Does Larry Gopnik have cancer? Was the Hebrew school be destroyed by a tornado? Did the ancient Hebrew instructor get the door open in time? Was that old man really a dybbuk? The Coen Brothers’ A Serious Man leaves the audience with many questions. Throughout most of the film Larry Gopnik tries to understand what God is telling him. He cannot understand why his wife is leaving him yet it seems he is uninvolved with his family. His son is a pot smoker. A disgruntled student is trying to bribe him. His wife wants to marry an obnoxious widower whose wife “isn’t even cold yet”. The neighbor is mowing a part of his lawn. Uncle Arthur won’t come out of the bathroom and keeps breaking the law. All of this is going on while Larry is up for tenure at the university where he works trying to explain the world with physics. Larry turns to his lawyer and two rabbis trying to get the answers to his problems. He gets stories, but not answers. Larry told his failing student Clive Park that stories are not important you have to know how to solve the problem: “The math tells how it really works. That's the real thing; the stories I give you in class are just illustrative; they're like, fables, say, to help give you a picture. An imperfect model. I mean - even I don't understand the dead cat. The math is how it really works”. Fables are what Larry gets from the rabbis and he is not satisfied. On the other hand this does not seem to bother him that much in his lectures: “The Uncertainty Principle. It proves we can't ever really know... what's going on. So it shouldn't bother you. Not being able to figure anything out”. And yet it does bother Larry in his life. Many readers are bothered that Job does not get any answers from God, but Job himself seems content at the end of chapter 42. The quote at the beginning of A Serious Man said, “Receive with simplicity everything that happens to you.” After Larry’s son’s Bar Mitzvah things seem to be going up for Larry and it looks like he has accepted what has happened to him. He gets tenure and has a moment of pity and lets Clive Park pass, but then things start to go badly again when the doctor calls and a tornado approaches. The film ends before these issues are resolved. We’ll never get the answers, God’s not going to come down in whirlwind and tell us the answers (that did not work out for Job either) and I doubt that the Coen Brothers will make A Serious Man 2. The film forces the viewer to deal with not getting all the answers.
After watching A Serious Man, I wasn't so much left with questions, but reminded that there is no fairy godmother to call when things get touch. It is possible, though statistically unlikely, for life to go completely out of control and for everything you touch to break.
ReplyDeleteI like your reference to Larry's acceptance of certain "uncertanties," but those are things he has under his control. He can explain the Uncertainty Principal neatly in the chalkboard, but he cannot understand and (understandably) cannot accept that his life recently does not make any coherent sense.
I'm glad you mentioned the opening short film because I think that the moment when the old man/dybbuk is leaving, and the husband and wife are just staring as he leaves, is a moment that characterizes the whole movie, as well as the book of Job. It's that moment of intense uncertainty, when God's answer and No answer become the same thing. The emotional state of this moment is what the movie and the book of Job are all about, because its themoment when God and things of ultimate concern come most into question.
ReplyDeleteI really appreciated your take on the interplay between Larry's life and philosophy as a physics professor and the way things play out in his personal life. I'm curious as to whether you see a connection between the tornado at the Hebrew school and the theophany
ReplyDeletewhirlwind/storm/tornado in the last few chapters of Job?