Wednesday, August 25, 2010

So this is different...

Although I am the son of a preacher man, I cannot not even pretend to be extremely well versed in the bible. The book of Ecclesiastes shares several similarities with an Alanis Morisette album. It starts with the blatant declaration of the futility of everything. With such a broad and inclusive statement, I was expecting more than mere speculation for the lack of impact we, as humans, will make. With further reading, I was intrigued with the gloom and foreboding nature of the book. It was like someone took away this guy’s antidepressants and made him watch the Diary of Anne Frank. Ecclesiastes raises several questions, which I was told never to have as a good Christian boy. Why seek out knowledge, why seek pleasure, why work? With these questions now raised, there now exists the need to answer them, which I am having a few issues doing.

One of the main issues that I had with the book, upon first glance, was the conflict between the idea of loving God and fearing God. It leads to the question, ‘which is more powerful, fear or love.’ Unlike much of the rest of the New Testament, Ecclesiastes lends itself to the side of fear. In my experience, church and organized Christian worship have always taught that Jesus died for our sins so that there is hope for an eternal life in Heaven. In all honesty, I have always thought of New Testament God to be more forgiving and loving than Old Testament God. The book of Ecclesiastes seems to not only question this idea, but contradict it as well by insisting on life’s lack of purpose and fulfillment without God.

Upon further examination, however, it would appear that the point that is being made is that mankind can have no fulfillment without God’s love. If you approach it from that angle, the book of Ecclesiastes is much less contradictory to the rest of the New Testament. I am however still struck by the Old Testament manner in which the message is delivered, a sort of ‘love or be forsaken NOW’ manner.

3 comments:

  1. Just to clarify, Ecclesiastes is in the Old Testament (Hebrew Bible). Its closest "relatives" amongst the books of the OT are Proverbs and Job. The theological position of Ecclesiastes relative to other books will be an important question. How does Qohelet's God compare to the God of Proverbs? Or the God of Genesis? (Or the God of Jesus for that matter). Where does Qohelet's voice fit into the scriptural witness to the God of faith, if at all?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fear, you say? What about 9:1-11, especially the beautiful 9:7?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have no excuse for thinking it was in the new testament, other than the fact that I was having a brain spasm. I am... shame faced.

    ReplyDelete