This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Monday, November 1, 2010
The Place of Questioning and Doubt
One might even expect Berish to completely denounce God but, he does not. Even with the arrival of an angry pogrom mob coming to take his life for being Jewish, Berish does not take the easy way out to attempt to save himself. The priest offers Berish the opportunity to convert to Christianity, even if it is not an honest conversion but Berish responds, “Well, the answer is no. My sons and my fathers perished without betraying their faith; I can do no less.” How does Berish justify the existence of both his accusations against God and his reluctance to leave Judaism for his survival? Perhaps this doubting and questioning, even the accusations, are an important part of a developing faith.
Sam, the defending attorney of God, argues against Berish’s accusations even though he acknowledges the existence of the sufferings and deaths of the innocent. Sam reiterates that God is always just time and time again throughout his defense. However, Sam is revealed to be Satan at the end of the play. Perhaps Wiesel is advocating the idea that questioning God is an important component of faith. So, in the end Berish is right to question God.
God's Emissary
As the trial begins, Berish speaks passionately about the horrors he witnessed as proof of God’s injustice. Sam claims that such imagery is irrelevant and uses slick logic to undermine Berish’s arguments and assert that humankind should accept suffering and continue to have faith in God.
At the end of the trial, when a second massacre is about to occur, it is revealed that Sam is Satan. Just as in Job, Satan plays the role of “God’s emissary” who God sends to “visit his creation and bring stories back to Him” (158). Likewise, the Hebrew word ha-satan describes Satan as God’s helper who goes out into the world to test people and see if they are behaving as they should. This is depicted in Sam’s relationship with Maria. Maria tells of their tryst by describing how Sam seduced her with expressions of love, but after it was over, Sam punishes Maria with insults and physical abuse. Furthermore, he says to her “You cheap harlot, you fell for it, you really did!” (141), revealing the test that Maria failed.
Moreover, Berish remembers seeing Sam before the pogrom and one of the actors also remembers seeing him before a different pogrom. As previously stated, Sam reveals himself as Satan right before the onset of another massacre. Based on this, it seems that perhaps Satan, God’s emissary, has a stronger hand in injustice than God himself. Perhaps we are to interpret the massacres as punishments from God’s defender for the sin that he uncovered while roaming the Earth.
The Trial of God
The Trial of God by Ellie Wiesel reminded me a lot of the film God on Trial. In the text, three men arrive at an inn in the Ukraine on the eve of Purim. They ask the innkeeper if they can perform a play in exchange for food and water. The innkeeper tells them they can perform the play as long as it a trial of God. This trial of God is commissioned because of a pogrom that occurred a year earlier in the town. They decide that the innkeeper will be the prosecutor, and later in the story, a stranger shows up to play the “defense attorney.” The story ends with the abandonment of the trial, due to the need for the men to defend themselves against a mob. There is no final verdict, and the story concludes with Mendel saying that the “ The verdict will be announced by someone else, at a later sate. For the trial will continue without us.”
There are several parallels between The Trial of God and the book of Job. In Job 2:3, God says that Job’s suffering is “for no reason.” In The Trial of God, it is evident that they cannot see why they are being forced to suffer. It is hard for these Jews and Job (and the Jews in God on Trial) to come to terms with the fact that God is causing (or if not causing then allowing) them to suffer for what appears to be no reason.
Another parallel between the book of Job and The Trial of God is that they both contain people who suggest that those who are suffering have done something wrong. In the book of Job it is Job’s friends who suggest that Job must have cursed God , because God is just and does not punish the righteous. In The Trial of God, it is Sam who suggests that all is suffering is “because of our sins”( p.125). The people in both of these texts and the film cannot seem to reconcile suffering with a just God. Unfortunately, after reading both of these texts and the seeing this film, I have a feeling that the question of suffering is one which will never be able to answer.
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
How Redundant
Although it’s kind of boring I think the repetition of the arguments shows the strength of Job’s character. It would be easy (and probably natural) to claim innocence at the beginning of an argument in which people are questioning your actions. However, I think the compelling arguments offered by the friends the second time would make many people crack. This seems especially likely since it’s a three against one argument. The fact that Job endures the accusations twice from each friend and still steadfastly clings to his claim shows that Job is a strong man whose beliefs aren’t easily changed by the suggestions of others.
I feel like Job is becoming a little desperate in these chapters. His friends won’t stop heckling him and the god who did this to him won’t even answer his questions. I feel sad for Job and I wish for his sake that God would have appeared after the first round of arguments to explain himself. I also feel similarly desperate to find the truth about what is really going on in the book. I think the fact that God hasn’t shown up maybe says something about how he feels about the situation. I get the feeling that God might be trying to avoid Job and the situation he created because he realizes it might have been too much. I suppose it’s also possible that God is so arrogant and sure of his actions that he didn’t feel the need to explain himself to his own creation. If the first is true, Job’s God has similar characteristics to humans and that isn’t very awe-inspiring. If the latter is the case, God doesn’t seem very approachable or loving. It’s impossible to understand exactly how God felt about what he did to Job. It’s also impossible to know if Job was truly righteous or if he was guilty of some punishment-deserving deed. These impossibilities make it frustrating to read the text because we can never know the truth. Although I don’t usually welcome frustration, I think it might provide a way for readers to feel just a touch of what Job felt during his misery.
I Swear On Everything I Own, I'm Innocent
Job is getting angry, you won't like Job when he is angry.
This section of Job starts with Eliphaz claiming that no man could be righteous before God. "Can a man be of Benefit to God?" Eliphaz asks many rhetorical questions which all sum to "God does not care about you!" This is the same argument we saw from the scientist in "God on Trial" I believe. Why would God make a hundred thousand million stars and care about one man? God simply has not yet noticed that Job is suffering according to Eliphaz, but once god does notice He will do something about it. Bildad does not even think that Job is owed an explanation. "Dominion and awe belong to God; he established order in the heights of heaven." Bildad thinks that God is too busy to be bothered by Job's plight. This only makes Job more forceful with wanting to plead his case before God. Job seems quite upset with God now opposed to simply wanting to be able to state his case. "I would state my case before him and fill my mouth with arguments." Is what Job says he would do if he could only find God. Job seems to think that God has hidden himself so that Job can't make his case and therefore God does not have to answer for what He has done. Eliphaz would seem to agree with the statement that God is hidden but not because he does not want to talk to Job, simply because he does not have to talk to Job because He is God. Job then continues on to make his case about other people disserving punishment more than he does in ch 24. In ch 27 there is a hint as to why Job is so upset at his friends, and why the friends may be punished at the end of the book. In Ch. 27 verses 4-6 Job says that he will never say a wrong thing and this is why he will not curse god or admit to having sinned. The friends have been telling him to speak against God and die and Job refuses because that would not be a truthful thing to say. Job is insistent that he cannot admit to doing anything wrong because that would be a lie.
I like Job's Friends.
Job grows increasingly impatient and begins lamenting the injustice that God lets wicked people prosper while he and countless other innocent people suffer. In chapter 23 Job wants to confront God and complain, but Job can't physically find God to do it. Job believes that wisdom is hidden from human minds, that no one can know. Since job can't see God face to face, he resolves to pursuing wisdom by fearing God and avoiding evil. In chapter 27 Job gives all these examples of him maintaining his integrity. Job says that he will die before he puts away his integrity.
Bildad and Eliphaz also are curt in their answers to Job. In chapter 25, Bildad only had six verses, when before it was in the 20's, when refuting Job. Eliphaz takes the other approach, he is long winded but accuses Job of high crimes and misdemeanours for which he supposes God was now punishing him. Chapter 22 is my favorite of this section. Eliphaz is totally justifiable in his thinking: Job is being punished, so Job did something wrong. Eliphaz accuses Job of oppressing and being unjust to the world and people around him (v. 5-11) and of committing treason with God (v. 12-14). Eliphaz then compares Job to the world of the old (v. 15-20) Here it seems as though Eliphaz might be hinting at the flood (v. 16) and that they were punished for doing wrong, just like Job is. But at the end, Eliphaz doesn't just leave Job out to dry, but gives him very good counsel, assuring him that, if he would take it, God would return mercy to him and he should return to his former prosperity (v. 21-30). Ironically, this is what actually happens in the end.
I believe that the friends are just being themselves and have concern for Job's life. If they didn't care, i don't think that they would waste the time arguing with him. Yes, maybe his friends are a little harsh, but its comes from a good place.