham is to reach the magic number which will make all things better. Only Bingham knows what that number is and he only shares it with Alex (his on-the-road girlfriend) whom he thinks may be the one person who understands him. However, after going to his sister's wedding and having to talk her fiancé back into a commitment that Bingham himself thinks no one should ever make, he realizes that family and relationships are the most important things in life, and that magic number he is trying so hard to reach is just false hope. Finally, the audience sees all the people Bingham has fired over the years talking about the thing that got them through losing their job. The common theme in all of the responses is family. Every single one of the people who have been fired mentions that they would not have been able to stay afloat if they had not had their family to lean on. That companionship and love is what kept them afloat more than a steady paycheck ever could. The audience learns what Bingham has been searching for the whole movie, the most important thing in life is to love and be loved in return (I think there is another movie/song about that).
Now Ecclesiastes. So far in Ecclesiastes the underlying theme is that everything is meaningless. Everyone ends up dead and there is nothing you can do about it. "Up in the Air" does not go against this interpretation in my mind it simply fills in the middle. Everything is still meaningless, in the end nothing matters, but there are some damn fun ways of passing the time until you die. Your family is what gets you through the meaninglessness. In Ecclesiastes Qoheleth goes though the same sort of learning process as Bingham. First the man finds his joy in his toil, then the toil becomes meaningless and enjoying oneself is what is important, then a balance is found between the man's work and play. In Ecclesiastes I am pointing to Ch. 2, and in the movie I am pointing towards Bingham's relationship with Alex. Chapter 2 moves though a series of activities and lifestyles to see which, if any, are truly meaningful. First there is pleasure. Qoheleth tries food and drink, laughter and being silly and finds that those things are meaningless. He then tries amassing great wealth by building gardens and gaining wealth and denying him-self nothing, but that too was meaningless. Next Qoheleth finds wisdom to try to get some meaning in his life, but alas that too is meaningless. Finally Qoheleth looks to his work and finds "a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work" (Qoh 2:24a). However, this too ends up being meaningless. In the movie Ryan goes though these 4 stages. First Ryan is trying to amass all the wealth that he possibly can. Ryan works all the time and tries to find his happiness in his everyday routine. Second Ryan finds Alex. He finds that Alex is a fun person to be around and maybe that that life is not all about work. Alex gives Ryan something in his life besides work and makes him begin to question what he has been doing with his life. Third, Natalie comes on the scene and Ryan tries to pass on the wisdom that he has gained over the years, but though trying to pass on his wisdom he finds that simply having the ability to fire people really well is not the most important thing in the world. Then finally after everything has fallen apart in Ryan's relationship with Alex he turns back to his work for some kind of meaning in his life all the while knowing deep in his heart that it is meaningless.
Now the important thing through all this is that we just have to live our lives the best we can. Ryan Bingham thought that it was just too late for him to do anything about his life and Qoheleth could not focus on anything but the end of his. The more important thing is that we find what makes us happy and what gets us though the meaninglessness. These things I believe are love and companionship, and even if it is meaningless it is some damn good meaninglessness.
Now Ecclesiastes. So far in Ecclesiastes the underlying theme is that everything is meaningless. Everyone ends up dead and there is nothing you can do about it. "Up in the Air" does not go against this interpretation in my mind it simply fills in the middle. Everything is still meaningless, in the end nothing matters, but there are some damn fun ways of passing the time until you die. Your family is what gets you through the meaninglessness. In Ecclesiastes Qoheleth goes though the same sort of learning process as Bingham. First the man finds his joy in his toil, then the toil becomes meaningless and enjoying oneself is what is important, then a balance is found between the man's work and play. In Ecclesiastes I am pointing to Ch. 2, and in the movie I am pointing towards Bingham's relationship with Alex. Chapter 2 moves though a series of activities and lifestyles to see which, if any, are truly meaningful. First there is pleasure. Qoheleth tries food and drink, laughter and being silly and finds that those things are meaningless. He then tries amassing great wealth by building gardens and gaining wealth and denying him-self nothing, but that too was meaningless. Next Qoheleth finds wisdom to try to get some meaning in his life, but alas that too is meaningless. Finally Qoheleth looks to his work and finds "a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work" (Qoh 2:24a). However, this too ends up being meaningless. In the movie Ryan goes though these 4 stages. First Ryan is trying to amass all the wealth that he possibly can. Ryan works all the time and tries to find his happiness in his everyday routine. Second Ryan finds Alex. He finds that Alex is a fun person to be around and maybe that that life is not all about work. Alex gives Ryan something in his life besides work and makes him begin to question what he has been doing with his life. Third, Natalie comes on the scene and Ryan tries to pass on the wisdom that he has gained over the years, but though trying to pass on his wisdom he finds that simply having the ability to fire people really well is not the most important thing in the world. Then finally after everything has fallen apart in Ryan's relationship with Alex he turns back to his work for some kind of meaning in his life all the while knowing deep in his heart that it is meaningless.
Now the important thing through all this is that we just have to live our lives the best we can. Ryan Bingham thought that it was just too late for him to do anything about his life and Qoheleth could not focus on anything but the end of his. The more important thing is that we find what makes us happy and what gets us though the meaninglessness. These things I believe are love and companionship, and even if it is meaningless it is some damn good meaninglessness.
"I did write six words." -Pete Seeger
3:1-8 is probably the most famous passage from Ecclesiastes. It is still known, quoted, and borrowed from. For example, The Byrds's #1 hit "Turn! Turn! Turn!" ( http://bit.ly/2gBEVY ) recognizes that there is nothing new under the sun and that everything has already been said, and so shamelessly swipes 3:1-8 in full for its lyrics (mostly-- the very end slaps in a somewhat incongruous "a time for peace, I swear it's not too late" which could either be a cute 9:7-like assertion about inner-peace, or more likely a current-events reference-- but there's a time for war, too, right, right?)
I was looking up information about this song, actually, and was very amused to see the Wikipedia article on it mention the following hilarious gem:
""" The Byrds' version distinguishes the song as the #1 pop hit with the oldest lyrics, dating back to the Book of Ecclesiastes. Many biblical scholars believe Ecclesiastes 1:1 implies King Solomon as the book's author; thus, if true, giving Solomon lyrical credit for a number one hit. """ ( http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Turn!_Turn!_Turn!&oldid=381917274 )
Some things never change! I wonder of Koheleth would like to update his resume in 2:4-9: "I laid out gardens and groves... got myself male and female singes... acquired more cattle than all who were before me... and I got more Grammies than any king in Jerusalem before or after."
In all seriousness, 3:1-8 makes what I think is a pretty clear point: the trajectory of the world is set, and simple human ideas about good and bad may be misguided, because all events are appropriate when they occur, just as all the events in a play are set-- it isn't a tragedy when Macbeth kills Banquo, that was in the script! I think 9:1 ("...That the actions of even the righteous and the wise are determined by God. Even love! Even hate! Man knows none of these in advance") and 9:7 ("Go, eat your bread in gladness, and drink your wine in joy; for your action was long ago approved by God.") are helpful related texts.
The form of 3:1-8 is interesting-- the repetition of the parallels. It does seem really effective, doesn't it? This is one of the most memorable poems in human history so far, and many of us have said it seems especially appealing or beautiful. Why does it work? Maybe the series of examples manages to be very strong in its point, yet subtle. It doesn't hit you over the head with its point by stating it explicitly, like say, this blog post, which is definitely not poetry. But the continuous examples gradually convince you that the author really, really does mean *everything*, and a very cyclic sense of the world is conveyed by these complementary opposites without actually stating it.
3:9-13 looks like a unit to me. Koheleth, having just seen that everything is predestined, varied, and cyclical, asks again what "profit" a person can get out of his or her toil in such a world. The answer is none, because that would require being able to predict what will come about tomorrow as a result of your toil today, which is impossible, even though it is our nature to want to do that (3:11) So enjoy what you do in the moment at least (3:12), since at least you get that for sure (3:13).
3:14-15 on the surface seems to be yet another straightforward repetition of the current theme, but actually I think there's more to meets the eye. There's a puzzling part in there at the end of each of those verses, just when you thought you were starting to understand them. Funnily, this kind of situation is actually
Something weird: 4:17 seems more linked with ch. 5 than ch. 4. Why were the chapters separated the way they were?
I was looking up information about this song, actually, and was very amused to see the Wikipedia article on it mention the following hilarious gem:
""" The Byrds' version distinguishes the song as the #1 pop hit with the oldest lyrics, dating back to the Book of Ecclesiastes. Many biblical scholars believe Ecclesiastes 1:1 implies King Solomon as the book's author; thus, if true, giving Solomon lyrical credit for a number one hit. """ ( http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Turn!_Turn!_Turn!&oldid=381917274 )
Some things never change! I wonder of Koheleth would like to update his resume in 2:4-9: "I laid out gardens and groves... got myself male and female singes... acquired more cattle than all who were before me... and I got more Grammies than any king in Jerusalem before or after."
In all seriousness, 3:1-8 makes what I think is a pretty clear point: the trajectory of the world is set, and simple human ideas about good and bad may be misguided, because all events are appropriate when they occur, just as all the events in a play are set-- it isn't a tragedy when Macbeth kills Banquo, that was in the script! I think 9:1 ("...That the actions of even the righteous and the wise are determined by God. Even love! Even hate! Man knows none of these in advance") and 9:7 ("Go, eat your bread in gladness, and drink your wine in joy; for your action was long ago approved by God.") are helpful related texts.
The form of 3:1-8 is interesting-- the repetition of the parallels. It does seem really effective, doesn't it? This is one of the most memorable poems in human history so far, and many of us have said it seems especially appealing or beautiful. Why does it work? Maybe the series of examples manages to be very strong in its point, yet subtle. It doesn't hit you over the head with its point by stating it explicitly, like say, this blog post, which is definitely not poetry. But the continuous examples gradually convince you that the author really, really does mean *everything*, and a very cyclic sense of the world is conveyed by these complementary opposites without actually stating it.
3:9-13 looks like a unit to me. Koheleth, having just seen that everything is predestined, varied, and cyclical, asks again what "profit" a person can get out of his or her toil in such a world. The answer is none, because that would require being able to predict what will come about tomorrow as a result of your toil today, which is impossible, even though it is our nature to want to do that (3:11) So enjoy what you do in the moment at least (3:12), since at least you get that for sure (3:13).
3:14-15 on the surface seems to be yet another straightforward repetition of the current theme, but actually I think there's more to meets the eye. There's a puzzling part in there at the end of each of those verses, just when you thought you were starting to understand them. Funnily, this kind of situation is actually
Something weird: 4:17 seems more linked with ch. 5 than ch. 4. Why were the chapters separated the way they were?
Monday, September 6, 2010
on the side of Their oppressors there was power, ...
There is much to ponder over in a reading of Ecclesiastes chs 3 and 4, from perspectives as broad as theology, social justice, and even cosmology. The everpresent theme of life as vane struggle persists, coupled with an eye to the(primarily economic) injustices that human existence perpetuates. As I have come to expect, for Qoheleth toil is the key motor that gets humanity going, our unhappy conatus. It is our primary reason for existing, according to a number of passages in the text. Whether this toil is given us by god or man is up for debate, for while God is represented as an all-powerful entity who has placed us upon the earth, he does not appear to be the benevolent deity so often conceived of in the popular imagination. I will have more to say on this later, but sufficed to say suffering is a leitmotif that represents the struggle of existence and its fleeting pleasures. "It is an unhappy business god has given human beings to be busy with," we are told in 1:13, and this inflexible unhappiness can be overcome through neither wisdom or follely. Rather we are advised to take pleasure in the small joys aforded us through food, drink and prurience, though none of these will provide us anything so unrealizable as ultimate satisfaction.
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that it is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1) Note that God, so often understood in the Bible as a shepherd overseeing his flock, or in the new testament as one who knows even the number of hairs on a subject's head, ... is strikingly absent. Those who endure with "no one to comfort them" are without consolation, hence the great emphasis given their plight by the Preacher. This undertaking emulates the work of such prophets as Amos and, admittedly anachronisticly, Martin Luther king, whose task was, as they saw it, to be a voice for those who have been silenced through the all-too-human inequalities inherent in the unequal distribution of power into which they are born. "‘For whom am I toiling’, they ask, ‘and depriving myself of pleasure?’ This also is vanity and an unhappy business."(3:8) Indeed, though i do not have time to pursue this line of thought, I feel that Qoheleth's belief that "all toil and all skill in work come from one person’s envy of another ..." could be, if followed, incorporated into an implicit critique of capitalism given this system's propencity to raise selfishness to the highest of virtues. but that's a story, for another time. ...broad as theology, social justice, and even cosmology. The everpresent theme of life as vane struggle persists, coupled with an eye to the(primarily economic) injustices that human existence perpetuates. As I have come to expect, for Qoheleth toil is the key motor that gets humanity going, our unhappy conatus. It is our primary reason for existing, according to a number of passages in the text. Whether this toil is given us by god or man is up for debate, for while God is represented as an all-powerful entity who has placed us upon the earth, he does not appear to be the benevolent deity so often conceived of in the popular imagination. I will have more to say on this later, but sufficed to say suffering is a leitmotif that represents the struggle of existence and its fleeting pleasures. "It is an unhappy business god has given human beings to be busy with," we are told in 1:13, and this inflexible unhappiness can be overcome through neither wisdom or follely. Rather we are advised to
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1)
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that it is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1) Note that God, so often understood in the Bible as a shepherd overseeing his flock, or in the new testament as one who knows even the number of hairs on a subject's head, ... is strikingly absent. Those who endure with "no one to comfort them" are without consolation, hence the great emphasis given their plight by the Preacher. This undertaking emulates the work of such prophets as Amos and, admittedly anachronisticly, Martin Luther king, whose task was, as they saw it, to be a voice for those who have been silenced through the all-too-human inequalities inherent in the unequal distribution of power into which they are born. "‘For whom am I toiling’, they ask, ‘and depriving myself of pleasure?’ This also is vanity and an unhappy business."(3:8) Indeed, though i do not have time to pursue this line of thought, I feel that Qoheleth's belief that "all toil and all skill in work come from one person’s envy of another ..." could be, if followed, incorporated into an implicit critique of capitalism given this system's propencity to raise selfishness to the highest of virtues. but that's a story, for another time. ...broad as theology, social justice, and even cosmology. The everpresent theme of life as vane struggle persists, coupled with an eye to the(primarily economic) injustices that human existence perpetuates. As I have come to expect, for Qoheleth toil is the key motor that gets humanity going, our unhappy conatus. It is our primary reason for existing, according to a number of passages in the text. Whether this toil is given us by god or man is up for debate, for while God is represented as an all-powerful entity who has placed us upon the earth, he does not appear to be the benevolent deity so often conceived of in the popular imagination. I will have more to say on this later, but sufficed to say suffering is a leitmotif that represents the struggle of existence and its fleeting pleasures. "It is an unhappy business god has given human beings to be busy with," we are told in 1:13, and this inflexible unhappiness can be overcome through neither wisdom or follely. Rather we are advised to
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1)
For who am I toiling?
When I read Ecclesisastes, I understand the Teacher to be writing with the intention of teaching something. So, as I interpret I ask myself, what insight or inspiration might the Teacher intend to leave his students with? Not, what is he saying, but what is his message? For this particular passage, it is my understanding that the Teacher wants his students to ask themselves, first, "for who am I toiling?" and second, "what determines how I experience my toil"?
I understand the first section of this passage to be 3:1-9. Qoheleth starts in v. 3:1 saying "for everything there is a season", and then goes on to show not only that everything is part of a cycle, but that nature possesses a certain sort of balance, or harmony. The problem with this reality is then pointed out in v.3:9, "What gain has the worker from his toil?" What i take this all to suggest is that humans are a part of nature, and nature consists of a natural balance of relationships, but because humans have such diverse experiences they are doomed to toil with the mystery of their own proper place in things. Sure, the Ten commandments say not to kill, as if this is a black-and-white, right-or-wrong world we live in, but Qoheleth is saying lets be honest, let's take a look at all of the natural processes taking place all around us, and admit that if all individuals do have an appointed place and time, what they do not have is an instruction manual telling them what their own place and time is. This my friends is why humans are doomed to a life of toiling.
In what i would call the second section of the passage, vv. 3:10-15, Qoheleth goes on to suggest that yeah, life is full of toil, but clearly that's how God made it. He says in v. 11, "he has put eternity into man's mind, yet so that he cannot find out what God has done from the beginning to the end." Qoheleth is saying, yeah we are never going to solve life's mysteries, or conquer anything ultimate, but that was never god's intention, and that type of mindset is a waste of time. Qohelth's message therefore, is to toil everyday knowing that v.3:12 "there is nothing better for them to be happy and enjoy themselves."
In what I would call the third section of the passage, vv. 3:10 - 4:8, Qoheleth is describing multiple realties of human experience to suggest that it makes no sense to toil for any particular thing or idea. Instead, humans ought to toil on behalf of a general experience of life that can be described as happy or enjoyable. The message here is that when we take joy in life, its source is never a particular thing or idea, but it is in fact an emergent from multiple things and ideas coming together in harmony. In vv. 3:16-21Qoheleth provides a set of what he would consider significant examples, to suggest that even the ideals of justice and righteousness are impure ideas, and even men can't be said to be a better thing than an animal is. In vv. 4:1-8, Qoheleth admits that there is absolutely nothing satisfying about living a life of oppression, and then goes onto suggest that even those who are free from the oppression of others, end up oppressing themselves by toiling vainly.
So, after acknowledging humanity's uncomfortable position in what appears to be a comfortably balanced universe, and after undermining any one who might want to think that man is special if he toils after a particular thing or idea, Qoheleth finally offers an approach to dealing with all the shit life gives you. I understand the teaching to go something likes this: As you toil in hopes of having an enjoyable experience keep in mind that "two are better than one" and "better is a poor and wise youth than an old and foolish king, who will no longer take advice." In short, the power to experience life in a positive way is obtained by consciously toiling alongside your fellow man, and never losing the will to learn from others.
Despite the abundance of vain toiling...Toil with the toils of others in mind, and never lose the will to toil some more.
I understand the first section of this passage to be 3:1-9. Qoheleth starts in v. 3:1 saying "for everything there is a season", and then goes on to show not only that everything is part of a cycle, but that nature possesses a certain sort of balance, or harmony. The problem with this reality is then pointed out in v.3:9, "What gain has the worker from his toil?" What i take this all to suggest is that humans are a part of nature, and nature consists of a natural balance of relationships, but because humans have such diverse experiences they are doomed to toil with the mystery of their own proper place in things. Sure, the Ten commandments say not to kill, as if this is a black-and-white, right-or-wrong world we live in, but Qoheleth is saying lets be honest, let's take a look at all of the natural processes taking place all around us, and admit that if all individuals do have an appointed place and time, what they do not have is an instruction manual telling them what their own place and time is. This my friends is why humans are doomed to a life of toiling.
In what i would call the second section of the passage, vv. 3:10-15, Qoheleth goes on to suggest that yeah, life is full of toil, but clearly that's how God made it. He says in v. 11, "he has put eternity into man's mind, yet so that he cannot find out what God has done from the beginning to the end." Qoheleth is saying, yeah we are never going to solve life's mysteries, or conquer anything ultimate, but that was never god's intention, and that type of mindset is a waste of time. Qohelth's message therefore, is to toil everyday knowing that v.3:12 "there is nothing better for them to be happy and enjoy themselves."
In what I would call the third section of the passage, vv. 3:10 - 4:8, Qoheleth is describing multiple realties of human experience to suggest that it makes no sense to toil for any particular thing or idea. Instead, humans ought to toil on behalf of a general experience of life that can be described as happy or enjoyable. The message here is that when we take joy in life, its source is never a particular thing or idea, but it is in fact an emergent from multiple things and ideas coming together in harmony. In vv. 3:16-21Qoheleth provides a set of what he would consider significant examples, to suggest that even the ideals of justice and righteousness are impure ideas, and even men can't be said to be a better thing than an animal is. In vv. 4:1-8, Qoheleth admits that there is absolutely nothing satisfying about living a life of oppression, and then goes onto suggest that even those who are free from the oppression of others, end up oppressing themselves by toiling vainly.
So, after acknowledging humanity's uncomfortable position in what appears to be a comfortably balanced universe, and after undermining any one who might want to think that man is special if he toils after a particular thing or idea, Qoheleth finally offers an approach to dealing with all the shit life gives you. I understand the teaching to go something likes this: As you toil in hopes of having an enjoyable experience keep in mind that "two are better than one" and "better is a poor and wise youth than an old and foolish king, who will no longer take advice." In short, the power to experience life in a positive way is obtained by consciously toiling alongside your fellow man, and never losing the will to learn from others.
Despite the abundance of vain toiling...Toil with the toils of others in mind, and never lose the will to toil some more.
More Meaninglessness and Repetition
Qoheleth begins chapter 3 by making a long list of antithetical pairs. As everything else in his cosmos, it seems to be a list of repetitive cycles, continuing on into eternity, never resting. I'll be the first to admit, I've always had some problems with this oft quoted passage. I'm not so sure about a time to kill, a time for war, and a time to hate. Back in the first group of posts, Cayce Guy made the suggestion in a comment that these things less had an appointed time or season, and were more things that Qoheleth simply thought always were and always would be. The Byrds' song, "Turn, Turn, Turn," based on the song's upbeat sound, seems to take a happier stance toward the meaning of this passage (http://bit.ly/2gBEVY). The Byrds, however, are meaningless and they're not saying anything new, because there is nothing new. As I continue through the chapter, Qoheleth surprises me with 3:11, "[G-d] has made everything beautiful in it's time." Qoheleth reiterates that he can fin nothing better for men to do (in my reading, no better answer to the meaninglessness he sees) than for us all to enjoy our chasing after the wind while we can, because simple joys (gifts) come from G-d.
Thoughts on an afterlife? In 3:15-17 Qoheleth makes reference to G-d bringing judgment to both the wicked and the righteous and calling all of their actions into account. On my first read through for the first blog, this was the only mention I remember of G-d justly calling into account the actions of men. Does this mean Qoheleth believes in an afterlife? Not necessarily. This passage is immediately followed by a discourse on the uncertainty on what happens to the soul and whether or not our fate is different from that of the animals (3:18-22). Any thoughts on that?
Chapter 4 finds Qoheleth completely returning to his tone of depression and hopelessness. Qoheleth states that he sees the tears of the oppressed, and how all the power is in the hands of their oppressors. Rather than doing something about this (which he should be completely able to from his supposed kingship), Qoheleth decides that it's better to be dead or to never have been born at all (4:1-3). Remember all that volunteer work you've done? Well, you only did it because you were envious of your neighbor. In 4:4 Qoheleth argues that there's no such thing as a selfless action, and all our labor is hevel. It is better to work with someone else and have a friend than to be alone, because two can produce more and can more easily keep safe (4:9-12). If I had to guess though, the work you do with a friend, while more productive, is still meaningless. Qoheleth finishes out the chapter by saying that a poor youth is better than an old foolish king (4:13). This poor youth has potential to become a great leader, even to become the next king. In the long run though, people won't like him, and his rise from poverty to kingship will all have been, you guessed it, meaningless (4:14-16).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)