This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
...wait what?
Job’s response was a little anticlimactic. Throughout the book he’s been talking about how all he wants is a chance to question God and put him on trial. When he gets his chance, however, he shuts up. Job let God’s rant intimidate him into silence. Granted, most people probably would be a bit speechless if a whirlwind started talking to them.
In chapter 42 Job “confesses” that he has been wrong to question “what I did not understand.” This section is a little uncomfortable because it seems as if God, who has taken away Job’s family and possessions for no apparent reason, has made Job feel that it was his own fault. I think God was very strategic with what he said in these chapters and also how he said it. He very easily could have approached him in a calmer manner and actually answered his questions. I don’t like that God seems to be using intimidation techniques to avoid giving Job straight-up answers about why he’s suffering.
Get On My LEVEL!!!
"The Lord Speaks" Job 38:1-42:6
In this passage God flips out at Job. God's statements are a series of questions aimed at Job realizing that he is nothing compared to the Lord. The one major disappointment in what God says is that he never actually answers Job's questions. Job does not get an explanation as to why he has been punished by the Lord, and he back's down. I am disappointed in both God and Job in this passage. I think God should have answered Job's questions and Job should not have backed down.
I do, however, like the way that Wilson describes God's apparent rebukes. God is not rebuking Job. The bombardment of questions is the only way that the author knows to separate the Greatness that is God from humanity. God only wants Job to understand that God is so much more then Job. (Wilson 420-421) This makes a little more sense to me as to why God sounds so antagonistic towards Job. Job does not get an answer from God because he would not have understood the answer. The logic of God is too big for any human to understand so Job simply must accept that God is God and Job is not. This interpretation does seem to go back on what we have been saying which is that Job is changing his world view for the better. Job has to back off and stop asking questions because God has come down to earth "like and asteroid, and Job is squished." (O'Conner 172) Job seems to have fallen back into the more traditional worldview, wherein God is always right even if we do not understand why he is right. I do not really like this. I think Job really grew a lot and now has been forced to take the view of his friends who are later severely rebuked by God.
All in all I think that God is a bully in this passage. He does not really give Job an answer and simply yells until he gets his way, much like a spoiled child.
And God Answered
At the beginning of chapter 38 Job finally gets what he wants and God responds to him. God delivers a speech that’s whole point is to prove the inadequacy of humans and the sovereignty of God. He starts by telling Job to “ Gird up your loins like a man, I will question you, and you shall declare to me” (Job 38:3). Gods begins this conversation by making sure that Job understands creation. He uses phrases like “where were you” or “have you commanded” or “have you entered” (Job 38) to show that Job really has no knowledge of creation. God probes Job and asks “Tell me, if you have understanding” (Job 38:4). He talks the sea, snow, light and rain. Just to show his immaculate work upon the earth and to prove that he is the only one with this power.
However in Chapter 39 the type of questions start to change and God starts asking questions with “do you” or “can you” (Job 39). In Gerald H.Wilson’s commentary, he explains this change in the type of questions “to establish clearly that humans have no power to order creation, and that God remains the sovereign in control of his creation” (Wilson 435). In this chapter, we are given several descriptions of the habits of animals. I think that the reasons that animals are such an intricate part of this chapter is because God is trying to show that animals just like the earth are out of human control and that they are a free part of God’s creation. After God is done speaking he gives Job a chance to respond and says, “Anyone who argues with God must respond” (Job 40:2).
Job’s response is exactly what he has been afraid of this entire time. He has nothing to say. God frightens and intimidates him and with God’s looming over him, he can’t get the words out.
God continues on and again say to Job “Gird up your loins like a man; I will question you and you declare to me” (Job 40:7). In his next section of speech God’s point is to prove to Job that he has rule over everything including chaos. He uses two very large untamed beasts, the hippopotamus and the whale, which are according to Wilson “ beasts of chaos” to show that he is the only one who can control them. God ends his speech saying “on earth is has no equal, a creature without fear. It surveys everything that is lofty; it is king over all that are proud” (Job 41: 33-34). Certainly while this description may be still talking about the whale, has other stronger implications to the power of God.
Job finally finds his voice in chapter 42 and provides a much more impressive response than his non-speech in chapter 40: 3-5. Job acknowledges his lack of understanding of God’s sovereignty and chooses to finally repent, which is what his friends have been telling him to do this entire book. He says to God “But now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes” (Job 42: 5-6). Job has finally relinquished his pride and acknowledged God's supreme power.
God's Rebuking of Job's Friends
In chapters 38-41 God challenges Job to answer some questions. A series of questions follow in rapid succession regarding the creation, cosmos, nature, the inanimate creations (38:1938) along with the animate creations (38:39-40:30). These questions contrast God's great power and wisdom with Job's limited ability and understanding. God continues to question Job, asking if Job can truly annul God's judgement, or condemn Him so that he can be justified. If Job could do all this, than God would confess that Job could save himself. Then, God once more illustrates His power and wisdom by asking Job to consider the two great creatures, Behemoth and Leviathan (40:15-41:34). These two creatures represent the biggest and most powerful entities. If a man is fearful of them, how then could one stand against God? After all of this, Job's simple response is humbly acknowledging God's ability to do everything, and that no purpose of His can be thwarted (42:2). Job also confesses that he has spoken of things he did not understand, and that were beyond his ability to comprehend. Having now heard and seen God, Job hated himself and repented.
I could see this being an alternative reason for God rebuking Job's friends. Job has repented and humbled himself before God, however, Job's friends have not done so. They have spoken wrong before the Lord and have not repented or humbled themselves. I don't think that God expected them to know what they couldn't know; rather, He expected them to appreciate that there were aspects to the matter known to God but hidden to man, and these aspects made sense of what seemed to make no sense. Job's friends thought that they knew the Lord and could speak on behalf of Him, but they should have realized that God is unknowable. For this, they did not repent so God rebuked them. But since God was just, He did not punish them for it.
Monday, November 8, 2010
What was Elihu waiting for?
Chapters 32 through 37 of Job contain the speech of Elihu. Elihu and the speech that he gives are very important and very interesting elements in the book of Job. Part of the reason that Elihu’s speech at this late point in the dialogue is so interesting is that he has, until this moment, remained silent, yet it is assumed that he has been there through the dialogue between Job and the other three friends from the beginning. It is only when the others “cease to answer Job, because he was righteous in his own eyes (32:1)” that Elihu speaks.
I find it the dynamic between Job, Elihu, and the other friends to be quite interesting. Elihu is both angry at Job for being “righteous in his own eyes(32:3),” and angry at the other three friends because “they had found no answer, but declared Job to be in the wrong (32:4).” Elihu gives Job and the other three speakers ample chances to make some sense of what has happened to Job and the reasons for it before himself deciding to speak. Elihu in his speeches is a very strong proponent of the traditional ideas of wisdom. Chapter 36 shows the traditionalist view that Elihu holds:
“Surely God is mighty and does not despise any; he is mighty in strength of understanding. He does not keep the wicked alive, but gives the afflicted their right. He does not withdraw his eyes from the righteous, but with kings on the throne he sets them forever, and they are exalted…If they listen, and serve him, they complete their days in prosperity, and their years in pleasantness. But if they do not listen, they shall perish by the sword, and die without knowledge (36:5-7, 11,12)”
There are many different ideas about why Elihu would wait until the end of the book to speak. Some may think that his passage does not make sense or was perhaps added later. I think that Elihu’s reluctance to speak is further evidence of his traditional views and, as shown in the fervor that his speech holds, is part of his youthful hopefulness (or naiveté).
Elihu himself explains his reluctance to speak and his reasons for doing so when his speech begins in chapter 32: “I am young in years, and you are aged; therefore I was timid and afraid to declare my opinion to you. I said, 'Let days speak, and many years teach wisdom.' But truly it is the spirit in a mortal, the breath of the Almighty, that makes for understanding. It is not the old that are wise, nor the aged that understand what is right. 1 Therefore I say, 'Listen to me; let me also declare my opinion (32:6-10).” It is only when Elihu’s worldview is so confronted that he finds himself unable to stay silent: “I must speak, so that I may find relief; I must open my lips and answer (32:20).” Elihu wishes to hold to tradition so much that he waits as long as possible to speak for reverence of conventional wisdom, but it seems that he, perhaps through the hopefulness of youth, has the most to lose when it comes to confronting assumptions about God. When he finally speaks, it is because he cannot be silent anymore and because, in my view, he is unable to question God in the way that Job has started to do.