This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Monday, August 30, 2010
First of all, I really enjoyed both “Thrills” by Cake and “Dust in the wind” by Kansas. I found it interesting that lyrics from both of the songs could be pulled right out of Ecclesiastes. I thought it was significant that “Thrills” sounded like a message straight from a southern evangelical preacher. “Thrills” is pretty deliberately conveying the message that today’s youth is seeking satisfaction in material things but from the singer’s point of view, they are not finding it. In Ecclesiastes 1:8, the idea is the same, “All things are wearisome; more than one can express; the eye is not satisfied with seeing, or the ear filled with hearing”. This line is stating that we as humans cannot be satisfied on our own, or with worldly affairs. In “Dust in the Wind” the meaning is different from “Thrills” but still very alike that of Ecclesiastes. I feel as though this song could be interpreted as both very depressing and hopeless or an almost uplifting and contemplative song, which can also be said about Ecclesiastes. Seeing our lives as “dust in the wind” could mean total meaningless, or precious and fleeting. If the message is that of everything being only momentary it shows us how we should appreciate the time we are given. I think this message can be interpreted from Ecclesiastes if you can make it past the initial bleakness of the first few verses. Brown discusses the use of constant movement in the imagery of Ecclesiastes, in both the water and the wind, and the way human lives move. We are constantly in this circle of work and folly, but we never reach a worthwhile purpose. Brown uses the term “mirage” to describe the progress that comes of our work on this earth. I feel as though this is a very accurate description, and agrees well with how it is approached in Ecclesiastes.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I definitely agree that "Thrills" sounded like an evangelical preacher, not only in the content but also in the presentation. It is straightforward and can very easily be connected to Ecclesiastes.
ReplyDeleteI also like the idea that both "Dust in the Wind" and Ecclesiastes can be interpreted at either end of the spectrum. I think there is a sense of calm, and maybe even peacefulness, when you look into "Dust in the Wind" and how it relates to Ecclesiastes. It's almost reassuring that nothing will last, that time continues to move on, and that there will be generation after generation who will continue this cycle of appreciating what time they have, toiling, enjoying life's pleasures, and getting blown away, just dust in the wind.