Monday, November 15, 2010

Job 42:7-17 :: God Seeks Unity with his Opposite

The South Park episode we watched awhile ago, where Kyle's parents visit their sick child in the hospital, is still such a good example of a contradictory interpretation of Job, when compared to the message God himself was trying to get across to humans. In the episode, Kyle's parents tell Kyle about Job, who, since he was such a good man, always praised God, even when God was being irrational and blatantly unfair, (and some might say evil?). To Kyle's parents, such blind loyalty and a personal conviction of God's true (but sometimes concealed) goodness is the essence of a relationship with Yahweh. Job's friends would probably not be heavily criticized by Kyle's parents either because they, like Job, do not doubt God's goodness, though they do doubt Job's. To them, the belief in the simplicity of God and denial that his actions can be evil is imperative.
What was it about God's lesson to mankind that Kyle's parents overlooked? We can start by knowing that nothing Job's friends said was well-received by God. This means that God did not like the qualifications and rationalizations put forth that attempted to put God's means to act in a well-defined box. Though the friends were well-intentioned and thought they were respecting God, they nevertheless restricted him so that the only actions God could perform were good and just.
I don't know what God's definition of evil was, but he certainty wanted the acknowledgment from his human peers that he was just as capable of doing it as they were. Job was a a good man, and yet God tortured him. If we are playing by the logic that God does not intentionally harm good people, then God's actions were incoherent. However, maybe God was trying to prove a point other than the cause-and-effect relationship between him and humans. In “A Masque of Reason,” God is quoted as saying to Job, “The only free will there at first was man's...I had to prosper good and punish evil. You changed all that. You set me free to reign.” (p.4-5) After Job was inflicted, he changed from a man who had a simple relationship with a simple God to a man with deep understanding and respect for the complex capabilities of a God who could operate outside of Job's and other humans' set of presumptions. Job, as an example for people to come, liberated God from being underestimated. God may not desire to punish the good and let evil prosper, but he demonstrated, through Job, that he is complex and encompasses the ability (and, as God, IS) both good and evil. Humans do not anymore possess a capability that God does not because God, as he demonstrated, is both lightness and darkness.

4 comments:

  1. Did Job really come to a "deep understanding and respect for the complex capabilities of God"? I don't think he did. It seems that God strutted his tail feathers a bit and Job cowered like a little child. He didn't learn, he was beaten. If God was teaching a lesson, the lesson was that "I am God, and this is all you need to know." Job learned the "I am God" part and this does indeed seem to be all that he gleaned from the experience. Coming to a deeper understanding would actually require understanding! Job does not understand anything.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the comparison between southpark and Job. What stood out to me was how you rationalized God's displeasure with the friend's arguments. What I would have liked to hear is your understanding of why Elihu did not upset God with his reasoning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like when you said, " Though the friends were well-intentioned and thought they were respecting God, they nevertheless restricted him so that the only actions God could perform were good and just. " I also got this out of today's reading. I never thought about like this before, but I think that one of the lessons we can take from the book of Job is that God cannot be put into a box. As humans, we don't have the authority to place restrictions on God- such as He is only good.. He is only just. I think this is one of the main problems of Christianity today- they make claims about who God is, without examining texts such as Job and Ecclesiastes that suggest that God is not the happy, all-loving God that we make him out to be.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "What I would have liked to hear is your understanding of why Elihu did not upset God with his reasoning."

    Same.

    And I like what you said about how they limited him to only preforming good and just actions.

    ReplyDelete