The film A Serious Man tells about a portion of the life of a man named Larry Gopnik. He lives with (and supports) his wife, Judith; his son, Danny; his daughter, Sarah; and his brother, Arthur. Judith tells him one day that she wants a “get” (a divorce so that she may remarry in the Jewish faith) and that she is seeing their recently widowed friend, Sy Ableman. At the university where Larry works as a Physics professor, one of his students begins to pester him about a failing grade he received. Larry is being considered for a tenure position, but one of the faculty members tells Larry that they have been receiving anonymous letters recommending that he not receive it. Judith does not hide from the children that their parents are having problems, and insists that Larry and his brother Arthur move into a nearby hotel. (Larry’s children seem strangely unfazed by this.) Larry’s divorce attorney suggests that he see the Rabbi. He sees two, Rabbi Ginzler and Rabbi Nachtner, though neither are very helpful to him. He struggles to see the senior Rabbi, Rabbi Marshack, though he is never available, even by appointment. One day, Larry and Sy are both involved in (unrelated) car accidents simultaneously. Larry is unharmed but Judith insists that he pay for Sy’s funeral (although he is already struggling financially). The family attends Danny’s bar mitzvah and Judith tells Larry that she is sorry. Danny is invited to Rabbi Marshack’s office after the ceremony, and he tells Danny to “be a good boy.” The movie closes with Larry at his desk at work when he receives a call from his doctor telling him he needs to speak with him about test results as soon as possible. In a simultaneous closing scene, Danny is shown at school as a tornado is about to reach them.
The movie had a lot of details that reminded me of Job; one of the big ones was how Larry tried over and over to speak to Rabbi Marshack but he just couldn’t reach him, how Job just wanted to speak to God throughout the book. When we finally see Marshack with Danny near the end of the movie we expect some great words to come out of him, but he doesn’t have much to say (of course there’s different interpretations of this, but I felt like Job expected some different answers to come out of God’s mouth). One contrast I saw was the family in A Serious Man didn’t seem to have all that much interest in each other…the kids were extremely selfish, the parents didn’t speak to the kids all that much (for example, we never learned where Sarah went when she was “going out”), and I’m not sure I ever saw anyone really speak to Arthur expect for Larry. Job was pretty concerned with his kids-in his own way-by giving offerings for them every day. One thing I really enjoyed was the story about the teeth. I think the way Larry reacted to it is how most people react to the story of Job…like, “that’s it?!”
I had some of the same thoughts you had. Larry's life just kind of falls apart around him with him not doing anything to actually make it happen. Then when Larry is trying to get to the man that will have all the answers he can't reach him.
ReplyDeleteOne thing i am curious about is what the movie actually means in your opinion. Does it tell us anything about the nature of God, faith, or how we are supposed to live?
I noticed another difference between Larry and Job. Larry seems to take a much more active approach than Job takes to helping himself instead of waiting on God to improve his life for him. For instance, Larry actually gets up and seeks out advice from the rabbis. Job, on the other hand, sits in his ash heap and scratches himself. I realize that Job does get "advice" from his "friends" but this is because they seek him out, not the other way around. Also, Larry hires a lawyer to take care of his property line and marital problems. He actually moves out of the house into the Jolly Roger. If nothing else, Larry does indeed move. He doesn't hear bad news and then stay planted in an ash heap for a week. He pretty much goes on with life, teaching his classes and what not. I'm not sure what this means, but it makes me think more highly of Larry. At least, he is trying.
ReplyDeleteI definitely see the parallels to Job, as well as the differences. I thought your comment about the differences in the families was very interesting. Though I agree that the kids in "A Serious Man" seemed selfish and communication was clearly not a big thing in the home, it reminded me a little of Job's family in the prologue. His kids are out doing who knows what, causing Job to feel like he has to make sacrifices for them. I also saw some parallels between the wives - both were exasperated with their husbands' reactions to events and just complicated things.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Job and Larry's life have several parallels. One thing I thought about was the role of Clive. In some ways, he sort of plays the Ha-Satan character. We first see him tempting Larry to behave immorally and after this temptation is when Larry's life starts to fall apart. Like Job, Larry is dealing with the temptation to sin under the pressure of great suffering. However, unlike Job, Larry gives into his tempter and changes the grade, which immediately leads to dramatically worse consequences. It seems like both Job and Larry were being tested by God/Satan but Job passed and Larry failed. I also found it interesting that the one time Larry really fights back against Clive/Ha-Satan, one of his sufferings is immediately alleviated (the death of Sy Ableman). Though Larry has to pay for the funeral, he gets his wife back, which is one of the few uplifting moments in the film.
ReplyDelete