This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Monday, September 6, 2010
Everything Sucks and You are Going to Die Like an Animal...but Cheer Up and Enjoy Yourself
Sunday, September 5, 2010
Ecc. 3:1-4:16 :: How to Doublethink
Koheleth's skeptical view that life is hardly worth living is permissible because he does not fully bite onto that bait. Rather than completely giving up on life, he represses his underlying negativity and theorizes ways to get by in life, while he has to. For example, in Ecc. 3:21-22, Koheleth opens saying, “Who knows if a man's lifebreath does rise upward and if a beast's breath does sink down into the earth?,” representing his unresolved view of what eventually is to come of all of life. In 3:22 he then resolves and devises a practical way to live with his unsettled heart, writing, “I saw that there is nothing better for man than to enjoy his possessions, since that is his portion. For who can enable him to see what will happen afterword?” Neither Koheleth nor any man can see with a divine perspective and know whether anything is worth any effort, but we continue to try anyways because the risk of completely giving up outweighs the sacrifice of what we could reap from trying. To this point, Koheleth seems to cling to the spark of hope that life, perhaps when viewed from upside-down, will eventually have meaning and to not let himself fully cave into the tempting and engulfing wave of hevel.
Thursday, September 2, 2010
Sorry bout the late post
The idea of "chasing after the wind" is applied to all pursuit of a better life. I thought for a while that the moral of this teaching was to be content with what you already have rather than to stargaze your whole life. The pursuit of something more always leaves you with more material possessions, but the feeling of emptiness upon discovering what else there is to be had that you don't already have will always remain with you and eventually break you. This led me to believe in being thankful for what you already have, but the teacher then appears to even speak against that as well. Ecclesiastes 2:3 talks about the teacher's attempt at complacency, but says that with the knowledge and wisdom he already had gained, it was pointless and futile to try to fool his own mind into believing a reality that he knew wasn't true. So many contradictory thoughts.....
"Would Not Come" by Alanis Morissette speaks directly about a more modern take on the pursuit of something more. Everything that she thought would bring he peace of mind and happiness just left her aching for what else she didn't have. All of these things that were suppossed to fill that emptiness that comes from knowing about what you don't have never went away, and no matter what she achieved, who she spoke to, and what she tried to do to take her mind off of her restlessness, the joy to occupy that empty space in her heart "would not come".
This modern experience coupled with the teacher's further documentation of his views on the futility of everything in life really does paint a more bleak picture of the book of Ecclesiastes if one looks at life as the viscious circular cycle of wanting, but never gaining; trying to forget this sorrow from "a chasing after the wind" but knowing that the truth in your mind will never go away. Reality is haunting, isn't it?
Wednesday, September 1, 2010
wisdom and folly
In Ecclesiastes 1:12-2:26 Qoheleth describes his search for wisdom and pleasure that, in the end, he deems to be futile. In 1:12-1:17 he tells the reader of his qualifications, of the circumstances and deeds that make him wise enough and experienced enough to discourse on wisdom and futility with authority. In 1:12-13 he states that “I, Qoheleth was king in Jerusalem over Israel. I set my mind to study and to probe with wisdom all that happens under the sun.” In 1:14 he reiterates “I observed all the happenings beneath the sun.” and in 1:16, yet again, “Here I have grown richer and wiser than any that ruled before me over Jerusalem and my mind has zealously absorbed wisdom and learning.” Qoheleth is making it clear that he has made a life’s work of acquiring wisdom and that he did so in an attempt to bring meaning to his life. Yet in his search he “observed all the happenings beneath the sun, and I found that all is futile and pursuit of wind: A twisted thing that cannot be made straight, a lack that cannot be made good (1:14-15).” His pursuit of wisdom, he finally learns, is fruitless. Fox’s commentary analyzes this with great clarity, saying: “Not only are all things senseless, but also they cannot be improved […] Koheleth is resigned to the intractability of the world’s fundamental wrongs.”
In 2:1-26, Qoheleth attempts to make another go at finding meaning, this time through pleasure. “I ventured to tempt my flesh with wine, and to grasp folly, while letting my mind direct with wisdom, to the end that I might learn which of the two was better for men to practice in their few days of life under heaven (2:3).” He finds that this, too, is “all futile and pursuit of wind (2:11).” Though later in chapter 2 he declares that “wisdom is superior to folly/ As light is superior to darkness (2:13),” he concludes that “the same fate awaits them both (2:14). Though Qoheleth finds some comfort in wisdom and in pleasing God, he inevitably concludes that no matter what wisdom or pleasure he partakes in, he will eventually die and eventually be forgotten, just as the fool also dies and is forgotten.
No Reason to Follow God?
Although Qohelet is not advocating that a higher power does not exist, it does seem that in Ecclesiastes 1:12 - 2:26 that he is suggesting that this higher power does not process any qualities that make Him worthy of our admiration. This part of Ecclesiastes is a testimony of Qohelet’s struggle with the actual vanity of believing in God.
In 1:13, Qohelet expresses that he believes that God gave wisdom to humans in order for them to learn about the ways in which the world operates, but goes on to let his readers know that this gift from God has made him extremely unhappy. It is almost like Qohelet views the relationship between God, wisdom, and humans as an evil game created for God’s amusement at the expense of humans. In verses 1:16-18, Qohelet realizes that because he has participated in God’s “wisdom game” he has received a great deal of sorrow.
It seems that Qohelet does not like the argument that he is making, because at the beginning of chapter 2 he begins to try to disprove his own idea. He speaks of how he no longer found enjoyment in pleasure because of his wisdom, but still attempted to convince himself that there was something to be gained from life. In verses 4-11, he explains to the reader the extent to which he tried to dissuade himself from his pervious notion. It is important to note that Qohelet admits that he did feel pleasure in the moment of his toil, but became dissatisfied because the pleasure of the moment passes once the moment is gone, which still results in no net gain.
This small bit of pleasure is important to Qohelet, because in 2:13 he starts to hint that he thinks wisdom may have an intrinsic value in and of itself. He explains that at least the wise have eyes to see, when the fools just walk in darkness. I am unsure as to whether he means that it is better to at least know that you are in darkness, or if he means that those who have eyes are seeing something better than darkness, such as light. Regardless of what Quohelet was feeling, he quickly neglects this positive outlook for a more negative tone. He begins to mourn the fact that the wise come to the same end in death as the foolish. Qohelet circles his argument one last time by offering the idea that even the fleeting pleasures of the moment come from God. This causes the reader to have hope that Quohelet is going to come to the conclusion that we should enjoy the moment and rejoice that God has given us this ability. Unfortunately, Quohelet crushes this hope by pointing out that since the moment is so vain, that we were not any better off in the end for having enjoyed it. This leads the reader to conclude that Qohelet thinks that the only gain from God is pleasure in the moment, but since the pleasure of the moment is not lasting, there is no actual gain from following the will of God.
Joy from God
In chapter two, Qohelet first describes how he tried to find meaning in pleasure. Verses three through nine relate the luxuries and joys Qohelet had. Twice in this verses Qohelet makes the point that he maintained his wisdom throughout his search for pleasure. This could possibly be to make clear that he never lost himself to pleasure and that perhaps those who devote themselves entirely to pleasure and “folly” (1:3) do not suffer the frustration of searching for purpose and meaning. Similarly, the Kanye West song “Diamonds from Sierra Leone” relates a pleasure filled existence. The singer seems only interested in prestige and material wealth, but rather than being utterly lost to pleasure, the singer, like Qohelet, questions the lasting significance of his joys (“Forever ever? Forever, ever? Ever, ever?”). In contrast, the Alanis Morissette song “Would Not Come” echoes the frustrations of Qohelet. The singer finds that no pleasure or efforts ever bring fulfillment (“I’d be the hero and still it would not come,” “I’d be filthy rich and still it would not come”). Additionally, the sense of chaos in the music depicts the senselessness of the world that has no meaning.
Despite the depressing message of the passage, verses twenty four through twenty six offer hope. In verse twenty four, Qohelet states that “a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work.” As Brown explains in his interpretation of Ecclesiastes, “no longer is enjoyment to be gained from one’s toil; it is recognized as part and parcel of one’s work, discerned within the labor, an intrinsic joy” (p. 38). Thus, although the world and all of our actions in it is meaningless, there is hope in the joys of simple gifts. Additionally, Qohelet states that these joys are “from the hand of God, for without him, who can eat or find enjoyment?” (2:24-25). Because our ability to experience pleasure is itself a gift from God, pleasure cannot be found in one’s own searching. Rather, pleasure and joy are experienced in the basic necessities of life that God gives us. For Qohelet, the world is meaningless and without God, the world is not only meaningless, but also without any pleasure.
Still it would not come.
Ecclesiastes 1:12 – 2:26 is rich in content, and a lot can be said about these verses. For me, wisdom is the most interesting aspect of this passage because of the different ways Qohelet talks about wisdom and meaning. As I read this text, especially 2:9-23, I felt that he was not saying that wisdom is necessarily bad, but rather he was resigning to the fact that wisdom does not change the fact that death is inevitable, and someone will take over all the things left behind. 2:24-26 goes on to say that a man “can do no better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work.” Worrying about who will get the things you’ve toiled for is meaningless because it’s not going to be any different. Rather, things are given from God and should be appreciated. Though wisdom can be a burden, God gives the “man who pleases him” the ability to gain that knowledge and understand that true fulfillment is unattainable.
Something I found really interesting in Fox’s commentary was a discussion of part of 1:13 (“I set my mind…”). Fox translates it to “I set my heart” and goes on to talk about Qohelet’s distinction between his heart and his ego. Qohelet speaks to his heart and explores in his heart, as if it is a completely separate person. Reading the text with this in mind put a new spin on it. It was interesting to swap “myself” with “heart” and look at how it changed the tone or content of the text.
Finally, I think Alanis Morissette's “Would Not Come” was such a reflection of Ecclesiastes 1:12 – 2:26. That feeling of never being fulfilled, of obtaining or changing things, was vey clear in the lyrics. “I’d be filthy rich and still it would not come. I would seduce them and still it would not come. I would drink vodka and still it would not come…if I accumulate knowledge I’ll be impenetrable.” Wealth, pleasure, and drink are not fully satisfying. The idea that accumulating knowledge will cause impenetrability (but in reality it will not)…where have we heard that before? I feel Alanis captures Qohelet’s attitude in just four minutes, and adds a new layer to the question of fulfillment.