Every time I read from Ecclesiastes I ask myself the same types of questions…If he is so convinced that after we die that’s it, why does he even believe in God? Is that any better than chasing the wind? If he believes what he is saying, how is he not utterly apathetic, or at least sarcastic towards everything? I can hear him now… How about instead of ‘life’ we just call it ‘meaningful meaninglessness’.
Nonetheless, I believe this book is of great value to the human race. I think that what the Teacher does well is to hone in on the ambiguousness of things, which is why it’s clear to me that he is not just some depressed, self-contradicting, know-it-all. I think for today’s audience, it might have helped if he had started out by saying “ambiguity of ambiguities, all is ambiguous!” To me is his main point is not that life’s light is sadly brief and dim, but that it must be carefully carried through the vast darkness, never knowing where the either light or dark begins or ends.
Indeed, every time I read Ecclesiastes I hear a man who is confidently dwelling within the ambiguous space between righteousness and sin, between predetermination and free will, between enthusiastic embrace and gloomy acceptance. Despite this seemingly overwhelming gray-area that we all exist in, I don’t think the Teacher was most concerned with making other people aware of their own vanity. I’d like to think that the Teacher would agree with my interpretation, that the universal value and beauty of this text is not its brutally honest realism as much as how it subtly suggests humans ought to respond to ambiguity. By going through a myriad of life’s dimensions, and labeling them one by one as utter vanity, what’s being suggested is not that everything is a waste of time, but that God or no God, ambiguity in human experience is a constant. Humans simply cannot escape ambiguity as long as they are breathing. The skeptic might say ok, but, if ambiguity is a constant then why suggest that something as rigid as the Ten Commandments should be upheld? Well, for the Teacher to remain a truly ‘wise’ figure in my mind, what he must have wanted to convey was that dealing with life requires a high degree of self-composure. The message I hear is that what we do in life places no limit on how we experience life. The teacher is suggesting that what people need more than satisfaction or pleasure, are things like temperance and humility. The reasoning goes something like this: By focusing on ‘what’ instead of ‘how’ , fulfilled desires convince people that they have discovered an unambiguous space that they can stay in forever, even though ambiguity is in fact a constant that cannot in this life be escaped.
Heh, I like the "ambiguity of ambiguities" thought. Hmmm. Conceivably, "vapors" could be interpreted along those lines?
ReplyDeleteBut wait a ding-darn minute, I take serious issue with this:
"""If he is so convinced that after we die that’s it, why does he even believe in God? """
Why are you linking up belief in an afterlife with belief in a Creator? These two beliefs are independent; there are religions and belief systems and people that accept both, neither, just one but not the other, and just the other but not the one. There is no contradiction in accepting one but not the other.
Well said my friend...too personal of a reading i guess. I ought not impose my own contemporary perspectives...
ReplyDeleteI am curious though, was impossible for him to question the existence of a God? If not, then all of his 'been there, done that' claims start to appear empty. How can one suggest that all efforts are ultimately made in vain without questioning the effort it takes to maintain faith in the unseen? Or was belief in God literally effortless for him? I don't know...I'm curious what anyone thinks.
A very good question.
ReplyDeleteMaybe it *was* effortless, and the idea of all "creation" having some Creator was "obvious" to him. Unlike most religious teaching, he attributes very, very little in terms of arbitrary and complicated properties to the Creator (e.g., "He sent Muhammed as his prophet" or "He is composed of three parts, the father, the son, and the holy ghost" or "he told Noah to put animals on a boat")
A simpler, less knowable, more mysterious God like that one is easier to believe in than one with a lot of ornaments hanging on. It seems that pretty much all his statements about the Creator are based on inference from observing the Creator's creation, rather than complex ornamental beliefs.
Ah, indeed, that helps a lot. Very well said.
ReplyDeleteNonetheless, I am still troubled by the multiple instances in which Ecclesiastes claims to know God's intentions. Like in 3:10-15.
Perhaps the most subtle of all philosophical messages emanating from this text is that to "know thyself", one must first know thy God; meaning no two people's God is conceived exactly the same, no matter how much they might think that to be the case. Considering the myriad of all there is that is said to be a part of the Abrahamic traditions, perhaps, Qohelet's genius is rooted in the fact that he was far ahead of his time in realizing that God speaks to each in their own personalized language, because on some level he exists for each as their own personalized conception.
Hah! Maybe that's why he wrote this darn Rorsarch blot of a text, then, huh, so he could get away with writing one piece that would speak to everyone separately?
ReplyDelete3:10-15, good point. I see what you mean-- it really is a difficult thing, because although he says things like he doesn't know what God will bring to pass, that in itself is knowledge. So you really can't say much!
(This problem doesn't seem to bother Koheleth too badly, though, cause he *does* say much)