This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Monday, November 8, 2010
The Young, the Wise, and the Restless.
The God of Elihu is much greater than man and responds to man in a variety of ways. God will spare a man from “going down to the pit” (33:24) if he prays to God for forgiveness and renewal. This God does not do wrong, he is just yet not patient for men who cry out only when they suffer. Elihu makes an interesting and notable claim in 35:10-11 – “But no one says, ‘Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night, who teaches more to us than to the beasts of the earth and makes us wiser than the birds of the air?’” It seems that Elihu is disgusted because men who pray to God and cry out to him only do so in their suffering and do not praise God for the good, everyday things in the world. This seems to be one of Elihu’s major issues with Job, that he did not pray to God, thanking him for each day genuinely; it was only when Job began to suffer that he cried out and wanted to speak with God
Another of Elihu's issues with Job seems to be Job's mindset about the effect of righteousness and sinfulness on God. Job has been saying to God that if he just tells him what the suffering was for then he will be satisfied. Elihu takes this up vehemently, asking Job what he thinks God gains from Job’s sin or righteousness. This is the whole of chapter 35, Elihu ultimately telling Job God will pay no mind to those who are arrogant, and that Job must wait for God now that he has presented his case to him.
Elihu’s main argument seems to manifest itself most significantly at the end of his speech, in chapters 36 and 37. This is where Elihu focuses on the mightiness, strength, and power of God, who can control the elements. Elihu is using illustrations of God’s magnificence to reiterate the mystery of such a powerful yet caring God and also to ask Job how he can really expect to get an immediate response from the divine just because he is insistent.
I feel Elihu has good intentions, and was genuine in his speech. He reminded me very much of a “Jesus-freak,” someone who has so much passion that they cannot contain it and must share their opinion on matters of the divine. Elihu may be annoying, but his words should be taken with as much seriousness as the other three friends.
Elihu, who are you?
Elihu begins by reproaching Job’s friends for their judgment of Job. Elihu is angry with the friends because “they had found no answer, though they declared Job to be in the wrong” (3). Elihu criticizes Job’s friends for passing judgment on Job despite the fact that they have no explanation to offer him. However, this is not the only aspect of the situation that upsets him. Elihu is also angry that he has waited to address Job because the friends are older than himself, and yet they offer no wisdom. Elihu asks “am I to wait, because they do not speak, because they stand there, and answer no more?” (16). I believe this points to Elihu being a reader of Job who is frustrated by the response of the friends. Elihu has been reading Job, patiently waiting for an answer from these wise Scripture characters and eventually finds that there is none. Frustrated, Elihu states “it is not the old that are wise, nor the aged that understand what is right” (9). Elihu believes that even though the trial of Job occurred in the past, he still has a right to state his opinion on the matter, saying “truly it is the spirit in a mortal, the breath of the Almighty, that makes for understanding” (8). Because Elihu was created by God, he has an equal claim in this debate about the nature of God. Elihu further argues his right in chapter 33 by declaring that “the spirit of God has made me, and the breath of the Almighty gives me life” (4). Elihu believes that the spirit of God in him allows him to argue against Job and his friends and to put himself in Job’s story.
Despite this, Elihu’s answer seems to be that there is not answer. In the rest of his section, he reprimands Job for belittling God and basically says that God is so powerful and glorious that whatever he does must be right. I am not entirely sure how different Elihu’s argument is from anything else that has been said in Job. However, I do find it interesting that his commentary seems to have been added at a later time.
The Annoying Brat
The Elihu speeches of Job 32:1 - 37:24 are a sad repeat of the preceding friend speeches. Elihu has apparently been sitting in a corner of the ash heap area pouting while the older men have their chance to speak. In chapter 32, Elihu finally speaks up for himself. Though he thinks he has something profoundly new to say, he is basically offering another long-winded account of the infallibility of the proverbial worldview; he is reiterating that Job must be guilty.
It seems trivial to wade through exactly what Elihu said; after all we have already heard his point of view from Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. The gist of the speech is that since God is just and Job is suffering Job must have done something wrong, because the just God would never allow him to suffer otherwise. It’s ironic that Elihu thinks his speech more wise than the friends, yet he is really just repeating exactly what they said.
Elihu does not only think his words are more wise, he is actually angry with the friends for what they have said to Job. I cannot help thinking about Elihu as the angsty teenager in the group. He is mad at the adults for their “old-fashioned” ways. He encounters something wrong in the world and gets very anxious and worked-up about it. After reading his introduction in chapter 32, I thought he was really going to lambast the friends and stand up for Job. I thought he was going to be a like a modern-day hippie, someone who is a bit counter-cultural, but is trying to stand up for what he believes is right. Elihu is a major disappointment. Instead of being a protestor, he is a weakling. He sees suffering in the world, gets angry about it, and then does nothing productive. He just rants and raves, while accomplishing absolutely nothing. Elihu is not a protestor who might help Job; he is just a spoiled kid who was mad that he did not get to talk first.
Wednesday, November 3, 2010
Job 32:1 – 37:24 :: Another Pesky Friend
Whatever his personal motives, Elihu does recognize one true thing about Job, which is that his friends did not provide any real help, that “there was in fact no one that confuted Job, no one among you [the friends] that answered his words” (32:12). If the reader similarly felt that the words of Job's friends were devoid of truth, Elihu may at first glance appear to be the voice of reason and console that Job needs. But, is the little bit of wisdom Elihu manages to extrapolate from his qualifications any more helpful than that of the friends?
Like Job's other friends, Elihu believes that Job must have sinned and is now receiving punishment from God. Wilson's NIV commentary depicts Job as “a sinner in need of confession,”(378) in the eyes of Elihu. This consolation does not sound much better than that of the friends, and must have sounded even worse to Job, when he was told that he wasn't even receiving the punishment he deserved. Of course Job didn't think he deserved the horrific punishment he was receiving from God, but Elihu went in another direction, claiming that Job should have been punished even more! Only by God's great mercy was Job's soul spared from “going down to the Pit”(33:28). Elihu chastises Job for not having faith in God's unfailing justice and for daring to question God's ultimate authority and judgment. Elihu portrays God as a being who is impeccable, incapable of mistakes, and ultimately out-of-bounds for questioning by humans, especially to those as self-righteous as Job. This may be consolation to Job if he is able to see his suffering as constructive, but that point of view is dubious in the face of Job's stark confusion.
Job Has Become "A Companion of Ostriches"
I'm not sure about this Job guy...
Prayerful Engagement
The best way to understand what I mean by this is to refer to Soelle’s three phases of human suffering. Job’s suffering prior to and during the dialogue of Job 3-27 is summed up by Job’s question to his friends, “Why do you, like God, pursue me, never satisfied with my flesh?” (Job 19:22). This is an example of Soelle’s phase 1; Job is lamenting the fact that he is suffering at the hands of others, and expressing his belief that there is no reason he should be suffering. This lamentation of his suffering halts promptly at the end of Job 27. Next, the meditative words on wisdom in Chapter 28 turn the text away from suffering momentarily, and in that moment Job’s phase 2 transitions into phase 3.
As a transition of character, Job 28 neatly separates Job’s argumentative voice in Job 3-27 from his more subdued voice in Job 29-31. At the same time, as a transition of content, Job 28 divides Job expressing his frustrations with the injustices of his suffering through dialogue (see Job 10:1), from the later Job who ceases to address people, and pleads with God to reveal what his injustices are (see Job 31:5-6). In other words, after a phase 2 style argument with friends the idea of wisdom in chapter 28 prefaces Job’s heightened state of mind in phase 3, during which he has moved beyond seeking the sympathy of peers and wants only to know what he has done wrong.
My main point of interest in this section of the text is that whether the neutral voice of Job 28 represents the narrator outside of Job’s story, or Job briefly getting outside of himself does not matter necessarily. What’s beautiful about Job 28 is that for a brief moment, Judaism’s higher reality of wisdom not only acts as a turning point for the text, but wisdom imbeds itself in Job in such a way that the prayerful engagement with God that is so important to Judaism rises to the surface of the text. This prayerful engagement is precisely what brings Job out from dwelling in his suffering and into the phase 3, the phase of change.