It’s hard not to feel a certain sense of unfulfillment when reading the end of Job. The text ends as it began, with a section of narrative text. The problem with these narrative texts is their simplicity, which undercut the complex, reasoned dialogues that came before. After over 40 chapters of confronting some of the most difficult philosophical questions known to man, the text delivers an ending that’s anticlimactic and full of logical holes. After God confronts Job and Job humbles himself before God, God chastises Job’s friends and gives Job back twice the possessions he had before. Job has many beautiful children and lives a long, happy life. The end. It’s the kind of out-of-nowhere happy ending that recalls a Hollywood script doctor changing the ending of an art film after bad test screenings.
Clearly, Robert Frost was not a fan of the ending either. In “The Masque of Reason”, Robert Frost creates a forty-third chapter of Job, one allows him to give Job some closure. Job and his wife have lived for a thousand years and are enjoying themselves outside their home. They then see a figure get stuck and then free himself from a tree. This figure turns out to be God, who wants to talk to Job and give him a long overdue apology. Job and his wife, though, won’t let him get off that easily. After Job’s wife barrages God with questions and Job sends her away, Job gets to ask God face to face the question that has bothered him his entire life. Why? Why did God feel the need to make Job’s life difficult? God intends to explain this by talking about the philosophical importance of Job’s ordeal. God claimed that Job’s suffering freed God from acting according to strict cause and effect models of reward and punishment. It made man learn to accept the apparent lack of reason in the world. Job doesn’t buy it, though. To Job, those are the after effects. He wants the original reason that he chose Job. God’s answer, he was trying to impress the devil as chapter 1 and 2 of Job claim. It’s somewhat underwhelming for Job. It’s also a disappointingly human. Maybe that’s the moral of this story, God doesn’t offer answers in real life, and if he did, they would be destined to disappoint. The biblical figure of Job perfectly illustrates this problem, which is why Robert Frost used him to address it.
"Maybe that’s the moral of this story, God doesn’t offer answers in real life, and if he did, they would be destined to disappoint." I agree with this wholeheartedly, though sometimes it's difficult to accept. I like that you made this point because it echoes one of my views of faith that is illustrated in Job: We can't understand God. If God could be easily understood by man, how could he be God? A God that is simple enough for man to wrap its mind around is likely to be a God that is the product of man's mind. I think one of the messages of Job is saying the same thing: God cannot be understood and this, in a sense, is how we should understand the nature of God.
ReplyDeleteI very much agree that God is an idea that cannot be easily understood, and if God could be understood He is most likely a fabrication of man. However, I still don't like that Job does not get an answer in the book. That is where Frost comes in and tries to give us an answer. I like you interpretation of the Frost and i really like that story.
ReplyDeleteI really like the way that this 'forty-third chapter' has God admitting his reasons for choosing Job. It seemed to me that God's speech in the whirlwind at the end of Job completely ignored God's actions and decisions in the first 2 chapters. This, while ultimately unsatisfying and perhaps disillusioning for Job, seems to be a more consistent interpretation of the God of Job.
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree that God cannot be understood by man. I also think that Job shows us that this is ok. I think that's is the best thing about the book. It gives us room to question God. However, I do wish Job actually got an answer from God.
ReplyDeleteI also agree that we can never get satisfactory answers about God or much else. Most "why" questions humans ask can't have a satisfying answer. Even if science answers how the Universe was formed I don't think it will ever be to answer why the universe exists in the first place. The answer Job and humans have to settle for is basically "it is what it is". Little kids keep asking why after every answer they get. The answer is never satisfying. Although I think that Job deserved to know about God's bet.
ReplyDeleteI suppose I agree that we can't understand God and that most of our questions can't be answered. Perhaps it's redundant but I don't get why it has to be that way. Job's story makes me feel like God doesn't have enough respect for his creation to tell us the truth about what's going on. Because of this I find it hard to believe that God is honest. I think that if God had just kept it real from the beginning our questions could be answered and people would have more reason to believe.
ReplyDelete