Wednesday, October 6, 2010

God, You Need a Time-Out

Job’s wife seems to be the realist in the bunch with her advice to “Curse God, and die” in Job 2:9. Even though Job renders her remark foolish, through out the entire book of Job, I found myself wondering exactly who was the fool, Job or his wife, or even God.

By the end of the Book of Job, I had decided that essentially every character (including God, but excluding Job’s wife) can be considered foolish. God may even be the most foolish of fools. God clearly had the upmost admiration from quite a few people, especially Job. Even if Job and his friends did not agree on a whole lot, they did agree that God was mighty and should be respected. However, all of this glory was not enough for God. God was tempted by the tauntings of Satan and God’s weakness resulted in mass suffering. Job’s ten children and numerous servants were killed because of God’s need to be seen as even greater than he already was seen. The hell on Job’s Earth that God caused is a good example of the problems that are likely to result when people are never satisfied.

Job and his friends are all foolish for the same reason: they are unwilling to give up a worldview that is harmful and incompatible with life experience. Job’s friends are so convinced that they know how some Other Being operating off the planet works that they cannot sympathize with the suffering of a person that is right in front of them. Although this is ridiculous, Job may be even more pitituful because he knows with out a doubt that he is innocent and still clings to the idea that God is just and worthy of his admiration.

Feeling sympathy for Job and his friends is permissible—even though they are foolish, they are still just humans, and in their defense they are being duped by a Higher Power. I do feel sorry for these fellows, but I’m aggravated at God. If God is so shallow that he needs to cause major pain for kicks or to get some kind of an ego boost, then this God is not worthy of our admiration. This God is worthy of a time-out (or maybe something more severe).

The Psychology of Job...maybe

When reading Job, I can’t help but notice how wonderfully it contradicts the idea of a belief in a just world. This belief is a topic of psychology that explains people’s desire to believe that people get what they deserve. This belief is at work when people ask questions like “why do bad things happen to good people,” and for this reason I think it is applicable to Job. The most interesting aspect of applying this theory to Job is that not only does the reader possibly have trouble accepting the events that transpire in Job’s life but even Job’s “friends” can’t help but believe that he must have done something to deserve what happens to him. I appreciate the book of Job because it challenges people to realize that no matter what justifications people can come up with for why bad things happen to others, negative experiences are a part of life…and not just for bad people.
I also noticed quite a bit of defensive attribution in Job which I think is, in part, due to the need to preserve a belief in a just world. Defensive attribution is a mechanism by which people make up excuses for why something bad happened to someone else in order to make themselves feel like it wouldn’t happen to them. I think this is what Job’s friends were doing when they insisted that he had done something to deserve the terrible things that were happening to him. Because these men are normal human beings who obviously have a hard time believing that God would do such awful things to someone who doesn’t deserve it, they justify it by finding reasons that will: 1) make the experiences seem just and 2) make it seem like they won’t go through the same experiences.
Overall I think there’s a lot to learn from Job. I don’t think these lessons only involve some kind of heartwarming moral story about having faith in God and the experiences he puts us through. The most important lesson to learn is that God is in control of our lives and no matter what we’ve done or how good we think we are, we might encounter terrible experiences because that’s what God feels we need.

Learning to be Depressed All Over Again

Between Tuesday afternoon and Wednesday evening, I experienced a something that I had not felt in weeks. Was it optimism, hope, joy? I can never be sure. That fleeting feeling quickly came to an end when I cracked open my JPS bible to start reading Job. Just like when reading Ecclesiastes, I was taken on a tour of abject human suffering and unanswerable philosophical quandaries. What I found while reading Job, though is the same problem that I've had since I first heard the Job story. Why exactly does God punish Job, why does he feel the need? To prove a point to Satan? Or is it just "part of his divine plan"? I find it very troublesome that an all-knowing, all-powerful deity would feel the need to test such a pious man. Now it's true that in the end Job gets twice what he had before, but to me that doesn't put to rest my problems with the book. As far as the structure of the book goes, I found it strange that the extended dialogue was wedged between the two narrative sections. I thought that the narrative story of Job would take up more of the book than it did. Although I new that Job was categorized as a wisdom text, I did not expect so much pontificating on the part of Job and his friends. It was often very difficult to read all of the (not undeserved) "woe is me" text. Job was just so, so very depressed about his admittedly horrible situation. Job's descriptions of his troubles often provided terrible details about his situation that the narrative text did not.

Why can't anyone answer Job's questions???

Job is a book filled with contradictions and tension within itself that I surprisingly found more depressing than Qohelet. The book does have a more concise structure with narrative at the beginning and end with a poetic debate in the middle.

Job, the main character of the book, was one the greatest men of his time. He was “blameless and upright”, and he “feared God and turned away from evil” (1:1). Job was also very wealthy and had seven sons and three daughters. But, one day Satan comes along and challenges God to test Job to see if he truly is a righteous man of God. So God destroys everything he has and kills his children all in the same day. Of course Job is devastated however, Job does not claim that God did anything wrong. After this, Satan again challenges God to test Job. God allows Satan to attack Job’s health this time by afflicting him with sores covering his body. Once again, Job does not blame God for this or even question why he has done this (1:2-2:10).

Job has three friends that come to try to console him and this is where the poetic argument begins. This is also where the contradictions begin. In the narrative Job did not blame God or even question his actions however here Job begins complaining about his life and saying that he should not have been born. Job’s three companions keep offering him reasons that this has happened to him; they say he surely must have sinned and that he must deserve this punishment. Job persists and says that he has done no wrong. Why does Job accept his fate in the narrative but defend his righteousness in the poetry?

In his arguments Job questions the sufferings of the innocent and why such bad things happen to righteous people but his companions have no good answer for him. Then a fourth person, Elihu, attempts to provide an answer. Elihu is mad at Job for only justifying himself and he is mad at his friends for not providing him with the correct answer. Elihu argues that God is righteous and majestic and that God “does not recard any who are wise in their on conceit” (37:24b). Elihu’s answer seems to be a contradiction in itself. Job has all these tough questions about the suffering of the innocent but Elihu’s answer is simply “God is good.”

Then in chapters 38 and 39 God speaks directly to Job asking him if he knows all these things that only God could know. Then in chapter 40 verse 2 God tells Job to respond to this; Job says he has nothing to say. Then God challenges Job to stand against the Behemoth and the Leviathan, two of God’s greatest creations. Here Job concedes to God claiming that he did not understand and that God’s will cannot be stopped and Job repents.

Job’s difficult questions such as the suffering of innocent people were not answered even by God. Why does Job allow this? Does he just give up? Does God reward him at the end just to keep him quiet so he will stop asking these difficult questions? This book ends very sadly to me even though the main character enjoys a happy ending being rewarded with twice as much as he had in the first place… with none of his questions answered.

Oh Job...

God makes two deals with Satan in order to prove Job’s faith. God first asks Satan to take away all of Job’s possessions, his servants, his livestock, his children, everything, but Job still does not blame God for his misery. Then God, asks Satan to harm him physically and Satan gives Job horrible sores all over his body. Job still does not curse God.

Job’s three friends visit him and they begin to talk about why such misfortune has fell upon Job. Each friend seems to think that Job has done something to deserve this pain and that he needs to repent to God in order to regain his favor. However, Job continues to respond that he has been faithful and that he has done nothing to offend God. Then Elihu starts to speak and he explains that the reason God is causing all of this suffering is because he wants Job to realize the magnitude of God’s love and his forgiveness. Elihu also believes that the reason Job is suffering is because he has committed some evil in his life.

God finally speaks and says to Job that he can do all things and that everything he does is for a purpose. Job then repents and God restores all of Job’s fortune and gives him seven sons and three daughters, just to prove that Job is back in his good graces.

I’m not sure how I feel about God’s role in the Book of Job. It seems to me that God, while he does not perform the evil by himself, asks Satan to make Job’s life miserable just because he can. The evil isn’t to punish him or to teach him anything, it’s because God is toying with him and is trying to prove that Job is faithful. I also wonder why Job gets to have all of his riches and fortunes returned and then doubled. This doesn’t seem to be realistic at all. Is God saying here, let me use you and show your suffering off, because soon I will double your riches and life will be wonderful again. I wish everything worked like that. I’m frustrated with God is this book because it seems that God is just using Job as a pawn is his game and still doesn’t have the courtesy to explain himself when he comes to talk to Job.

Put Your Big Girl Panties on and Deal with It!

Well, we have now descended into another tragic and self loathing story with a seemingly difficult plot. During the prologue, we are introduced to Job, who is "blameless and upright", he worked hard and pleased God so he was favored with plentiful crop, sons and daughters, beautiful land and stock, and many servants. Well, God decides to place a bet with the devil, betting that no matter what the devil puts Job through he shall not turn his back to him. God proceeds to allow Satan to take away all of his worldly possessions, including his ten children, then gets a nasty case of boils covering his entire body. Poor Job.

After all of these incidents, Job and a few of his friends, sit for seven entire days and nights, while Job proceeds to bitch and complain for thirty-six entire chapters. He repeatedly whines to his friends of his innocence during his entire life and he has lived only for God, his friends tell him on the other hand that no son of man is perfect and can live without sin, that there must be a reason for God's anger towards Job. This concept is rather common through Ecclesiastes as well, sinners are supposed to be the only one's that God punishes, and the back and forth controversy in which both Qoheleth and Job experience while trying to decipher the meaning of their "vaporous" lives.

Like Ecclesiastes, there are a few things that bother me and a few questions about the reading, first why is Job so eager to blame God and his power for everything that has happened to him? God has told us that what he gives, he can also take, sorry Job. Two, why was God so persistent that Job be the one to be punished? He has always proven his loyalty to his God, why let Satan hurt and almost destroy one of your most adamant followers? Also, while reading Job 14:5, Job states, "Man's days are determined, you have decreed the number of his months, and you have set limits he can not succeed," I believe that Job is saying that even his turmoil was predestined, that God had always planned to build him up to be the man that he was then watch him crumble.

I also have at least one good thing to say about Job, I like it better than reading Qoheleth because Job actually has a reason to be a cry baby unlike Qoheleth. He lost everything but proved himself faithful to God after everything that God had allowed to be done to him and I never saw that in Ecclesiastes.

This is my first time to ever open the book of Job and at first glance, it scares me to death, I understand that everything was made to be okay between God and Job in the Epilogue but wow, it scares me that someone, even God, can control your life in such a way that he can take anything at any time he please and for any reason. Also, that there is no free will, God has predestined every movement and gesture you will ever say. Wow, religion is scary.

Job: Another Depressing Story (but not as much as Ecc.)

My first emotion while reading Job was excitement because we finally are reading something with an easy, straight forward structure. Unlike Ecc. the book of Job follows a specific outline: Job's life. It begins with an introduction to Job's character. He is described as a blessed man who lives righteously. Then God, all the angels, and Satan have a little meet n' greet. Here, Satan challenges Job's integrity, proposing to God that Job serves him only because God protects him. To prove Satan wrong, God agrees on the bet and removes Job's protections, allowing Satan to take his family, wealth, and then overall physical well being in order to tempt Job into cursing God. I found this strange and quite unsettling. I'm not sure that I would want to be the foundation of a bet between the two figures who represent all good and all evil. To respond to another person's blog, I don't think that it completely contradicts Gods promise in Jeremiah 29:11. God was certain that Job wouldn't curse him. God knew that Job was going to continue to be loyal and faithful. I think that God knew beforehand that Satan wanted to make a bet with God, if he didn't know, i don't think that God would have agreed.

After Satan had his chance to screw up Job's life, Job still didn't cave in. Despite his difficult circumstances, Job didn't curse God. Although he protests his dilemmas and begs for an explanation, he stops short of accusing God of injustice. At first I was annoyed with Job and all his whining and "woe is me" crap, but afterwards I was greatly impressed with Jobs integrity. Job never cursed God, I'm pretty sure if I lost my entire family, fortune, and health that cursing God would be the first thing to leave my lips. Job was the opposite, he still believed in God and confessed his loyalty but asked Him legitimate questions. I think that this might be an underlying theme or purpose of the book of Job, being able to sustain your faith in the Almighty but ask real and personal questions. Like Ecc, Job allows for some questioning in faith.

At the end of the book when God replied to Job, I really appreciated that God also responded to Job's friends. Personally, Job's friends annoyed me more than Job (they seemed more prideful). With God replying to both sets of people, it made it seem as though God wasn't just letting Job's life unravel and not paying any attention, but, in fact, God was watching, seeing, and hearing with the utmost scrutiny. God wasn't distant from Job, He was right there the whole time, paying attention.

The one thing that frustrated me was at the end when God replied, He didn't give a direct response to the question(s) Job demanded. Job just laid back and accepted God as all-knowing and humans as limited mortals. Even though Job was humbled and satisfied, he didn't get the answer to his original question,which i believe is the dominant theme of the book: the difficulty of understanding why an all powerful God allows good people to suffer.