Wednesday, November 10, 2010

...wait what?

In Job 38-39 we finally get the response from God we’ve been waiting for…or do we? God appears to Job in chapters 38 and 39 and gives quite a speech. He comes to Job in a whirlwind and lets him know that he is not powerful enough to create the world and all of the things in it. I think it’s kind of funny that God starts out by saying “Dress for action like a man” like a warning to Job for what is to come. He seems to have a pretty snarky attitude when he asks questions like “Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth?” and “who determined [the earth’s] measurements- surely you know.” God’s dialogue in these chapters reminds me of how some parents talk to their little children. When kids ask why they shouldn’t do certain things parents sometimes respond by saying “because I said so and I’m the parent.” This obviously doesn’t answer the question that the child asked but I think it usually pacifies them until the next time. God’s response, although true, doesn’t actually address why God is putting Job through all the suffering. God continues in a rant of similar questions until he finally allows Job to respond.
Job’s response was a little anticlimactic. Throughout the book he’s been talking about how all he wants is a chance to question God and put him on trial. When he gets his chance, however, he shuts up. Job let God’s rant intimidate him into silence. Granted, most people probably would be a bit speechless if a whirlwind started talking to them.
In chapter 42 Job “confesses” that he has been wrong to question “what I did not understand.” This section is a little uncomfortable because it seems as if God, who has taken away Job’s family and possessions for no apparent reason, has made Job feel that it was his own fault. I think God was very strategic with what he said in these chapters and also how he said it. He very easily could have approached him in a calmer manner and actually answered his questions. I don’t like that God seems to be using intimidation techniques to avoid giving Job straight-up answers about why he’s suffering.

8 comments:

  1. I definitely agree that there is a tone of parental authority in God's response. I also am totally with you in that I believe God was terribly strategic in the delivery of his speeches. It seems that maybe God is talking to Job in this manner as an indirect message to satan, showing him that Job will still praise him after all this suffering.
    I think the intimidation tactics God uses is an interesting aspect of the nature of God and how he views the situation and his relationship to Job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that this ending is somewhat anti-climactic, because both Job and God's responses are somewhat different than what the rest of the story seems to foreshadow. I do wonder, however, if it is possible if God's 'tactics' have been at work from the beginning, not just in the last speech. In other words, Is it possible that God had Satan target Job and the whole time planned to restore Job to his more favorable circumstances. If not than I find O'connor's interpretation very helpful. Its very important to pay attention to the language and the claims that are or are not being made.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thought that God sounded like a jerk when I first read this passage. It was like he was flaunting his power in front of Job. But I thought the O'Conner reading was very interesting. I was reminded of the man in "God on Trial" who asked where does all the beauty in the world come from? O'Conner's verision of God still did not exactly answer Job's question but God did show Job that creation is bigger than himself. And maybe (even though God did not come out a say it) showing Job that he, Job, doesn't know everything that goes on in the cosmos is a way to say that Job did not know about God and Satan's deal which is the reason for his suffering.

    ReplyDelete
  4. God does not answer any of Job's questions and instead asserts his authority. This may just be to reassert the idea that God is unknowable, and to question him, while not a sin, is ultimately a fruitless endeavor. The actions of God are just meant to be accepted, if not completely understood. God's speech from the tempest seems to support Job's original reaction to his problem. What I mean is that God seems to support the "the Lord gives and the Lord takes away" reaction over Job's lamentation. This complicates the message of the book of Job to me, and makes it hard to interpret.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is interesting that you use Job's response to God's speech to actually interpret God's speech. O'Conner seems to be keen on interpreting the God speech on its own and comes up with a very different interpretation than the one that you suggest. She seems to think that God's speech is God showing Job the aliveness of creation. Specifically because she ignores Job's response, I think she is misinterpreting the text. In my opinion, you have done a much better job. After all, this is the all-powerful God speaking. God should know how to best speak to Job to illicit the response that he is trying to get out of him. If God was going for aliveness, I don't think that Job would be feeling so insignificant at the end of God's speech. I agree with you that Job feels "tiny" in the end and that this cannot be ignored when examining God's speech.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It is interesting that you use Job's response to God's speech to actually interpret God's speech. O'Conner seems to be keen on interpreting the God speech on its own and comes up with a very different interpretation than the one that you suggest. She seems to think that God's speech is God showing Job the aliveness of creation. Specifically because she ignores Job's response, I think she is misinterpreting the text. In my opinion, you have done a much better job. After all, this is the all-powerful God speaking. God should know how to best speak to Job to illicit the response that he is trying to get out of him. If God was going for aliveness, I don't think that Job would be feeling so insignificant at the end of God's speech. I agree with you that Job feels "tiny" in the end and that this cannot be ignored when examining God's speech.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I also thought God sounded like a jerk in his speech and a parental jerk at that. But I also did not like the epilogue for Job. You should be rewarded for getting as close as you can to cursing God? I don't believe that this was written by the same author

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree that God was making the point that he is unknowable, and that questioning him is pretty pointless. I just don't understand why he couldn't have answered Job's real question. I also don't understand why he had to act like such a jerk about it all.

    ReplyDelete