Monday, November 8, 2010

The Young, the Wise, and the Restless.

Elih’s speech in 32:6-37:24 is certainly a jolt from the pattern of dialogue. Here is this new, young man who has apparently been sitting quietly but now cannot hold his tongue and has to jump into the debate. Though he is not happy with Job’s responses and speeches, the three friends who have been speaking with Job also aggravate him. Elihu focuses not on whether Job is righteous or not but the nature of Job’s words and claims. He feels they are empty, that Job is speaking without knowledge and clearly Elihu knows best, because “it is not only the old who are wise” (32:9). As Elihu’s speech goes on, it is interesting to note that he seems to be speaking on the subject of the nature of God, expressing many ideas of Christianity even today.
The God of Elihu is much greater than man and responds to man in a variety of ways. God will spare a man from “going down to the pit” (33:24) if he prays to God for forgiveness and renewal. This God does not do wrong, he is just yet not patient for men who cry out only when they suffer. Elihu makes an interesting and notable claim in 35:10-11 – “But no one says, ‘Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night, who teaches more to us than to the beasts of the earth and makes us wiser than the birds of the air?’” It seems that Elihu is disgusted because men who pray to God and cry out to him only do so in their suffering and do not praise God for the good, everyday things in the world. This seems to be one of Elihu’s major issues with Job, that he did not pray to God, thanking him for each day genuinely; it was only when Job began to suffer that he cried out and wanted to speak with God
Another of Elihu's issues with Job seems to be Job's mindset about the effect of righteousness and sinfulness on God. Job has been saying to God that if he just tells him what the suffering was for then he will be satisfied. Elihu takes this up vehemently, asking Job what he thinks God gains from Job’s sin or righteousness. This is the whole of chapter 35, Elihu ultimately telling Job God will pay no mind to those who are arrogant, and that Job must wait for God now that he has presented his case to him.
Elihu’s main argument seems to manifest itself most significantly at the end of his speech, in chapters 36 and 37. This is where Elihu focuses on the mightiness, strength, and power of God, who can control the elements. Elihu is using illustrations of God’s magnificence to reiterate the mystery of such a powerful yet caring God and also to ask Job how he can really expect to get an immediate response from the divine just because he is insistent.
I feel Elihu has good intentions, and was genuine in his speech. He reminded me very much of a “Jesus-freak,” someone who has so much passion that they cannot contain it and must share their opinion on matters of the divine. Elihu may be annoying, but his words should be taken with as much seriousness as the other three friends.

2 comments:

  1. I totally agree with what you said at the end of your second paragraph. I actually thought of that point when reading another blog and was happy to see it in your post. It makes me wonder if Job's lack of appreciation for the things God gave him is the fault that the men have been searching for all along and thus the reason for his suffering.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Elihu's idea about a cosmic God who is beyond humans (37:23), is also seen in 33:12. According to Wilson, God's power overwhelms weak humans, (p. 373). This powerful God does not communicate in words, but with dreams and punishments (v. 14-28) to get them to behave (v. 30). Elihu's version of God appears too impersonal to be taken to court by Job.

    ReplyDelete