Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Dear Lord, Please don't pawn me off on Satan

This was my first time reading all the way through the book of Job, and unfortunately, I found it significantly more depressing than the book of Ecclesiastes. In the beginning of the book, God gets together with all of the heavenly beings and decides to use Job (a man who was “blameless and upright, one who feared God and turned away from evil”- Job 1:1) in a bet against Satan. God then allows Satan to take away all of Job’s possessions and his 10 children. As if that wasn’t enough, Job is then inflicted with boils over his entire body.

The next several chapters of the book focus on Job and three of his friends who have come to comfort him. Job repeatedly speaks of his innocence before God and his desire to speak with God about his punishment. His friends repeatedly respond by telling him that he must have done something wrong, because God wouldn’t inflict punishment on someone without just cause.

The book ends with God rebuking Job for his questioning of his punishment. God demonstrates his dominion over the earth, thus humbling Job. After God’s rebuke of Job, he goes to his friends and tells them that they must makes sacrifices, and ask Job to pray for them, because they have ”not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has” (Job 42:7). God then restores the fortunate of Job, giving him twice as much as he had before.

There were several things that I found troubling about the book of Job. 1.) Why is God so eager to use Job in a bet against Satan? Am I the only one who finds this to be extremely terrifying and contradictory to some of the other depictions of the Old Testament God? 2.) Why is Job’s questioning of God’s punishment completely unacceptable to both his friends and God? Isn’t it necessary to seek God in order to repent and thenceforth change one’s actions? 3.) What is God’s view of Job at the end of the text? It is evident from the last chapter that God believes Job has continued to be faithful. My question is if God believes this, why did he rebuke him for several chapters before that? Was it merely to continue to humble him?

Unfortunately, after the first reading I have not been able to come up with any pleasant conclusions about the book of Job. It seems to me that the book of Job is saying the following: God has ultimate control over everything, and it doesn’t matter if you are a good person, he still might choose to pawn you off on Satan and make your life suck for a while. Don’t worry though, because eventually he will humble you and restore your former wealth.

Can you pull in the Leviathan with a fishhook?

Job presents some very interesting concepts and questions. In the beginning of Job we have G-d being swayed by Satan to allow the "testing" of Job. This sets the stage for the long dialogue that follows between Job, his friends, and finally G-d himself. A large theme of the book seems to be one that was touched on in Ecclesiastes, stemming from the idea that G-d is in heaven and we are on earth. Job is told not to challenge or to question G-d -- it is not his right as the creation to challenge the Creator. He can't even pull in the Leviathan that G-d created with a fishhook.

Job's friends throughout the dialogue push for him to repent of his sin, whatever that may be. In what seems to be the worldview held by Proverbs, they believe that as long as you live a righteous life, you will be rewarded. Only the sinful are punished. This runs as another common theme with Qoheleth, who seems to disagree with the truth of this worldview. Job insists that he has done nothing wrong. He questions G-d's judgment.

There seems to be a distinction between questioning and challenging G-d in the book of Job. To challenge G-d is wrong. Challenging G-d is to assume the possibility that G-d made a bad decision or didn't think things through enough. It's a challenge to G-d's perfection. This may be wrong because as humans, we cannot fully understand the will of G-d (like our old friend Qoheleth). To question G-d though does not seem to be as big of an issue. After questioning why he is being made to suffer, Job is still praised for his righteousness. Job was not presuming that G-d might be in the wrong. Rather, he was trying to understand how G-d was in the right.

A few final thoughts that don't really go into paragraphs: What is the role of Satan before G-d at the beginning of the book? What is a Behemoth? What is a Leviathan, and can I have one? Presumably, it can live underwater for 30 minutes or more, and is technically dorm friendly. Might have issues fitting it in a 20 gallon tank though.

Have you considered my servant Job?

One of the first thoughts that came to mind as I was reading Job is that this book has a much more clearly defined structure than Ecclesiastes. Both books are quite poetic and both have somewhat of an underlying structure, though the structure in Ecclesiastes is, at times, quite loose. Job, however, has a more defined structure that seems to work to further the narrative in a clearer, more concise manner.


The beginning of the book (Chapters 1 and 2) are in prose. They set up the story of Job, letting the reader know of the tragedies that befell him and why. They serve as an introduction and a background to the poetic conversations between Job and his friends. The final section of the book (Chapter 42 verses 7-17) is also in prose and neatly finishes the story of Job in a straightforward, epilogue fashion. This occurs after the Lord finally answers Job's questions about his misfortune and Job repents.


I wonder if this narrative style of poetry bookended by prose is simply a narrative technique or whether it has thematic elements. The tragedies that befall Job and later the prosperity that the Lord returns to him are both concrete elements to the story. They are the only parts that have to do with action rather than speaking or questioning. They are also the only parts that occur in prose, rather than in poetic style. The poetic elements of Job occur in his questioning of God and in the debates with his friends. Perhaps this poetic nature is somehow related to the abstract aspects of Job's questing or of his friend's extolling the virtues of God. It does seem, however, that Job resolves itself much more neatly than did Ecclesiastes. Despite the troubles Job faces in the beginning, he finds answers in the end, repents, and his fortune is restored. This book seems to reaffirm Job's worldview rather than tearing it down.

I hope God isn't making bets with Satan about me...

My initial reading of Job left me feeling more confused and depressed than any reading from Ecclesiastes. The idea that God would use one of creatures in a bet against Satan is not only terrifying, but also disturbing. Moreover, it completely contradicts God’s promise in Jeremiah 29:11, which reads “For surely I know the plans I have for you, says the Lord, plan for your welfare and not to harm to give you a future with hope.” Surely Job has a right to want to question God and defend himself. I thought it was especially interesting that in 2:9-10, when Job’s wife encourages him to turn against God, Job refuses, asking “shall we receive the good at the hand of God, and not receive the bad?” And yet, his friends accuse him of sin.

I also agree with a previous post about how the concept of questioning that was depicted in Ecclesiastes is considered sinful here in Job. Is it possible to seek God without being able to question?

One aspect of Job that I did appreciate was how God, though he reprimanded Job, also reprimanded his friends. I felt that the friends were saying that if God was punishing Job, then Job must have done something to deserve the punishment. To me, the friends displayed more arrogance than Job by believing that they had a complete understanding of the nature of God. Clearly this is not the case, as Job’s suffering was not a consequence of his sin, but ironically, was due to his righteousness.

I think one way to read Job would be as something like a parable. This might just be me trying to explain away God offering Job up to Satan, but since God’s actions in this story are so opposite of the just and loving God described throughout the Old and New Testaments, I think it’s plausible to consider the possibility of Job being more fiction than literal. Viewed as a parable, I think the book of Job could be used to depict that the workings of God cannot be known or understood by humans; rather, just as Job and his friends were unaware of the bet between God and Satan, as humans, we do not have the full picture.

The moral of the story is....

I’m not sure if Job is supposed to be a man who really lived, or if it is simply a story with a hidden meaning behind it. However, I’m not exactly sure what the meaning would be as throughout the book God seems uninterested in Job’s plight. The writer focuses more on God’s power/sovereignty. Is the book about “why isn’t God helping me” or “is God all I need in life”?

Chapter one, verse one says Job has perfect integrity, feared God and turned away from evil. God tells Satan these things about Job, and Satan says Job is only that way because God has blessed him and placed a hedge around him, that surely Job would curse God if his possessions were taken away (vv. 9-11). God gives Satan power over basically everything that is valuable to Job, though Satan is not allowed to do anything directly to him (Job).

Satan goes on to take Job’s possessions away and kill Job’s offspring. God then gives Satan permission to directly influence Job, but he is not allowed to take Job’s life. Job is afflicted with boils, and his wife encourages him to “curse God and die” (v. 2:9). Job calls her foolish, but curses the day he was born.

After Job speaks with his friends, God speaks to him. God criticizes Job’s friends for their stupidity and tells them to arrange burnt offerings. In the end, Job regains his health and is blessed with ten new children.

I think the book of Job, true or not, may simply be about how to suffer when bad times come. Recently so many people ask “why do bad things happen to good people?” and this book prompts one to think about that. Even though this question isn’t directly answered in the book, one can raise many interesting questions simply by reading.

The World is God's Casino

So apparently God makes bets with Satan.  The Book of Job begins with God, some angels, and Satan having a little get together.  Satan says what he's been up to and then God decides to suggest that Satan checks out Job who God says is "blameless and upright".  Job would probably continued to live his nice life if God had not told Satan about him because Satan challenges God on Job’s faith in God.  Satan thinks that Job will curse God if bad stuff happens to him.  I guess it is good that God has faith in Job, but it seems like God and Satan are playing games with each other and, unfortunately, Job gets caught in between.  So Satan goes and kills Job’s family and destroys his wealth.  When Job does not curse God, Satan goes back to God and God lets him bring more bad fortune to Job.  Nice. After this Job and his friends talk for a long time and Job still does not curse God. Finally, God appears to Job and tells him that He knows everything about everything and Job repents.  I’m not sure if he’s repenting for speaking of things he can understand (42:3) or even questioning why bad stuff was happening to him.  God rewards Job with even more wealth than he had before and he replaces his children because a family is replaceable when they’re more attractive than the old one.


Unlike in Ecclesiastes, God and Satan (evil personified?) are actually seen in Job.  We have insight to what God is up to.  We learn that evil does not come from God which is why bad things happen to good people.  However, God lets evil happen. At least that’s what I got from it and putting it that way (in more general terms) does not make God seem so bad.  Perhaps Job is an extreme example used to teach that lesson.

Let's not drag this whole thing out any longer.

The first two chapters of the book of Job start out as an interesting little folk tale of God, Satan, some heavenly beings, Job and his family. Satan tells God he’s been gallivanting around the Earth and God has to go and bring up his most righteous servant Job. Satan states that the only reason Job is such a great servant is because of all the great things God has done for him. God makes a deal with the Devil and mayhem ensues. Satan destroys all of Jobs many possessions and then depletes his health. After all of this Job still stands strong and does not curse God. This was about as much of Job that I was familiar with, but apparently there's more, a lot more.

Jobs three friends then come and visit, after they sit in silence for a week they start giving their opinions on the issue. Eliphaz is the first to speak, starting in chapter 4; he discusses the amazing things God has done for the “innocent”. Eliphaz advises Job to seek God and acknowledge his sins before him. Eliphaz says, “As I have seen, those who plow iniquity and sow trouble reap the same” showing that he must believe God is a just one. He seems to think Job must have done something to deserve all the disasters, but if he goes to God, talks it over and admits to his sins, everything will turn out all right. Bildad comes in chapter 8; he has the same understanding of Gods actions as Eliphaz does. If Job has been completely sin free, there would be no reason for God to touch him, and if you are going through trials you just need to repent and things should get better. Zophar speaks in chapter 11, and doesn’t really hold anything back. I’m not really sure you could call this guy a friend of Job because the whole time he is speaking he is pretty much calling Job a liar. His advice is the same as the other “friends”, admit that you are a stinky, no-good, lying asshole and God will probably make everything better. The dialogue between Job and the men was pretty lengthy, a few of the chapters could have been cut out. The main points of the friends were made pretty quickly and the rest just seemed like a bunch of ramble.

Even after these three men have accused Job of not being as holy as he says he is, Job stands firm in the belief that he really is pure. He never once curses God, he simply ask him for some kind of explanation as to why these things have happened to him. God finally replies, and quite frankly isn’t very nice about things. I find it interesting that even after God puts Job in his place, he warns the other men of how they were speaking and ends up giving Job twice the riches he had before. I don’t really understand why God was so mean to Job when he talked with him, it seems like he could’ve just given him an explanations, his possessions back, and moved on.