Monday, November 8, 2010

Elihu, who are you?

Job 32-37 consists of Elihu’s criticism of both Job and his friends. Elihu’s section is particularly interesting because it seems to come out of nowhere. Throughout the book of Job, the only characters mentioned as being present for the conversation are Job, Eliphaz, Zophar and Bildad. Suddenly, this new character Elihu chimes in. Where did he come from? Based on Elihu’s monologue, especially in chapters 32 and 33, I interpreted this section as something of a commentary that was added to the book at a later time, similar to the epilogue of Ecclesiastes.

Elihu begins by reproaching Job’s friends for their judgment of Job. Elihu is angry with the friends because “they had found no answer, though they declared Job to be in the wrong” (3). Elihu criticizes Job’s friends for passing judgment on Job despite the fact that they have no explanation to offer him. However, this is not the only aspect of the situation that upsets him. Elihu is also angry that he has waited to address Job because the friends are older than himself, and yet they offer no wisdom. Elihu asks “am I to wait, because they do not speak, because they stand there, and answer no more?” (16). I believe this points to Elihu being a reader of Job who is frustrated by the response of the friends. Elihu has been reading Job, patiently waiting for an answer from these wise Scripture characters and eventually finds that there is none. Frustrated, Elihu states “it is not the old that are wise, nor the aged that understand what is right” (9). Elihu believes that even though the trial of Job occurred in the past, he still has a right to state his opinion on the matter, saying “truly it is the spirit in a mortal, the breath of the Almighty, that makes for understanding” (8). Because Elihu was created by God, he has an equal claim in this debate about the nature of God. Elihu further argues his right in chapter 33 by declaring that “the spirit of God has made me, and the breath of the Almighty gives me life” (4). Elihu believes that the spirit of God in him allows him to argue against Job and his friends and to put himself in Job’s story.

Despite this, Elihu’s answer seems to be that there is not answer. In the rest of his section, he reprimands Job for belittling God and basically says that God is so powerful and glorious that whatever he does must be right. I am not entirely sure how different Elihu’s argument is from anything else that has been said in Job. However, I do find it interesting that his commentary seems to have been added at a later time.

3 comments:

  1. I like your idea that Elihu might be the first reader of Job and his response. I also agree with you that he does not really provide an answer.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I found it interesting reading your reason why this passage was added at a later time. However, I don't think that it was added at a later time. If Elihu felt that he should add something, then it should have been so insightful that Job's questions were answered. Elihu just restates what the other friends have said. Why would a person add something in later, if their addition didn't solve any problems or answer any questions? I have to agree more with Melody saying that Elihu didn't speak for so long because of his reverence and loyalty to his traditional views.

    ReplyDelete
  3. That Elihu's commentary was added at a later point would explain it's sudden appearance, but would serve as an underwhelming addition. Elihu didn't seem to add much to the argument or persuade Job's view of God. If his section was added, it seems to be more to the advantage of the reader to hear another viewpoint, than a contribution to Job, the character in the story.

    ReplyDelete