This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Wednesday, September 15, 2010
Better to Live, or to Never Be Born?
Apparently we should all envy the man who doesn't have to suffer through 1.) The trials and tribulations of this life any longer (as stated in earlier chapters) 2.) They don't half to walk in circles any longer seeking a peace of mind and feeling of fulfilment that will never come and 3.) The realization that in the end, according to the teacher, joy is stupid anyway and the more you mourn and suffer the wiser you are, so thank God you don't have to deal with that anymore. The Qoheleth says a man should not be overwise, but he does assert that it is good to be wise. This almost points to a masochistic lifestyle since wisdom seems to be another word for suffering.
Qoheleth is Meaningless, Yet he Still Has his Moments
Despite the fact that Qoheleth eventually does offer advice for how to cultivate a meaningful existence, Ecc. 6:10-7:14 begins in a fashion that leaves the reader thinking that man is indeed a totally hopeless creature. Ecc. 6:10-12 functions as a concise introduction. Qoheleth begins this passage with an explanation of why it is the fate of man to be insignificant. In 6:10, he states, “Whatever has come to be has already been named, and it is known what human beings are...”. Since all things have already been named, or determined, the fate of human beings is already decided. Qoheleth goes on to point out that humans are not capable of disputing with those who are stronger, which is presumably God, wisdom, or someone divine. In 6:12, Qoheleth reminds humans that they “pass like a shadow” and that because of this they cannot really know what is good. This introduction is important because it opens the reader to the idea that man truly is meaningless in the grand scheme of the universe. It is imperative that the reader realizes this in the beginning because the rest of the passage is Qoheleth’s advice for how to make peace with this convoluted life.
There is an obscure shift to positivity in 7:1. Although it may be difficult to realize the positivity, Qoheleth is attempting to comfort his audience by helping them see the value in recognizing their insignificance. Qoheleth seems jaded when he says in 7:1 “...the day of death [is better], than the day of birth.” The reader must realize that Qoheleth is truly saying that recognizing the certainty of death is a means by which a person can see her life in perspective and enjoy it before it vanishes. This most constructive way of interpreting 7:1-4 considers Qoheleth’s musings as pre-requisites to enjoying life. Basically, you must realize that all will perish in the end, before you can understand that enjoying the moment is all that mortals ever have.
In Ecc. 7: 5-12, Qoheleth seems to feel that he has convinced his audience of the importance of living in the present. In this section of text, he turns to offering some real council for how to heed his advice. For example, in 7:10, he touches on the foolishness of nostalgia by warning the reader not to ask “Why were the former days better than these?”. In 7:12, he says that wisdom gives life. Wisely realizing the fleetingness of life is what enables a person to actually have a life that is enjoyed, to actually have a life worth living.
In keeping with his advocation that man is insignificant, Qoheleth returns the focus to God in 7:13. He says “Consider the work of God: who can make straight what he has made crooked?”. This verse seems to have dual meaning. The most obvious is that humans are powerless and that they cannot effect the will of God. However, on a deeper level, this verse hints that humans and God are not even viewing the world in a common language. Humans find something crooked that God considers straight. In 7:14, Qoheleth advises humans to live in the moment by being happy at the appropriate times and sad when adversity comes. Pointing out the dominance of God is excellent support for Qoheleth’s advice, because it leaves the reader with the idea that living with the highs and lows of life is all the she is capable of, therefore she might as well accept Qoheleth’s advice and enjoy all the fleeting moments that she is given.
Death and Wisdom
The next three verses continue similarly and place sorrow and mourning over gladness. In verse 4, Qoheleth states that “the heart of the wise is in the house of mourning; but the heart of fools is in the house of mirth.” Rather than saying that if we are wise, we should be mourning, I think maybe Qoheleth is saying that those who have wisdom have no choice but to mourn, for they understand the vanity of our Earthly lives. In this sense, wisdom is something of a Pandora’s box.
However, Qoheleth later praises wisdom, saying “the protection of wisdom is like the protection of money” (v. 12). I think this comparison raises an interesting point about where Qoheleth places his trust. Jeremiah 9:23-24 says “do not let the wise boast in their wisdom, do not let the mighty boast in their might, do not let the wealthy boast in their wealth; but let those who boast boast in this, that they understand and know me, that I am the Lord.” I think Ecclesiastes 5:1-7 make it clear that Qoheleth has a reverence for and belief in God, but maybe Qoheleth should take more comfort from knowing God than from his own wisdom.
In verse 14, Qoheleth asks the reader to “consider the work of God; who can make straight what he has made crooked?” I found this interesting because Qoheleth seems to be saying that although God is all powerful so what he has made crooked cannot be made straight, Qoheleth questions whether God knows what is best. If Qoheleth wishes to make straight something God has made crooked, does Qoheleth mean that he better understands what is “good” than God does? I think this is another example of Qoheleth trusting in his own wisdom instead the omnipotence of God.
Wisdom and Women
In this text from Ecclesiastes, the general theme seems to be on wisdom and what is better for man. Qohelet’s ideas are consistent in that he continues to bring up death and mourning as “better” than birth and feasting (7:1-2). He goes on to say “sorrow is better than laughter” (7:3a), and the “heart of the wise is in the house of mourning” (7:4a). I read this as a reality check – sadness and death reminds man of the inevitable destiny.
In 7:11-12, Qohelet praises wisdom, saying it is a good and beneficial thing. It is a shelter (just like money) but possessing knowledge means having the wisdom to preserve one’s life for longer. Qohelet goes on to say in 7:13-14 that man cannot discover anything about his future, so just be happy when things are great and when things are awful, remember God has made it so. I take this to mean that yes, wisdom is a good thing, and can protect those who have it and do not abuse it, yet man should not try to use their knowledge to guess the future, for that is futile.
After establishing wisdom is beneficial, Qohelet moves on to parallels he has seen in his life in 7:15-18. He warns of a life of extremes – a righteous man can perish in his righteousness and a wicked man lives long in his wickedness (7:15). Do not be too wise, or too foolish, for either way will knock you down. It is only those who find the balance, avoiding the extremes, who will fear and obey God sincerely.
Finally, I am a little bewildered at Qohelet’s statements about women at then end of chapter 7. He says a woman who is a snare, with her heart as a trap, is more bitter than death and it is the sinner who will become entangled (7:26). Then Qohelet goes on to say that he “found one upright man among a thousand, but not one upright woman among them all” (7:28). Is Qohelet saying women cannot authentically fear and obey God? Is this a result of the patriarchal society of ancient times or is Qohelet just a bitter bachelor?
Monday, September 13, 2010
Life is Vapor, Enjoy It. (sorry so late)
Ecclesiastes 5 begins by describing the proper way to worship God, with much emphasis on words in verses 1-7. Verse 2 states “God is in heaven and you are on earth, so let your words be few.” This verse shows that God is all-powerful and above us, so we should learn to listen to him rather than speak a lot. Verse 7 says that “Much dreaming and many words are meaningless. Therefore stand in awe of God,” proving that talking too much is vanity and that we do not listen and “stand in awe” of Him enough and enjoy His presence.
The next section would be 5:8-6:9, discussing the satisfaction that man tries to find in the world. These satisfactions vary from food, money, and the other things that we strive to find, yet never truly find the satisfaction that we are looking for. Verse 15 says “Naked a man comes from his mother's womb, and as he comes, so he departs. He takes nothing from his labor that he can carry in his hand.” We continuously try to find this satisfaction in worldly possessions but will only find true satisfaction through God. As humans, we “toil” but this is all vanity when it comes to the end of a mans life. I find this verse in some sense beautiful, reminding me to not worry about the worldly things and to focus more on God. There is then a shift in verse 18 where Qoheleth realizes that it is good for a man to enjoy all the things he has toiled over, even though we will leave the world with nothing, because in the end God wants humans to be happy. He must enjoy the work he has done because it is God’s gift to the world. It is better to enjoy the present than to wonder about the what if and the future.
Qoheleth then begins to contemplate again about the continuing hunger that man has towards worldly possessions and satisfactions. Stating in the end that we must enjoy what we have been given, including the worldly possessions. It may be vapor, but it is better to enjoy a meaningless life than to be constantly worried about the future. So bottom line? Enjoy your life, even if it is vapor.
"with the joy of their hearts"
The beginning of Ecclesiastes 5, Qoheleth presents the correct behavior in worshiping God, but warns against the vanity that can lie within. Ecc. 5:1 states, “to draw near to listen is better than the sacrifice offered by fools; for they do not know how to keep from doing evil”, this, along with 5:2, “Never be rash with your mouth, nor let your heart be quick to utter a word before God” illustrate how quickly worship can turn impertinent. Reverence must be pure, or else you are just listening to yourself talk, which is vanity. Qoheleth goes on to say “God is in heaven, and you on earth”, showing that God is above man, he is the supreme power, and we cannot fool him with meaningless words. This idea is confirmed in 5:8-9, Qoheleth discusses how to act when we observe the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice and right”. He tells us “do not be amazed” or in essence, not to worry when we experience this, for there is always someone in a higher position watching over. God is not just some idle bystander; he will come to judge the oppressors and the violators. I feel as though you would have to have an abundance of faith to watch this happening and believe that a just God is allowing it and will bring the wrongdoers into judgment some day though.
In Ecc. 5:18-20 Qoheleth is saying again how eating, drinking and finding enjoyment in all the toil is what is good and how we should be continuing the days we have on this earth. The last line of the chapter is my favorite though, 5:20 states “For they will scarcely brood over the days of their lives, because God keeps them occupied with the joy of their hearts”. I cannot imagine anyone reading this line in a depressing light. If we can realize that God has given us worth beyond that of the gains from toiling under the sun, then nothing in life is “meaningless” at all, in fact all of our toil has more value then we could ever imagine. I find all of chapter 5 to be the most uplifting section of Ecclesiastes we have analyzed so far.
In the song “Casimir Pulaski Day” by Sufjan Stevens ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EzeW5KoPUI ) it is obvious that he is singing about the decay of someone close to him, and his internal conflict with why God would allow this to happen. In the line “All the glory that the Lord has made and the complications you could do without” I believe we can hear a somewhat sarcastic approach by mentioning the glory of the lord, and this obvious terrible mistake he has made by giving this ill human all of these obstacles that were not necessary. In the last two verses of this song, the singer addresses his own interactions with God, I think he doesn’t understand why God let this happened and is most likely really hurt and confused. I can see how this song ties into this weeks’ reading though, you must have faith in a just God that knows best and will be fair in the end.
"Wandering of the Soul"
Qohelet says in Chapter 5 verse seven to not wonder at oppression/suppression of the poor. It sounds as if Qohelet doesn’t foresee improvements in social oppression. He says that everyone must tend their land in order to survive. He notably uses the word “control” in talking about the land (“he controls a field that is cultivated”, 5:8). Verses 9-12, Qohelet speaks of the futility of the love of money. The purpose of money is instant gratification, but you will soon want more. Money ignites greed in others, and causes the holder of wealth to have anxiety about losing it to another. Qohelet sees it as pointless to have money and lose it never having enjoyed it, or to have money due to God, but God does not allow you to enjoy it. Qohelet sees working and never gaining anything from it as the worst case scenario. He believes the best thing to do is use your money in a timely fashion in a way that would please you.
In Chapter 6 verses 7-9, Qohelet talks of what we have (“feasting of the eyes”) versus what we want (“the pursuit of desires”). If we our enjoying our lives/possessions or “feasting our eyes”, it’s good. But if we start wanting other things (“pursuit of desire”), we forget about whatever we were enjoying and the things we were enjoying are lost…this leaves us with nothing, thus making it all hevel.