Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Not Pie in the Sky

“The making of many books is without limit, and much study is wearying of the flesh.” (Ecclesiastes 12:12)

Once I too was very weary of all philosophical or religious writing. So much of that genre feels irrelevant, unproductive. Then I read Ecclesiastes, and found it more immediately practical than a cookbook or manual. Wow!

It reads like a (meandering) account of a (relatively) scientific investigation into a problem, the problem of being a living human being, regularly confronted by "vexation of the spirit." The central question: "What's the point?" (1:3)

Ecclesiastes yields some practical advice on this. Here is what I think it is right now:
  • The trajectory of the world over time is immutable, having been fixed beforehand by its Creator (3:1-8). It is also too complicated to be understood by the humans within it.
  • Thus humans can never reliably control, understand, or predict their world.
  • Sadly, it is their nature is to attempt just that! (3:10-11)
  • As a result, human pleasure and happiness (like life itself) is fleeting.
  • These are universal truths. They can be shown by reproducible experiment (2:1-16).
  • Paradoxically, these statements do represent some weird indirect understanding by humans of their world**, and by living according to this wisdom rather than vainly struggling against it, they can minimize their suffering.
  • But there's a catch: since being lucky enough to uncover and successfully apply this wisdom is itself a worldly activity, subject to the same preordained, unpredictable will of the Creator as all other goals (2:24-26, 7:6-7). So good luck, schmuck.***

I think as a practical work it successful. I have now often read it in times of trouble. I still don't fully get it though. I keep finding new things to puzzle over in it, like a good painting.

(**: The way Koheleth puts it bothers me. It sounds to me like he is assuming that the way this wisdom is distributed to people is that the person who "pleases" the Creator gets the wisdom and the one who "displeases" Him gets punished with the "urge to gather and amass." This sounds suspiciously circular.)

(***: It's hard for me to read Ecclesiastes for long without running again and again into circular/self-referential "paradoxes" like that one! It must not just be me, though; I think I saw a remark to that effect in the introduction to one of our textbooks-- but of course I would have, since "there is nothing new under the sun"... see how easy it is to fall down that rabbit hole?)

(By the way, what does everyone think of 12:9-13? I think it feels tacked on, trivializing the rest of the work, and patronizing the audience. (though the actual message seems consistent with the rest) It seems almost like a disclaimer from worried authorities saying "Hey, in case that was too confusing, he was just saying you should follow the rules. Oh that crazy Koheleth, always saying his sayings!" I don't like it. And it spoils the symmetry!)


2 comments:

  1. In your response to your feeling of the end of chapter 12, I would agree that it spoils the symmetry. The footnotes of the Harper Collins Study Bible say that the epilogue is likely written by someone other than the original author and is an assurance to the readers of the text that this very interesting book was "faithfully and honestly written."

    ReplyDelete
  2. You raise some important issues here. Ecclesiastes undeniably has a strong sense of paradox and contradiction (or irony, some would say). How do these function in the text? Is Qohelet preferring one pole of the paradox? Pointing out the paradoxical nature of existence? Waffling between two contradictory perspectives? Or has someone tried to "correct" Qohelet by inserting sayings that contradict what Qohelet himself has said? (And if so, how do we determine which are which?)

    The role of 12:9-14 in the text is also an important issue. As Cayce notes, most scholars think it is of a separate piece than 1:2-12:8. If so, then what function (if any) should it play in our interpretation of the book as a whole?

    ReplyDelete