Wednesday, November 17, 2010

"Recieve with simplicity, everything that happens to you."

“A Serious Man”, directed by Ethan and Joel Coen, is a dark comedy about the unraveling of the Jewish Professor Lawrence ‘Larry’ Gopnik’s (Michael Stuhlbarg) life after a series of unfortunate events. Larry thinks he is happy with his life but looking back at the course of events, that were begining to pile up, he realizes he really was not. His son, Danny (Aaron Wolff) is a pot head and even decides to smoke before his own bar-mitzvah, his daughter, Sarah (Jessica McManus), is more concerned with her hair and stealing money from her father for a nose job than what is going on with her own family. Quite suddenly, his wife, Judith (Sari Lennick) informs him that she has been having an intimate relationship with Sy Ableman (Fred Melamed) and no longer wants to be married to Larry. Uncle Arthur (Richard Kind), Larry’s brother, is a very timid, awkward man with a brilliant mind but is unwanted in the Gopnik household and is causing Larry lots of money due to getting in trouble with the law.

Watching “A Serious Man” could be compared to "watching the book" of Job. Both the lives of Job and Larry had been average and in Job’s case considered great before each set of events impacted and almost ruined both of their lives, and arguably ruined Larry’s life. The only difference between Job’s life and Larry’s is Job was forgiven and got his life back together while Larry continued to receive bad news from his doctor even after the movie had ended. The end of both Job and “A Serious Man” leaves us with one similarity, questions. We know neither the answers to the questions that Job seeks, what happens to Larry, if the Jewish school and Larry’s son are okay. Learning that questions are mostly unanswerable, is the main lesson that we learn from the Job and "A Serious Man".

2 comments:

  1. I agreed with the similarity of the questioning in both A Serious Man and in the book of Job. I don't think that Job or Larry ever really got the answers that they were looking for and, as the audience, both are unsatisfying and unsettling for this very reason. In the end, though Job's trials are worse than Larry's, he seems to get the better end of the deal. His questions don't get answered but he does get his life back. Larry, on the other hand, never gets the peace that Job supposedly does.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Overall I agree with you, but I don't think that Job and Larry's life were that similar and "average". Larry's, yes, was average, but Job's was extravagant and luxurious. And I can't tell if you are comparing Job and Larry directly, or just their somewhat similar situations? If you are I disagree, I think that Job and Larry act and behave very differently.

    I do agree with what you said about the ending of both the movie and Job, they do leave with some uncertainty. But, are the questions really unanswerable, or are they just unknowable by us?

    ReplyDelete