Thursday, November 18, 2010

"Why Me?"

A Serious Man, directed by Ethan and Joel Coen, depicts a man's struggle through life and his journey to understand his suffering and the question “Why Me?”

The audience first meet’s Larry Gopnick as a Physics professors who faces a moral dilemma of whether or not to change a foreign exchange student’s grade from failing to passing. The student, Clive, is very adamant on professor Gopnick changing his midterm grade so he does not lose his scholarship but professor Gopnick refuses. When Clive leaves his office, Larry realizes that he has left behind a large sum of money which is meant to bribe Larry to change the grade. This is when Larry’s life begins to fall apart. When Larry arrives home from work, He learns that his wife, Judith, is leaving him for his best friend, Sy Ableman. He is given no answers as to how or why this happened and is left in a state of shock. As he deals with this, the audience is given a look into the rest of Larry’s life. His two children, Danny and Sarah, are two teenagers who are a complete mystery to their father. Danny is a young teenager preparing for his Bar-Mitzvah who steals from his sister to buy pot and Sarah is the older sister who steals from her father to save up for a nose job. Larry has no connections with his children and suddenly loses connection with his wife as well.

When Larry meets with his divorce attorney, he explains all of the suffering that he is facing at the time. The attorney suggests that Larry should meet with the Rabbi to find some clarity in his life. After meeting with two Rabbi’s and finding no answers, Larry is told he needs to meet with Rabbi Marshak because he has all of the answers. The problem with this is Rabbi Marshak does not do pastoral care. He only meets with students directly after their Bar-Mitzvah so Larry is not able to meet with him, leaving Larry with no answers.

At the end of the film, Danny’s Bar-Mitzvah brings the whole family together. Although Danny is high, it is a moment that seems to bring peace to Larry’s life. Ironically, after the Bar-Mitzvah, Danny is able to meet with Rabbi Marshak instead of Larry. The film ends with scene changes from Danny at Hebrew School and Larry at work. At Danny’s school, a tornado warning is underway and all of the students seek to find cover. While this is happening, we see Larry give in and change Clive’s grade to passing as he receives a phone call from his doctor. The doctor asks Larry if he can come in immediately to discuss some X-Ray’s that he had taken at the beginning of the film. The film suddenly ends with a shot of the tornado coming quickly towards Danny’s school as the students watch. The audience is left with no answers as to what happened to Larry. Was he dyeing? Did he die anyways because of the tornado?

A Serious Man reminded me a lot of the Book of Job. Like Larry Gopnick, Job searches for the answer to “Why Me?” through his three friends, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. At the beginning of the book, the reader learns that Job has lost all of his possessions and his family (1:13-20). Although Job does not find the answers he is looking for through his friends, they are still interested in his suffering and want to help him, unlike the Rabbi’s that Larry meets with and Larry’s family who seems to have no interest in his suffering. Both men believe they have been righteous and have not committed any type of great sin that deserves the suffering they have gone through, although neither is given the answers to the question “Why Me?” I think the Book of Job is more satisfying in the end because the reader learns that Job is given everything that he lost in the end and Job lives a fulfilling life because of this. A Serious Man was more frustrating because the audience is left with no answers about the film and Larry Gopnick’s life.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

...is the movie over?

The film A Serious Man tells about a portion of the life of a man named Larry Gopnik. He lives with (and supports) his wife, Judith; his son, Danny; his daughter, Sarah; and his brother, Arthur. Judith tells him one day that she wants a “get” (a divorce so that she may remarry in the Jewish faith) and that she is seeing their recently widowed friend, Sy Ableman. At the university where Larry works as a Physics professor, one of his students begins to pester him about a failing grade he received. Larry is being considered for a tenure position, but one of the faculty members tells Larry that they have been receiving anonymous letters recommending that he not receive it. Judith does not hide from the children that their parents are having problems, and insists that Larry and his brother Arthur move into a nearby hotel. (Larry’s children seem strangely unfazed by this.) Larry’s divorce attorney suggests that he see the Rabbi. He sees two, Rabbi Ginzler and Rabbi Nachtner, though neither are very helpful to him. He struggles to see the senior Rabbi, Rabbi Marshack, though he is never available, even by appointment. One day, Larry and Sy are both involved in (unrelated) car accidents simultaneously. Larry is unharmed but Judith insists that he pay for Sy’s funeral (although he is already struggling financially). The family attends Danny’s bar mitzvah and Judith tells Larry that she is sorry. Danny is invited to Rabbi Marshack’s office after the ceremony, and he tells Danny to “be a good boy.” The movie closes with Larry at his desk at work when he receives a call from his doctor telling him he needs to speak with him about test results as soon as possible. In a simultaneous closing scene, Danny is shown at school as a tornado is about to reach them.
The movie had a lot of details that reminded me of Job; one of the big ones was how Larry tried over and over to speak to Rabbi Marshack but he just couldn’t reach him, how Job just wanted to speak to God throughout the book. When we finally see Marshack with Danny near the end of the movie we expect some great words to come out of him, but he doesn’t have much to say (of course there’s different interpretations of this, but I felt like Job expected some different answers to come out of God’s mouth). One contrast I saw was the family in A Serious Man didn’t seem to have all that much interest in each other…the kids were extremely selfish, the parents didn’t speak to the kids all that much (for example, we never learned where Sarah went when she was “going out”), and I’m not sure I ever saw anyone really speak to Arthur expect for Larry. Job was pretty concerned with his kids-in his own way-by giving offerings for them every day. One thing I really enjoyed was the story about the teeth. I think the way Larry reacted to it is how most people react to the story of Job…like, “that’s it?!”

"Recieve with simplicity, everything that happens to you."

“A Serious Man”, directed by Ethan and Joel Coen, is a dark comedy about the unraveling of the Jewish Professor Lawrence ‘Larry’ Gopnik’s (Michael Stuhlbarg) life after a series of unfortunate events. Larry thinks he is happy with his life but looking back at the course of events, that were begining to pile up, he realizes he really was not. His son, Danny (Aaron Wolff) is a pot head and even decides to smoke before his own bar-mitzvah, his daughter, Sarah (Jessica McManus), is more concerned with her hair and stealing money from her father for a nose job than what is going on with her own family. Quite suddenly, his wife, Judith (Sari Lennick) informs him that she has been having an intimate relationship with Sy Ableman (Fred Melamed) and no longer wants to be married to Larry. Uncle Arthur (Richard Kind), Larry’s brother, is a very timid, awkward man with a brilliant mind but is unwanted in the Gopnik household and is causing Larry lots of money due to getting in trouble with the law.

Watching “A Serious Man” could be compared to "watching the book" of Job. Both the lives of Job and Larry had been average and in Job’s case considered great before each set of events impacted and almost ruined both of their lives, and arguably ruined Larry’s life. The only difference between Job’s life and Larry’s is Job was forgiven and got his life back together while Larry continued to receive bad news from his doctor even after the movie had ended. The end of both Job and “A Serious Man” leaves us with one similarity, questions. We know neither the answers to the questions that Job seeks, what happens to Larry, if the Jewish school and Larry’s son are okay. Learning that questions are mostly unanswerable, is the main lesson that we learn from the Job and "A Serious Man".

When the truth is found to be lies...then what?

In the first part of “A Serious Man” the Jewish wife says, “Blessed is the Lord. Good riddance to evil” as she shuts the door on the “dybbuk”. Her words create a clear line between God and evil, as she believes that one cannot be a part of the other, which would mean God is all good and evil is evil. The main character in the film, Larry Gopnik, seems to have the same idea about life. Larry sees life in black and white, he is Physics professor but only understands the straight-forward math, not the stories he uses for explanations, he even states while talking to a student that, “Actions always have consequences”. This view doesn’t really hold up as Larry’s life begins to unravel, he starts wondering why these things have happened to him and searching for some answers.

First Larry’s wife tells him she wants a divorce, his children are little monsters, and his life gets pretty chaotic. Along with these things he has to deal with his wife’s other partner dying in a car wreck, and his live-in brother getting in trouble with the law and he might not be getting tenure like he thought he was going to. As a response to the turmoil Larry just keeps repeating, “I didn’t do anything”. Throughout the movie, as things fall apart for Larry, he tries to find reasons why these things are happening to him and what he should do about them. He starts talking with his rabbis-much like Jobs friends giving him advice-but never gets an answer he is satisfied with. The first rabbi that Larry speaks with is the junior rabbi, he is young and tells Larry “all his problems are just a mirror”, the mid-level rabbi tells him some story about a dentist finding a message in a man’s teeth…this doesn’t really make any sense to Larry either. As a last resort Larry tries his hardest to speak with the head rabbi, but the rabbi is always “busy”. He never gets to speak with this rabbi, but his son does. When Larry’s son meets with the rabbi, the rabbi hands him back his radio that was confiscated in class. Like the “Jefferson Airplane” song that was playing on the little radio, the rabbi says, “when the truth is found to be lies and all of the hope within you dies…then what”?

One of the themes of this movie, I think, is the uncertain line between “good” and “evil” and how to apply this to your life. Larry has a hard time figuring out the right or good things to do in his life once it starts to crumble. He keeps saying he hasn’t done anything, probably meaning anything bad, and he feels like all of these things are happening as no fault of his own. He tries to find the answers through his faith and still comes up short. This blurred line between good and evil can also be seen through the behavior of this whole Jewish community. These seemingly devout Jews act in a way that “good” Jews probably shouldn’t, but this doesn’t necessarily make them bad people. As the movie progresses I think we see the characters start making decisions based on what they feel is right or good, and not based on some higher power such as God, because he obviously is going to do whatever the hell he wants to.

A Serious Man...

The Cohen Brother' film A Serious Man, tells the story of Larry Gopnik, a middle aged, Jewish professor of physics dealing with some extremely bad circumstances. In the film Larry’s wife Judith leaves him for another man, his son smokes pot, his daughter steals money from him, a Korean student tries to bribe him for a grade, and his brother Arthur refuses to come out of the bathroom and repeatedly breaks the law. In response to all of the turmoil in his life, a friend suggests that he go see the rabbi in hopes that he can provide Larry with some answers as to why his life seems to have gone off the deep end. Along with her suggestion to see the rabbi, she reminds Larry that their Jewish heritage provides them with several stories of people who experienced the same kinds of suffering that he has, and that he should glean wisdom from the Torah. In this instance, she reminded me a lot of the friends in the book of Job, because she relied on the knowledge that she had been taught in the past. According to her (and Larry’s) tradition, when trouble comes it is important to seek wisdom in the scriptures and from the rabbi. Up until this point, I have not had a whole lot of sympathy for Job’s friends, but the portrayal of this woman in the Cohen brother’s film, made me view them as more caring individuals, than I had previously thought.

Unfortunately, traditional wisdom does not seem to work for Larry. The rabbis are unable to provide him with answers to his questions. Fortunately, he is granted tenure and after his son’s Bar Mitzvah things seem to get better for a little while, that is until he gets a call from his doctor and a tornado approaches the Hebrew school. It is with these things that the film concludes leaving the audience with no answers as to what has occurred in Larry Gopnik’s life. The film’s ending offers what is perhaps the greatest parallel to the book of Job within the film. Just as God does not give Job the answers that he seeks, the Cohen brothers do not provide us (or Larry) with the answers as to what happens in the life of Larry.

Earlier in the film, the friend who suggested that Larry go see the rabbi said, “It’s not always easy trying to figure out what God is trying to tell you, but that doesn’t mean you have to try to figure it out by yourself.” While I don’t think that the book of Job (or Larry) necessarily comes to the same conclusion as the friend, I do think that this perspective resembles something that Qoheleth would say. God may not always give us the answers that we wish he would, but it is much better to try to engage in dialogue with others about such questions, than to go at it alone.

There Are No Answers

Does Larry Gopnik have cancer?  Was the Hebrew school be destroyed by a tornado?  Did the ancient Hebrew instructor get the door open in time?  Was that old man really a dybbuk? The Coen Brothers’ A Serious Man leaves the audience with many questions.  Throughout most of the film Larry Gopnik tries to understand what God is telling him.  He cannot understand why his wife is leaving him yet it seems he is uninvolved with his family.  His son is a pot smoker.  A disgruntled student is trying to bribe him.  His wife wants to marry an obnoxious widower whose wife “isn’t even cold yet”.  The neighbor is mowing a part of his lawn.  Uncle Arthur won’t come out of the bathroom and keeps breaking the law.  All of this is going on while Larry is up for tenure at the university where he works trying to explain the world with physics.  Larry turns to his lawyer and two rabbis trying to get the answers to his problems.  He gets stories, but not answers.  Larry told his failing student Clive Park that stories are not important you have to know how to solve the problem:  “The math tells how it really works. That's the real thing; the stories I give you in class are just illustrative; they're like, fables, say, to help give you a picture. An imperfect model. I mean - even I don't understand the dead cat. The math is how it really works”.  Fables are what Larry gets from the rabbis and he is not satisfied.  On the other hand this does not seem to bother him that much in his lectures:   “The Uncertainty Principle. It proves we can't ever really know... what's going on. So it shouldn't bother you. Not being able to figure anything out”.  And yet it does bother Larry in his life.  Many readers are bothered that Job does not get any answers from God, but Job himself seems content at the end of chapter 42.  The quote at the beginning of A Serious Man said, “Receive with simplicity everything that happens to you.”  After Larry’s son’s Bar Mitzvah things seem to be going up for Larry and it looks like he has accepted what has happened to him.  He gets tenure and has a moment of pity and lets Clive Park pass, but then things start to go badly again when the doctor calls and a tornado approaches.  The film ends before these issues are resolved.  We’ll never get the answers, God’s not going to come down in whirlwind and tell us the answers (that did not work out for Job either) and I doubt that the Coen Brothers will make A Serious Man 2.  The film forces the viewer to deal with not getting all the answers.   

Monday, November 15, 2010

Job with some FROSTing on top

In the beginning, God and Satan decided to put Job through some tough times, and in the end, God alone restores Job by confronting him and his peers. However, the “happy” ending for Job is somewhat unsatisfying for readers, because even though most of the book consists of Job’s begging God to give him a reason for his suffering; the book ends with God giving no reasons whatsoever. This seemingly unreasonable conclusion is exactly what Frost hones in on. Above all, it is God’s apparent lack of reason that I find frustrating, but by creating his own 43rd chapter and illuminating the confusing, contradictory, and frustrating aspects of Job’s story, Frost has helped me understand the book much better.

My understanding of Frost’s take on the book of Job is that what’s most important about the story is not Job’s “happy” ending, but the fact that God pays attention to Job. From this perspective, the main topic addressed by this book is not justice, but the nature of God and man’s reality. This is why God explains in Frost’s chapter 43 that “there is no connection man can reason out between his just deserts and what he gets”. More importantly, this elaboration on Job’s situation is coming from God 1000 years after the situation occurred and still no official reason is given to Job. So, even though God never gives people reasons, what’s significant is that God is engaged with people constantly; especially those, like Job, who reciprocate his engagement. From this view, what the book of Job successfully portrays is that even though God seems unconcerned with the suffering of humans, he is nonetheless very concerned with humans. The nature of reality is that God and man are in it together. But Frost takes this further by accounting for the fact that Satan is also in the picture. If it was just God and man then surely, God is responsible for all evil that befalls humans, but Frost offers up the view that evil is ultimately just the dark side of God’s originality. He does so by suggesting that Satan is less of an accuser, and more of an instigator, because Satan is “God’s best inspiration.” What I think Frost accomplishes by portraying Satan in this way is that he, once again, makes the case that Job’s story is not about justice or the ambivalence of God. In both Frost’s chapter 43 and the book of Job, God is explicitly incited by Satan, but Frost makes it possible to read of God’s vulnerability to Satan without necessarily making God cold or ruthless. Instead, Frost’s story suggests that God, Satan and Man are not in a just reality that is to be reasoned out, but in a reality that is open ended and is moved along by the perpetual interactions of different wills.

Job 42:7-17 :: God Seeks Unity with his Opposite

The South Park episode we watched awhile ago, where Kyle's parents visit their sick child in the hospital, is still such a good example of a contradictory interpretation of Job, when compared to the message God himself was trying to get across to humans. In the episode, Kyle's parents tell Kyle about Job, who, since he was such a good man, always praised God, even when God was being irrational and blatantly unfair, (and some might say evil?). To Kyle's parents, such blind loyalty and a personal conviction of God's true (but sometimes concealed) goodness is the essence of a relationship with Yahweh. Job's friends would probably not be heavily criticized by Kyle's parents either because they, like Job, do not doubt God's goodness, though they do doubt Job's. To them, the belief in the simplicity of God and denial that his actions can be evil is imperative.
What was it about God's lesson to mankind that Kyle's parents overlooked? We can start by knowing that nothing Job's friends said was well-received by God. This means that God did not like the qualifications and rationalizations put forth that attempted to put God's means to act in a well-defined box. Though the friends were well-intentioned and thought they were respecting God, they nevertheless restricted him so that the only actions God could perform were good and just.
I don't know what God's definition of evil was, but he certainty wanted the acknowledgment from his human peers that he was just as capable of doing it as they were. Job was a a good man, and yet God tortured him. If we are playing by the logic that God does not intentionally harm good people, then God's actions were incoherent. However, maybe God was trying to prove a point other than the cause-and-effect relationship between him and humans. In “A Masque of Reason,” God is quoted as saying to Job, “The only free will there at first was man's...I had to prosper good and punish evil. You changed all that. You set me free to reign.” (p.4-5) After Job was inflicted, he changed from a man who had a simple relationship with a simple God to a man with deep understanding and respect for the complex capabilities of a God who could operate outside of Job's and other humans' set of presumptions. Job, as an example for people to come, liberated God from being underestimated. God may not desire to punish the good and let evil prosper, but he demonstrated, through Job, that he is complex and encompasses the ability (and, as God, IS) both good and evil. Humans do not anymore possess a capability that God does not because God, as he demonstrated, is both lightness and darkness.

Let's Have a One on One With God

It’s hard not to feel a certain sense of unfulfillment when reading the end of Job. The text ends as it began, with a section of narrative text. The problem with these narrative texts is their simplicity, which undercut the complex, reasoned dialogues that came before. After over 40 chapters of confronting some of the most difficult philosophical questions known to man, the text delivers an ending that’s anticlimactic and full of logical holes. After God confronts Job and Job humbles himself before God, God chastises Job’s friends and gives Job back twice the possessions he had before. Job has many beautiful children and lives a long, happy life. The end. It’s the kind of out-of-nowhere happy ending that recalls a Hollywood script doctor changing the ending of an art film after bad test screenings.
Clearly, Robert Frost was not a fan of the ending either. In “The Masque of Reason”, Robert Frost creates a forty-third chapter of Job, one allows him to give Job some closure. Job and his wife have lived for a thousand years and are enjoying themselves outside their home. They then see a figure get stuck and then free himself from a tree. This figure turns out to be God, who wants to talk to Job and give him a long overdue apology. Job and his wife, though, won’t let him get off that easily. After Job’s wife barrages God with questions and Job sends her away, Job gets to ask God face to face the question that has bothered him his entire life. Why? Why did God feel the need to make Job’s life difficult? God intends to explain this by talking about the philosophical importance of Job’s ordeal. God claimed that Job’s suffering freed God from acting according to strict cause and effect models of reward and punishment. It made man learn to accept the apparent lack of reason in the world. Job doesn’t buy it, though. To Job, those are the after effects. He wants the original reason that he chose Job. God’s answer, he was trying to impress the devil as chapter 1 and 2 of Job claim. It’s somewhat underwhelming for Job. It’s also a disappointingly human. Maybe that’s the moral of this story, God doesn’t offer answers in real life, and if he did, they would be destined to disappoint. The biblical figure of Job perfectly illustrates this problem, which is why Robert Frost used him to address it.

After all the trouble YHWH had brought upon him...

In the narrative epilogue, YHWH begins by rebuking Job's friends for speaking incorrectly, unlike Job, who apparently had everything right and remained righteous (Job 42:7-9). In his commentary, Janzen points out that each of the four times G-d makes mention of Job's friends, this mention is paired with some form of praise for Job's righteousness (263). G-d's dealing with the friends in this passage does not appear to connect very well to the narrative. It seems that G-d has done what the friends have said he would do, and yet G-d says that they spoke incorrectly. Janzen deals with this by arguing that Job argued that G-d might restore him because he was just, while Job's friends argued that Job would only be restored if he repented of his wrongdoing (263-264). I disagree strongly with Janzen's argument, as Job explicitly "repents in dust and ashes" at the end of he dialogues (Job 42:6). In the same dialogue, in v.3, Job states that he "spoke of things that he did not understand. Job seems to clearly think that he has done/spoken wrong and he has need to repent of it. The dialogue and the narrative in this instance are contradictory.

Another point which Janzen brings out in his commentary is the absence of the satan from the end narrative. Janzen argues that as long as we interpret the figure of the satan as a kind of mouthpiece for G-d's questions about Job's righteousness (as the Persian root word suggests), then the satan's absence is to be expected. This is because there is no longer a question for G-d as to whether or not Job is righteous (262-263).

This interpretation puts the action back in G-d's hands, as does the narrative itself when Job's relatives come together to comfort him "after all the trouble YHWH had brought upon him" (Job 42:11). In his commentary, Janzen notes a connection back to the law of Exodus. G-d gives Job back twice what was taken away. This is the punishment for a thief who is caught (Janzen 267, Exodus 22:4). This makes it seem that G-d is guilty of some wrong in what he has done to Job, far from the claim made by Elihu, "Far be it from G-d to do evil, from the Almighty to do wrong" (Job 34:10b).

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

...wait what?

In Job 38-39 we finally get the response from God we’ve been waiting for…or do we? God appears to Job in chapters 38 and 39 and gives quite a speech. He comes to Job in a whirlwind and lets him know that he is not powerful enough to create the world and all of the things in it. I think it’s kind of funny that God starts out by saying “Dress for action like a man” like a warning to Job for what is to come. He seems to have a pretty snarky attitude when he asks questions like “Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth?” and “who determined [the earth’s] measurements- surely you know.” God’s dialogue in these chapters reminds me of how some parents talk to their little children. When kids ask why they shouldn’t do certain things parents sometimes respond by saying “because I said so and I’m the parent.” This obviously doesn’t answer the question that the child asked but I think it usually pacifies them until the next time. God’s response, although true, doesn’t actually address why God is putting Job through all the suffering. God continues in a rant of similar questions until he finally allows Job to respond.
Job’s response was a little anticlimactic. Throughout the book he’s been talking about how all he wants is a chance to question God and put him on trial. When he gets his chance, however, he shuts up. Job let God’s rant intimidate him into silence. Granted, most people probably would be a bit speechless if a whirlwind started talking to them.
In chapter 42 Job “confesses” that he has been wrong to question “what I did not understand.” This section is a little uncomfortable because it seems as if God, who has taken away Job’s family and possessions for no apparent reason, has made Job feel that it was his own fault. I think God was very strategic with what he said in these chapters and also how he said it. He very easily could have approached him in a calmer manner and actually answered his questions. I don’t like that God seems to be using intimidation techniques to avoid giving Job straight-up answers about why he’s suffering.

Get On My LEVEL!!!


So, after chapter upon chapter of endless claims of innocence, Job is given his opportunity to address God. Unfortunately, Job had not realized the full extent of having a side bar with God. God pulls up in front of Job in a whirlwind fully stocked with his own questions for Job. What is more embarrassing is that Job cannot seem to find the answers to any of these questions; rather, he just sits there in awe. Perhaps he was expecting the whole burning bush experience that Moses had, or a skype date. Whatever the case is, it is almost as if God new that this type of entrance would have this effect on poor Job. Oh wait. He did know; he knows everything. Then why does God use intimidation instead of explanation?
One of the main points that God was getting at in his address to Job, is that humanity has no right to question his will. “Who is it that questions my wisdom with such ignorant words?” (Job 38:2) Through the means of rhetorical questions and his very powerful manifestation, God is showing Job that He is indeed on a higher level and that Job as a human cannot begin to grasp the span of his greatness. “Who created a channel for the torrents of rain? Who laid out the path for the lightening? Who makes the rain fall on barren land, in a desert where no one lives? Who sends the rain that satisfies the parched ground and makes the tender grass spring up?” (Job 38:25-27) After four chapters of these demonstrative questions, it is safe to say that Job gets the point, men are mud.
It seems as though God had adopted the “I can show you better than I can tell you” mindset when He decided to speak with Job. He got his point across and Job was quite humbled by the entire experience. Did Job deserve all the trouble he had to deal with? No, but he will have to deal with it because God said so.

"The Lord Speaks" Job 38:1-42:6

In this passage God flips out at Job. God's statements are a series of questions aimed at Job realizing that he is nothing compared to the Lord. The one major disappointment in what God says is that he never actually answers Job's questions. Job does not get an explanation as to why he has been punished by the Lord, and he back's down. I am disappointed in both God and Job in this passage. I think God should have answered Job's questions and Job should not have backed down.

I do, however, like the way that Wilson describes God's apparent rebukes. God is not rebuking Job. The bombardment of questions is the only way that the author knows to separate the Greatness that is God from humanity. God only wants Job to understand that God is so much more then Job. (Wilson 420-421) This makes a little more sense to me as to why God sounds so antagonistic towards Job. Job does not get an answer from God because he would not have understood the answer. The logic of God is too big for any human to understand so Job simply must accept that God is God and Job is not. This interpretation does seem to go back on what we have been saying which is that Job is changing his world view for the better. Job has to back off and stop asking questions because God has come down to earth "like and asteroid, and Job is squished." (O'Conner 172) Job seems to have fallen back into the more traditional worldview, wherein God is always right even if we do not understand why he is right. I do not really like this. I think Job really grew a lot and now has been forced to take the view of his friends who are later severely rebuked by God.

All in all I think that God is a bully in this passage. He does not really give Job an answer and simply yells until he gets his way, much like a spoiled child.

And God Answered

At the beginning of chapter 38 Job finally gets what he wants and God responds to him. God delivers a speech that’s whole point is to prove the inadequacy of humans and the sovereignty of God. He starts by telling Job to “ Gird up your loins like a man, I will question you, and you shall declare to me” (Job 38:3). Gods begins this conversation by making sure that Job understands creation. He uses phrases like “where were you” or “have you commanded” or “have you entered” (Job 38) to show that Job really has no knowledge of creation. God probes Job and asks “Tell me, if you have understanding” (Job 38:4). He talks the sea, snow, light and rain. Just to show his immaculate work upon the earth and to prove that he is the only one with this power.

However in Chapter 39 the type of questions start to change and God starts asking questions with “do you” or “can you” (Job 39). In Gerald H.Wilson’s commentary, he explains this change in the type of questions “to establish clearly that humans have no power to order creation, and that God remains the sovereign in control of his creation” (Wilson 435). In this chapter, we are given several descriptions of the habits of animals. I think that the reasons that animals are such an intricate part of this chapter is because God is trying to show that animals just like the earth are out of human control and that they are a free part of God’s creation. After God is done speaking he gives Job a chance to respond and says, “Anyone who argues with God must respond” (Job 40:2).

Job’s response is exactly what he has been afraid of this entire time. He has nothing to say. God frightens and intimidates him and with God’s looming over him, he can’t get the words out.

God continues on and again say to Job “Gird up your loins like a man; I will question you and you declare to me” (Job 40:7). In his next section of speech God’s point is to prove to Job that he has rule over everything including chaos. He uses two very large untamed beasts, the hippopotamus and the whale, which are according to Wilson “ beasts of chaos” to show that he is the only one who can control them. God ends his speech saying “on earth is has no equal, a creature without fear. It surveys everything that is lofty; it is king over all that are proud” (Job 41: 33-34). Certainly while this description may be still talking about the whale, has other stronger implications to the power of God.

Job finally finds his voice in chapter 42 and provides a much more impressive response than his non-speech in chapter 40: 3-5. Job acknowledges his lack of understanding of God’s sovereignty and chooses to finally repent, which is what his friends have been telling him to do this entire book. He says to God “But now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes” (Job 42: 5-6). Job has finally relinquished his pride and acknowledged God's supreme power.

God's Rebuking of Job's Friends

At last, Job is finally given his wish to talk, see, and have a "trial" with God. It is not what he expected. Speaking from a whirlwind, God charges Job with "darkening counsel by words without knowledge". At first, I thought this accusation was directed solely at Job, but then I realized that all the characters darkened counsel, even Elihu. Elihu was the previous speaker, who claimed that he could speak for the Lord (36:1-4). Can someone really speak for the Lord? Job's friends also "darkened counsel" because each of them spoke without accurate knowledge of God. The friends said that Job must have done something wrong, and that is why God is punishing him. But really Job did nothing wrong. The friends argued that suffering is always sent by God in response to sin, Job denied that; in this he was right and his friends were wrong. So unknowingly, the friends all "darkened counsel by words without knowledge". Maybe this is why God rebuked them in the end. The friends were speaking as if they knew the mind of God and all that He does, but we, as the readers, know this was not the case (chap 1 and 2). Job was being punished not for his sins. So in a confusing way, Job was right.

In chapters 38-41 God challenges Job to answer some questions. A series of questions follow in rapid succession regarding the creation, cosmos, nature, the inanimate creations (38:1938) along with the animate creations (38:39-40:30). These questions contrast God's great power and wisdom with Job's limited ability and understanding. God continues to question Job, asking if Job can truly annul God's judgement, or condemn Him so that he can be justified. If Job could do all this, than God would confess that Job could save himself. Then, God once more illustrates His power and wisdom by asking Job to consider the two great creatures, Behemoth and Leviathan (40:15-41:34). These two creatures represent the biggest and most powerful entities. If a man is fearful of them, how then could one stand against God? After all of this, Job's simple response is humbly acknowledging God's ability to do everything, and that no purpose of His can be thwarted (42:2). Job also confesses that he has spoken of things he did not understand, and that were beyond his ability to comprehend. Having now heard and seen God, Job hated himself and repented.

I could see this being an alternative reason for God rebuking Job's friends. Job has repented and humbled himself before God, however, Job's friends have not done so. They have spoken wrong before the Lord and have not repented or humbled themselves. I don't think that God expected them to know what they couldn't know; rather, He expected them to appreciate that there were aspects to the matter known to God but hidden to man, and these aspects made sense of what seemed to make no sense. Job's friends thought that they knew the Lord and could speak on behalf of Him, but they should have realized that God is unknowable. For this, they did not repent so God rebuked them. But since God was just, He did not punish them for it.

Monday, November 8, 2010

What was Elihu waiting for?

Chapters 32 through 37 of Job contain the speech of Elihu. Elihu and the speech that he gives are very important and very interesting elements in the book of Job. Part of the reason that Elihu’s speech at this late point in the dialogue is so interesting is that he has, until this moment, remained silent, yet it is assumed that he has been there through the dialogue between Job and the other three friends from the beginning. It is only when the others “cease to answer Job, because he was righteous in his own eyes (32:1)” that Elihu speaks.

I find it the dynamic between Job, Elihu, and the other friends to be quite interesting. Elihu is both angry at Job for being “righteous in his own eyes(32:3),” and angry at the other three friends because “they had found no answer, but declared Job to be in the wrong (32:4).” Elihu gives Job and the other three speakers ample chances to make some sense of what has happened to Job and the reasons for it before himself deciding to speak. Elihu in his speeches is a very strong proponent of the traditional ideas of wisdom. Chapter 36 shows the traditionalist view that Elihu holds:

“Surely God is mighty and does not despise any; he is mighty in strength of understanding. He does not keep the wicked alive, but gives the afflicted their right. He does not withdraw his eyes from the righteous, but with kings on the throne he sets them forever, and they are exalted…If they listen, and serve him, they complete their days in prosperity, and their years in pleasantness. But if they do not listen, they shall perish by the sword, and die without knowledge (36:5-7, 11,12)”

There are many different ideas about why Elihu would wait until the end of the book to speak. Some may think that his passage does not make sense or was perhaps added later. I think that Elihu’s reluctance to speak is further evidence of his traditional views and, as shown in the fervor that his speech holds, is part of his youthful hopefulness (or naiveté).

Elihu himself explains his reluctance to speak and his reasons for doing so when his speech begins in chapter 32: “I am young in years, and you are aged; therefore I was timid and afraid to declare my opinion to you. I said, 'Let days speak, and many years teach wisdom.' But truly it is the spirit in a mortal, the breath of the Almighty, that makes for understanding. It is not the old that are wise, nor the aged that understand what is right. 1 Therefore I say, 'Listen to me; let me also declare my opinion (32:6-10).” It is only when Elihu’s worldview is so confronted that he finds himself unable to stay silent: “I must speak, so that I may find relief; I must open my lips and answer (32:20).” Elihu wishes to hold to tradition so much that he waits as long as possible to speak for reverence of conventional wisdom, but it seems that he, perhaps through the hopefulness of youth, has the most to lose when it comes to confronting assumptions about God. When he finally speaks, it is because he cannot be silent anymore and because, in my view, he is unable to question God in the way that Job has started to do.

 


Werd Elihu. Werd

Elihu says in this passage what he believes about God's reasons for tormenting Job. I honestly think this is what most people would assume about a God who is supposed to be completely fair and just, so I can't blame him for assuming that Job has done lots of sinning to merit his suffering (as is insinuated). The interesting part here is that we know that Job is, by most measures, a righteous man indeed and does not deserve what is happening to him. Regardless of whether or not he is pious to the point of self-righteousness, he is not an evil man. Elihu seems to attempt to get Job to shoulder the blame for what is happening when he points out that he has tried to justify himself, but not God.
My own views on why Job has been messed with is that God used him basically as a means to demonstrate that everything is a gift from Him that He can take if he wants to. There really for the most part has been little to no correlation between being evil and suffering and being righteous and having a great life (as seen by Job being punished for seemingly nothing).
What Elihu wants Job to see is that whether or not he thinks what God has done to him is just and fair, God does. So Job should accept that and ask for God's mercy because surely he has done some terrible things.

The Young, the Wise, and the Restless.

Elih’s speech in 32:6-37:24 is certainly a jolt from the pattern of dialogue. Here is this new, young man who has apparently been sitting quietly but now cannot hold his tongue and has to jump into the debate. Though he is not happy with Job’s responses and speeches, the three friends who have been speaking with Job also aggravate him. Elihu focuses not on whether Job is righteous or not but the nature of Job’s words and claims. He feels they are empty, that Job is speaking without knowledge and clearly Elihu knows best, because “it is not only the old who are wise” (32:9). As Elihu’s speech goes on, it is interesting to note that he seems to be speaking on the subject of the nature of God, expressing many ideas of Christianity even today.
The God of Elihu is much greater than man and responds to man in a variety of ways. God will spare a man from “going down to the pit” (33:24) if he prays to God for forgiveness and renewal. This God does not do wrong, he is just yet not patient for men who cry out only when they suffer. Elihu makes an interesting and notable claim in 35:10-11 – “But no one says, ‘Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night, who teaches more to us than to the beasts of the earth and makes us wiser than the birds of the air?’” It seems that Elihu is disgusted because men who pray to God and cry out to him only do so in their suffering and do not praise God for the good, everyday things in the world. This seems to be one of Elihu’s major issues with Job, that he did not pray to God, thanking him for each day genuinely; it was only when Job began to suffer that he cried out and wanted to speak with God
Another of Elihu's issues with Job seems to be Job's mindset about the effect of righteousness and sinfulness on God. Job has been saying to God that if he just tells him what the suffering was for then he will be satisfied. Elihu takes this up vehemently, asking Job what he thinks God gains from Job’s sin or righteousness. This is the whole of chapter 35, Elihu ultimately telling Job God will pay no mind to those who are arrogant, and that Job must wait for God now that he has presented his case to him.
Elihu’s main argument seems to manifest itself most significantly at the end of his speech, in chapters 36 and 37. This is where Elihu focuses on the mightiness, strength, and power of God, who can control the elements. Elihu is using illustrations of God’s magnificence to reiterate the mystery of such a powerful yet caring God and also to ask Job how he can really expect to get an immediate response from the divine just because he is insistent.
I feel Elihu has good intentions, and was genuine in his speech. He reminded me very much of a “Jesus-freak,” someone who has so much passion that they cannot contain it and must share their opinion on matters of the divine. Elihu may be annoying, but his words should be taken with as much seriousness as the other three friends.

Elihu, who are you?

Job 32-37 consists of Elihu’s criticism of both Job and his friends. Elihu’s section is particularly interesting because it seems to come out of nowhere. Throughout the book of Job, the only characters mentioned as being present for the conversation are Job, Eliphaz, Zophar and Bildad. Suddenly, this new character Elihu chimes in. Where did he come from? Based on Elihu’s monologue, especially in chapters 32 and 33, I interpreted this section as something of a commentary that was added to the book at a later time, similar to the epilogue of Ecclesiastes.

Elihu begins by reproaching Job’s friends for their judgment of Job. Elihu is angry with the friends because “they had found no answer, though they declared Job to be in the wrong” (3). Elihu criticizes Job’s friends for passing judgment on Job despite the fact that they have no explanation to offer him. However, this is not the only aspect of the situation that upsets him. Elihu is also angry that he has waited to address Job because the friends are older than himself, and yet they offer no wisdom. Elihu asks “am I to wait, because they do not speak, because they stand there, and answer no more?” (16). I believe this points to Elihu being a reader of Job who is frustrated by the response of the friends. Elihu has been reading Job, patiently waiting for an answer from these wise Scripture characters and eventually finds that there is none. Frustrated, Elihu states “it is not the old that are wise, nor the aged that understand what is right” (9). Elihu believes that even though the trial of Job occurred in the past, he still has a right to state his opinion on the matter, saying “truly it is the spirit in a mortal, the breath of the Almighty, that makes for understanding” (8). Because Elihu was created by God, he has an equal claim in this debate about the nature of God. Elihu further argues his right in chapter 33 by declaring that “the spirit of God has made me, and the breath of the Almighty gives me life” (4). Elihu believes that the spirit of God in him allows him to argue against Job and his friends and to put himself in Job’s story.

Despite this, Elihu’s answer seems to be that there is not answer. In the rest of his section, he reprimands Job for belittling God and basically says that God is so powerful and glorious that whatever he does must be right. I am not entirely sure how different Elihu’s argument is from anything else that has been said in Job. However, I do find it interesting that his commentary seems to have been added at a later time.

The Annoying Brat

The Elihu speeches of Job 32:1 - 37:24 are a sad repeat of the preceding friend speeches. Elihu has apparently been sitting in a corner of the ash heap area pouting while the older men have their chance to speak. In chapter 32, Elihu finally speaks up for himself. Though he thinks he has something profoundly new to say, he is basically offering another long-winded account of the infallibility of the proverbial worldview; he is reiterating that Job must be guilty.

It seems trivial to wade through exactly what Elihu said; after all we have already heard his point of view from Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. The gist of the speech is that since God is just and Job is suffering Job must have done something wrong, because the just God would never allow him to suffer otherwise. It’s ironic that Elihu thinks his speech more wise than the friends, yet he is really just repeating exactly what they said.

Elihu does not only think his words are more wise, he is actually angry with the friends for what they have said to Job. I cannot help thinking about Elihu as the angsty teenager in the group. He is mad at the adults for their “old-fashioned” ways. He encounters something wrong in the world and gets very anxious and worked-up about it. After reading his introduction in chapter 32, I thought he was really going to lambast the friends and stand up for Job. I thought he was going to be a like a modern-day hippie, someone who is a bit counter-cultural, but is trying to stand up for what he believes is right. Elihu is a major disappointment. Instead of being a protestor, he is a weakling. He sees suffering in the world, gets angry about it, and then does nothing productive. He just rants and raves, while accomplishing absolutely nothing. Elihu is not a protestor who might help Job; he is just a spoiled kid who was mad that he did not get to talk first.